Liberalism's limits: Carlyle and Mill on “the negro question”

  title={Liberalism's limits: Carlyle and Mill on “the negro question”},
  author={D. Goldberg},
  journal={Nineteenth-Century Contexts},
  pages={203 - 216}
  • D. Goldberg
  • Published 2000
  • Philosophy
  • Nineteenth-Century Contexts
  • I n 1849Fraser'sMagazine, the popular London literary periodical, published an anonymous attack on the nature of black people under the title, "Occasional Discourse on the Negro Question." The vicious essay turned out to be written by Thomas Carlyle. Outraged by the incivility of its language, if not distressed by the intransigence of the sentiment it expressed, literate liberals in Britain and the northern States in the American Union openly objected to the attack. Chief among the responses… CONTINUE READING
    20 Citations


    Principles of Political Economy
    • J. Mill
    • Political Science, Sociology
    • 1820
    • 3,063
    • PDF
    The Methods of Ethics
    • 336
    • PDF
    John Stuart Mill and India
    • 84
    A Dying Colonialism
    • 737
    August includes in his little volume an editorial in a London newspaper of the day, The Inquirer, protesting Carlyle's claims
      John Stuart Mill: Servant of the English East India Company
      • Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science
      London: Longmans, 1924. _____. Considerations on Representative Government
      • Collected Works
      London: Pelican Books, 1970. _____. Black Skin White Masks
      • 1970
      Mill on India: A Reappraisal
      • 4