Meaningless Happiness and Meaningful Suffering

  title={Meaningless Happiness and Meaningful Suffering},
  author={Troy Jollimore},
  journal={Southern Journal of Philosophy},
  • T. Jollimore
  • Published 1 September 2004
  • Psychology
  • Southern Journal of Philosophy
The theory I will refer to as the eudaimonistic theory of value consists of three claims: (1) that all happiness is intrinsically valuable, (2) that all suffering is intrinsically disvaluable (i.e., possesses negative value), and (3) that nothing else is either intrinsically valuable or intrinsically disvaluable. By ‘happiness’ and ‘suffering’ I mean to refer to certain kinds of subjective states. (Some people, by contrast, mean by ‘happiness’ something like overall human flourishing.) Thus… 
Hedonism and Happiness in Theory and Practice
In this thesis, I investigate several different questions about happiness and hedonism in theory and practice and offer several arguments and theories. In addition to making progress in these
But What Kind of Badness?: An Inquiry into the Ethical Significance of Pain
In this thesis, I argue against a claim about pain which I call the “Minimization Thesis” or MT. According to MT, pain is objectively unconditionally intrinsically bad. Using the case of grief, I
Welfare and Posthumous Harm *
WHEN ONE ASSUMES, as I will, that death marks the irrevocable end to one’s existence, it is difficult to make sense of the idea that a person could be harmed or benefited by events that take place
What do our intuitions about the experience machine really tell us about hedonism?
Robert Nozick’s experience machine thought experiment is often considered a decisive refutation of hedonism. I argue that the conclusions we draw from Nozick’s thought experiment ought to be informed
Nozick's experience machine is dead, long live the experience machine!
Robert Nozick's experience machine thought experiment (Nozick's scenario) is widely used as the basis for a “knockdown” argument against all internalist mental state theories of well-being. Recently,
An Exploratory Study of a Counselling Framework: Four Noble Truths and Their Multi-Interactive Cause-and-Effect
Purpose: The present exploratory research aims to develop a counselling framework based on the theory of the Four Noble Truths and its multi-interplay of causality among the four elements. Structure:
Experience Machines, Conflicting Intuitions and the Bipartite Characterization of Well-being
While Nozick and his sympathizers assume there is a widespread anti-hedonist intuition to prefer reality to an experience machine, hedonists have marshalled empirical evidence that shows such an
What does bodily pain have in common with mental pain? According to “evaluativism”, both are representations of something bad. This paper puts forward three claims. First, that evaluativism vis-a-vis
Life Inside The Experience Machine


Rejoinder: If Grief Is Not Bad, Is It Good?
iF GRIEF is NOT BAD then is it good?" asks Thomas Wise. As his examples show, he does not limit inquiry to nonmoral categories as I did in considering two incompatible but prominent views in the
Is ‘Normal Grief’ a Mental Disorder?
I argue that grief (including ‘normal grief’) is a mental disorder. I discuss the main concepts involved briefly, and state the prima facie case in favour of the view that grief is a disorder. I
What Is It Like to Be a Bat?
Introduction: Thomas Nagel was born in Belgrade, Yugoslavia, in 1937. He came to the United States in 1939 and became a naturalized citizen five years later. After completing his undergraduate degree