Menstrual-cycle synchrony: problems and new directions for research.

@article{Schank2001MenstrualcycleSP,
  title={Menstrual-cycle synchrony: problems and new directions for research.},
  author={Jeffrey C. Schank},
  journal={Journal of comparative psychology},
  year={2001},
  volume={115 1},
  pages={
          3-15
        }
}
  • J. Schank
  • Published 1 March 2001
  • Psychology
  • Journal of comparative psychology
Since M. K. McClintock (1971) published the 1st study on menstrual synchrony among women, a number of other studies have also reported synchrony using a variety of methods. The most recent reports of synchrony come from A. Weller, L. Weller, and colleagues, and their findings of synchrony have been getting stronger (by their own account). In this article, the author analyzes their new methodology and presents 2 simulation studies that demonstrate how biases and errors can produce synchrony as… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Methods for obtaining menstrual-cycle data in menstrual-synchrony studies: commentary on Schank (2001).

  • C. Graham
  • Psychology
    Journal of comparative psychology
  • 2002
TLDR
This commentary focuses on the 2nd of these, recall biases, and other errors that he argued may result from "allowing participants to fill out menstrual-cycle-onset calendars" (p. 3).

Menstrual synchrony can be assessed, inherent cycle variability notwithstanding: commentary on Schank (2001).

TLDR
Research that has used random control groups has found significantly greater levels of synchrony in their experimental groups, refuting J. C. Schank's arguments.

A multitude of errors in menstrual-synchrony research: replies to Weller and Weller (2002) and Graham (2002).

  • J. Schank
  • Psychology
    Journal of comparative psychology
  • 2002
TLDR
In her commentary, C. A. Graham stated that A. Weller and L. weller's later research did not use recall data, but the author of this reply shows that this is not true.

Do non-human primates synchronise their menstrual cycles? A test in mandrills

Pheromones, feminism and the many lives of menstrual synchrony

Since first proposed in 1971, the theory of menstrual synchrony has been haunted by doubt while gaining greater public visibility. Based on a study of women living in a dormitory, biopsychologist

Demystifying Menstrual Synchrony: Women's Subjective Beliefs About Bleeding in Tandem With Other Women

Despite the empirical uncertainty about the existence of menstrual synchrony (i.e., the phenomenon where some women's menstrual cycles synchronize when they live in close proximity with one another),

Women do not synchronize their menstrual cycles

TLDR
It is shown that cycle variability produces convergences and subsequent divergences of cycle onsets and may explain perceptions of synchrony.

Cycling Together: Menstrual Synchrony as a Projection of Gendered Solidarity

Though researchers have hotly debated the phenomenon of menstrual synchrony—women menstruating in tandem when living in close quarters with one another—no conclusive evidence has proven or disproven

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 59 REFERENCES

Menstrual synchrony: Agenda for future research

A critical review of menstrual synchrony research

Human menstrual synchrony: A critical assessment

Whither menstrual synchrony?

TLDR
After almost 3 decades of work, excavated the site and been able to unearth more about the structure of this particular creature, a creature made up not only of menstrual synchrony, but various forms of the timing of spontaneous ovulatory cycles in adults.

Menstrual synchrony under optimal conditions: Bedouin families.

TLDR
Menstrual data were collected prospectively for 3 months from 27 Bedouin nuclear families living under conditions optimally conducive for synchrony: a highly sexually segregated society, standard living conditions, and minimal use of oral contraceptives.

Menstrual synchrony: awareness and subjective experiences

Menstrual synchrony occurs when the time difference between the onsets of menstruation of two or more women shifts such that they become closer. The aim of this study was to examine women's awareness

Environmental influences cause menstrual synchrony, not pheromones

TLDR
It would appear that common environmental influences play an important role in the overall pattern of menstrual cyclicity, although synchrony occurred to a greater extent in some houses than in others.

Menstrual synchrony pheromones: cause for doubt.

TLDR
The recent finding of ‘definitive evidence of human pheromones’ and ‘confirmation’ of the mechanism underlying ‘menstrual synchrony’ is indeed spectacular, but it disregarded the methodological critiques and negative evidence that undermine the original report of McClintock (1971).
...