Meta-Analyses of Sex Differences in Responses to Sexual Versus Emotional Infidelity

@article{Carpenter2012MetaAnalysesOS,
  title={Meta-Analyses of Sex Differences in Responses to Sexual Versus Emotional Infidelity},
  author={Christopher J. Carpenter},
  journal={Psychology of Women Quarterly},
  year={2012},
  volume={36},
  pages={25 - 37}
}
  • C. Carpenter
  • Published 1 March 2012
  • Psychology
  • Psychology of Women Quarterly
From 54 articles, 172 effect sizes were meta-analyzed to determine whether men and women are differentially distressed by emotional versus sexual infidelity. Predictions were derived and tested from an evolutionary psychology (EP) perspective, a social–cognitive perspective, and the double-shot perspective. The data were not consistent with the EP predictions because men tended to respond in the predicted manner in only the U.S. student samples, whereas the rest of the data were largely… 

Tables from this paper

Sex Differences in Attitudes toward Partner Infidelity

  • M. TaglerHeather M. Jeffers
  • Psychology
    Evolutionary psychology : an international journal of evolutionary approaches to psychology and behavior
  • 2013
TLDR
Men, to a significantly larger degree than women, evaluated partner sexual infidelity more negatively than emotional infidelity, consistent with the evolutionary perspective.

Gender differences in response to infidelity types and rival attractiveness

Abstract Some evolutionary psychologists hypothesize that women are more upset by their partners’ emotional infidelity than men, and men are more upset by sexual infidelity than women. In addition,

Sex Differences in Responses to Emotional and Sexual Infidelity in Dating Relationships

This study examined the influence of the type of partner infidelity (sexual vs. emotional) and sex of participant on actual mate abandonment and mate retention behaviors. It was predicted that men

Upset Over Sexual versus Emotional Infidelity Among Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, and Heterosexual Adults

TLDR
There is strong evidence that a gender difference exists in a broad sample of U.S. adults, but only among heterosexuals in upset over sexual versus emotional jealousy.

Perceptions of infidelity: A comparison of sexual, emotional, cyber-, and parasocial behaviors

Previous research indicates that extradyadic sexual behaviors and other behaviors including emotional infidelity, pornography use, and online infidelity are considered to be acts of betrayal.

Monogamy, the Protective Fallacy: Sexual versus Emotional Exclusivity and the Implication for Sexual Health Risk

TLDR
Over one-third of the participants in the study reported infidelity in their current self-defined monogamous relationships yet also reported feeling more protected from sexual health risks and reported less condom use than individuals who defined their relationship as nonmonogamous.

Explaining Sex Differences in Reactions to Relationship Infidelities: Comparisons of the Roles of Sex, Gender, Beliefs, Attachment, and Sociosexual Orientation

TLDR
Results found a consistent sex difference that was not mediated by any other variables, although a handful of other variables were related to male, but not female, individual differences.

Are You 2 Just Friends? Emotional and Sexual Infidelity Across Sexual Orientations

This study examined how participants’ perceived the emotional and sexual infidelity of their partner’s relationship with a friend differing across sexuality and biological sex. Our participants

Romantic Jealousy: A Test of Social Cognitive and Evolutionary Models in A Population-Representative Sample of Adults

Whereas sexually dimorphic evolutionary models argue for clear sex differences in responses to jealousy-evoking scenarios, social cognitive models emphasize the importance of other factors. This
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 82 REFERENCES

Emotional Responses to Sexual and Emotional Infidelity: Constants and Differences Across Genders, Samples, and Methods

TLDR
An evolutionary hypothesis was tested: Men are more bothered by sexual than emotional infidelity, whereas the reverse is true of women, and both genders were more upset, hurt, and angrier aboutSexual than emotional transgressions when rating one kind without hearing the opposite type.

When the sexes need not differ: Emotional responses to the sexual and emotional aspects of infidelity

This study assessed whether previously reported sex differences in jealousy could be accounted for by other related emotions. Participants were presented with hypothetical scenarios involving both a

Distress in response to relationship infidelity: The roles of gender and attitudes about relationships

According to the evolutionary model of psychology, biological influences may be a force behind many gender differences in relationship strategies and responses to relationship issues. For example,

Sex Differences in Subjective Distress to Violations of Trust: Extending an Evolutionary Perspective

Sex differences in subjective distress were observed when men and women were asked to imagine their partners being emotionally or sexually unfaithful. Additional sex-linked "violations of trust,"

Distress in Response to Emotional and Sexual Infidelity: Evidence of Evolved Gender Differences in Spanish Students

TLDR
Gender differences in response to hypothetical infidelity in Spanish students supported the hypothesis that particular infidelity types, which resemble adaptive problems that human beings faced in the past, contribute to the psychology of jealousy.

Gender differences in subjective distress to emotional and sexual infidelity: Evolutionary or logical inference explanation?

Men and women were asked to imagine a romantic partner being sexually unfaithful and/or emotionally unfaithful. Three hypotheses regarding gender differences in subjective distress to sexual and

Sex Differences in Jealousy

TLDR
It is hypothesized that attachment-style differences may help to explain both between- and within-sex differences in jealousy, and a series of sequential logistic regression analyses indicated significant moderation of the sex-jealousy relationship by attachment style.

Evidence for conditional sex differences in emotional but not in sexual jealousy at the automatic level of cognitive processing

The two evolutionary psychological hypotheses that men react more jealous than women to sexual infidelity and women react more jealous than men to emotional infidelity are currently controversial
...