Leaving theory behind: Why simplistic hypothesis testing is bad for International Relations

@article{Mearsheimer2013LeavingTB,
  title={Leaving theory behind: Why simplistic hypothesis testing is bad for International Relations},
  author={John J. Mearsheimer and Stephen M. Walt},
  journal={European Journal of International Relations},
  year={2013},
  volume={19},
  pages={427 - 457}
}
Theory creating and hypothesis testing are both critical components of social science, but the former is ultimately more important. Yet, in recent years, International Relations scholars have devoted less effort to creating and refining theories or using theory to guide empirical research. Instead, they increasingly focus on ‘simplistic hypothesis testing,’ which emphasizes discovering well-verified empirical regularities. Privileging simplistic hypothesis testing is a mistake, however, because… 

Induction and Deduction in International Relations: Squaring the Circle Between Theory and Evidence

International Relations (IR) scholarship represents the pursuit of theory about how the world works or ought to work. Yet despite this broad orientation of the field, the process of theory building

Politics is too important to be left to political scientists: A critique of the theory–policy nexus in International Relations

Albeit fashionable in some academic circles, the idea that International Relations theory should influence practice is based on the problematic view that scholars allegedly have a privileged

The closing of the American mind: ‘American School’ International Relations and the state of grand theory

Senior ‘American School’ International Relations theorists — John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt, Robert Keohane, and others — have evinced a growing concern about a rise of technocratic

A Foreign Policy Analysis Perspective on the Domestic Politics Turn in IR Theory

Over the last 25 years, there has been a noteworthy turn across major International Relations (IR) theories to include domestic politics and decision-making factors. Neoclassical realism and variants

Theorizing the Political Relevance of International Relations Theory

Two broad positions—the “gap-bridgers” and the “gap-minders”—dominate the current debate on the (lack of) political relevance of International Relations (IR) theory. Missing from this debate,

Resurrecting IR theory: Editors’ introduction to a special section

As a discipline, international relations (IR) has become increasingly circumspect about the role and explanatory power of theories of international politics (e.g. Mearsheimer and Walt, 2013;

Deep theorizing in International Relations

This article starts from the observation that International Relations scholars do not agree on what they mean by theory. The declining popularity of grand theory and the celebration of theoretical

The Myth of the Eclectic IR Scholar?

What does the decline in paradigmatic self-identification mean for how international relations (IR) scholars think about the world? We answer this question with a 2020 survey among nearly two

US Dominance and American Bias in International Relations Scholarship: A View from the Outside

  • Evelyn Goh
  • Political Science
    Journal of Global Security Studies
  • 2019
This article responds to the Journal of Global Security Studies special issue on “American Perspectives and Blind Spots on World Politics,” edited by Jeff Colgan. It applauds their significant

Micro-moves in International Relations theory

This article posits empirical and political reasons for recent ‘micro-moves’ in several contemporary debates, and seeks to further develop them in future International Relations studies. As evidenced
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 120 REFERENCES

Richness, Rigor, and Relevance in the Study of Soviet Foreign Policy

A short time ago, a group of senior specialists in the study of Soviet foreign policy gathered to assess the state of their field, Though none disputed the view that “we know more now than we did a

International Relations Theory and China's Rise: Assessing China's Potential for Territorial Expansion

Whether China’s rise as a great power will be peaceful or violent is a question that animates scholars and policymakers alike. Power transition theory and offensive realism reach pessimistic

The Reductionist Gamble: Open Economy Politics in the Global Economy

Abstract International political economy (IPE) should transition to “third-wave” scholarship because Open Economy Politics (OEP), which dominates current American IPE scholarship, can generate

What Rationality Assumption? or, How ‘Positive Political Theory’ Rests on a Mistake

In this article I address the reception of game-theoretic methods in political science. In particular I challenge the notion that such methods afford a plausible basis for what is commonly called

International Relations in the US Academy

Using two new data sources to describe trends in the international relations (IR) discipline since 1980—a database of every article published in the 12 leading journals in the field and three surveys

Rational Deterrence Theory and Comparative Case Studies

Rational deterrence is a more successful theory than portrayed in this literature, and it remains the only intellectually powerful alternative available.

Sorting Through the Wealth of Notions

The opportunity to better inform the readership of International Security on the important contributions of a rational choice perspective is most welcome. We and Stephen Walt agree on many issues. He

The Limits of Inference without Theory

In this rigorous and well-crafted work, Kenneth Wolpin examines the role of theory in inferential empirical work in economics and the social sciences in general--that is, any research that uses raw

Instruments, Randomization, and Learning about Development

There is currently much debate about the effectiveness of foreign aid and about what kind of projects can engender economic development. There is skepticism about the ability of econometric analysis

Concept Misformation in Comparative Politics

“To have mastered ‘theory’ and ‘method’ is to have become a conscious thinker, a man at work and aware of the assumptions and implications of whatever he is about. To be mastered by ‘method’ or
...