Mental rotation does not account for sex differences in left–right confusion

@article{Ocklenburg2011MentalRD,
  title={Mental rotation does not account for sex differences in left–right confusion},
  author={Sebastian Ocklenburg and Marco Hirnstein and Hanno A. Ohmann and Markus Hausmann},
  journal={Brain and Cognition},
  year={2011},
  volume={76},
  pages={166-171}
}
Several studies have demonstrated that women believe they are more prone to left-right confusion (LRC) than men. However, while some studies report that there is also a sex difference in LRC tasks favouring men, others report that men and women perform equally well. Recently, it was suggested that sex differences only emerge in LRC tasks when they involve mental rotation. That is, sex differences that are reported for some LRC tasks are strongly affected by the well-documented male advantage in… 

Figures and Topics from this paper

The neural correlates of sex differences in left–right confusion
TLDR
It is concluded that there are sex differences in the neurocognitive mechanisms underlying LRD, and the hypothesis that more left-right confusion is due to more bilateral activation (in women) can be rejected.
Dichotic listening and left–right confusion
TLDR
It is concluded that atypical ear asymmetries, as in certain clinical populations, cannot be explained by associated deficits in left-right discrimination, and LRC can negatively affect task performance, even when participants do not have to make explicit "left" versus "right" decisions.
The Impact of Handedness, Sex, and Cognitive Abilities on Left–Right Discrimination: A Behavioral Study
TLDR
An advantage of left-handers in both identifying left hands and in verifying “left” propositions and a negative correlation of LRD reaction time with visuo-spatial and verbal long-term memory was found independently of sex, providing new insights into the relationship between cognitive skills and performance on LRD.
Sex differences in components of imagined perspective transformation.
TLDR
It is suggested that imagined perspective transformations may not draw upon those empathic social-emotional perspective taking processes for which females show an advantage, and the range of spatial abilities for which a sex difference has been established should be extended to include imagined perspective Transformations.
Sex differences in language asymmetry are age-dependent and small: A large-scale, consonant–vowel dichotic listening study with behavioral and fMRI data
TLDR
It is suggested that sex differences in language lateralization as assessed with dichotic listening exist, but they are (a) not necessarily reflected in fMRI data, (b) age-dependent and (c) relatively small.
Distinguishing left from right: A large-scale investigation of left–right confusion in healthy individuals
TLDR
It is suggested that a top-down body representation is the key mechanism in determining left and right, even when this is not explicitly part of the task.
Visual and Verbal Processes in Right-Left Confusion: Psychometric and Experimental Approaches
Errors in discriminating right from left, termed right-left confusion, reflect a failure in translating visuospatial perceptions into verbal representation of right or left (i.e., visuo-verbal
The Bergen left–right discrimination test: practice effects, reliable change indices, and strategic performance in the standard and alternate form with inverted stimuli
TLDR
An extended version of the Bergen right–left discrimination (BRLD) test is constructed and evaluated including additional subtests with inverted stickmen stimuli and it is concluded that this version allows for the differentiation between LRD with high and low demands on MR abilities.
Sex hormones and mental rotation: An intensive longitudinal investigation
TLDR
In this intensive longitudinal study spanning two months, a monthly cycle in mental rotation performance was found among both males and females, with a larger cycle's amplitude for females.
Self-rated right–left confusability and performance on the Money Road-Map Test
TLDR
Although, women showed a significantly greater inclination than men to judge themselves as being more prone to confusion in right–left discrimination, the male advantage was not observed in terms of accuracy of response: there was a significant difference only in the completion time on the MRMT.
...
1
2
3
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 38 REFERENCES
Sex differences in left–right confusion depend on hemispheric asymmetry
TLDR
Both tasks consistently revealed that women were more susceptible to left-right confusion than men, which suggests that the impact of functional verbal asymmetries on LRC is mediated by sex.
Sex Differences in Left/Right Confusion
TLDR
It is concluded that self-ratings on left/right confusion questions, although they yield reliable sex differences, are poor predictors of actual performance on spatial tasks that involve left/ right judgements.
Women and men exhibit different cortical activation patterns during mental rotation tasks
TLDR
The results suggest that there are genuine between-sex differences in cerebral activation patterns during mental rotation activities even when performances are similar, and suggest that the sexes use different strategies in solving mental rotation tasks.
TMS over the left angular gyrus impairs the ability to discriminate left from right
TLDR
There was no overall sex difference in the LRD task and men and women were similarly affected by stimulation over the left and right angular gyrus, suggesting that the functional cerebral organization of LRD does not differ in men andWomen with similar LRD skills.
Right-left discrimination and brain lateralization. Sex differences.
TLDR
It is suggested that the female brain has less hemispheric functional asymmetry between the right and left cerebral hemispheres and that right-handed women have significantly poorer performance than left-handed men.
Is the gender difference in mental rotation disappearing?
TLDR
The finding of a stable gender difference on the Mental Rotations test argues against the general conclusion that the gender difference in spatial ability is decreasing.
Gender Differences in Mental Rotation Across Adulthood
TLDR
The gender effect decreased with age in the MRT, and men outperformed women in all age groups, and gender differences remained constant across age, however, in the error rates of the computer-based task.
Self‐rated right‐left confusability and objectively measured right‐left discrimination
Normal, intelligent young adult men and women, grouped according to handedness, were compared with regard to self‐rated right‐left confusability and performance on three objective measures of
Sex differences in self-reported right-left confusion by adults: a role for social desirability?
Self-reports of difficulty in discriminating right from left (R/L), a measure of the influence of social desirability, and motor performance on a discrimination task (a map test) were compared in
Left‐right discrimination in adults
A questionnaire has been used to survey two adult populations (optometrists and non‐optometrists) in regard to difficulties experienced with left/right discrimination. At least one third of the
...
1
2
3
4
...