Measuring Discomfort from Glare: Recommendations for Good Practice

@article{Fotios2020MeasuringDF,
  title={Measuring Discomfort from Glare: Recommendations for Good Practice},
  author={Steve Fotios and Michael G. Kent},
  journal={LEUKOS},
  year={2020},
  volume={17},
  pages={338 - 358}
}
ABSTRACT This article presents a review of the methods used for subjective evaluation of discomfort from glare, focusing on the two procedures most frequently used in past research – adjustment and category rating. Evidence is presented to demonstrate that some aspects of these procedures influence the evaluation, such as the range of glare source luminances available in an adjustment procedure, leading to biased evaluations and which hence reduce the reliability and validity of the data. The… 
7 Citations
Correspondence: A new two-step approach for evaluating discomfort from glare
While the de Boer scale is widely used to measure discomfort from glare, commonly in studies of pedestrian-scale outdoor lighting, its design has several problems that lead to noise in the data and
An examination of range effects when evaluating discomfort due to glare in Singaporean buildings
This article discusses ratings of visual discomfort from glare across different buildings located in Singapore. These data were used to determine if range effects influence the vertical illuminance
Proposing a Method Reducing UGR Calculations for LED Luminaires with Diffusers in Indoor Applications
This paper studies discomfort glare in indoor LED lighting systems and proposes a method reducing UGR calculations. There are several methods for expressing discomfort glare, among which the unified
Achieving Integrated Daylighting and Electric Lighting Systems: Current State of the Art and Needed Research
TLDR
The authors unwrap the research, tools, and technical gaps preventing the full integration of electric lighting and daylighting with advanced façades through the coordination of lighting and windows research activities.

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 123 REFERENCES
Correspondence: New methods for the evaluation of discomfort glare
At a recent international lighting research conference, there were several presentations concerning the measurement of discomfort due to glare. These presented new research data and used the data to
Discomfort glare evaluation: The influence of anchor bias in luminance adjustments
Luminance adjustment is a procedure commonly used to evaluate discomfort glare and the results from adjustment experiments form the basis of some recommendations for limiting its occurrence. There
Discomfort Glare: Range Effects
Forty paid observers made adjustments to the borderline between comfort and discomfort (BCD). A random half of the observers adjusted a glare source with a maximum luminance of 300,000 fL, the other
The reduction of discomfort glare from windows by interesting views.
TLDR
It has been found that an increase in interest in a glare source is associated with a decrease in the glare discomfort, both for a small projected screen image and a window.
Tolerance of discomfort glare from a large area source for work on a visual display
TLDR
The data suggest that the glare threshold should be redefined to consider glare tolerance to achieve a glare-free, inclusive visual environment.
The Effect of a Pre-Trial Range Demonstration on Subjective Evaluations Using Category Rating of Discomfort Due to Glare
ABSTRACT Category rating is a procedure commonly used to evaluate visual discomfort due to glare. One recommended step for good practise in a category rating procedure is to use a pre-trial
Discomfort glare and time of day
TLDR
Evidence of an effect of time of day on glare sensation is found, with a tendency towards greater tolerance to luminance increases in artificial lighting as the day progresses.
An Experimental Study on the Effect of Visual Tasks on Discomfort Due to Peripheral Glare
ABSTRACT This article concerns discomfort due to sources of glare in the peripheral visual field. A visual task is needed to maintain foveal fixation at a known location, and in past studies the
Glare discomfort and pupil diameter.
TLDR
The study indicates that the pupil diameter by itself cannot be used as an objective indicator of the degree of glare discomfort, as the more concentrated the source producing the illumination at the eye the greater the contraction of the pupil.
...
...