Law and the Emotions: The Problems of Affective Forecasting

  title={Law and the Emotions: The Problems of Affective Forecasting},
  author={Jeremy A. Blumenthal},
  journal={Litigation \& Procedure eJournal},
Legal scholarship on behavioralism and the implications of cognitive biases for the law is flourishing. In parallel with the rise of such commentary, legal scholars have begun to discuss the role of the emotions in legal discourse. Discussion turns on the "appropriateness" of various emotions for the substantive law, and on attempts to model the place of the emotions in the law. Implicit in some of these theories, however - and explicit in others - is the assumption that emotions are… 
Emotion and the Law
The field of law and emotion draws from a range of disciplines in the sciences, social sciences, and humanities to shed light on the emotions that pervade the legal system. It utilizes insights from
The present paper is an attempt to understand emotions and their impact on law and decisions. Emotions are seen as modification of desire and attachment. The desires are seen as arising from the
Law and Emotion: A Proposed Taxonomy of an Emerging Field
Any exploration of law and emotion should strive to identify which emotion(s) it takes as its focus; distinguish implicated emotion-driven phenomena; explore relevant and competing theories of the emotions; limit itself to a particular type of legal doctrine; expose underlying theories of law; and make clear which legal actors are implicated.
A Psychology of Emotional Legal Decision Making: Revulsion and Saving Face in Legal Theory and Practice
Professor Martha C. Nussbaum is an accomplished scholar in an impressive variety of fields. Drawing on her diverse academic backgrounds, Nussbaum has written extensively about emotions and their
The emotional dimensions of reason-giving in deliberative forums
This study investigates the role of emotions in the context of a controversial debate surrounding criminal legislation in Brazil. While several thinkers have criticized deliberation for requiring
The Ideal of the Dispassionate Judge: An Emotion Regulation Perspective
According to legal tradition, the ideal judge is entirely dispassionate. Affective science calls into question the legitimacy of this ideal; further, it suggests that no judge could ever meet this
Law and Social Cognition
The body of research on law and psychology is vast, but the overwhelming proportion of it is on jury decision making, especially in criminal cases. In this chapter for the forthcoming Oxford Handbook
A Moody View of the Law: Looking Back and Looking Ahead at Law and the Emotions
The current Symposium celebrates 3,400 years of law and emotion. How so? In Leviticus, Chapter 19 Verse 15, judges are instructed to judge rich and poor alike – interestingly, they are, separately,
Emotion and the Law: A Field Whose Time Has Come
Psychological research on emotion has a rich and varied history. A number of protopsychologists (e.g., Aristotle, Aquinas, Descartes, Hume) wrote about the effect of the passions on human thought and
On Judgment: Managing Emotions in Trials of Crimes Against Humanity in Argentina
For over a decade, judicial accountability of mass human rights violations committed during the last civil-military dictatorship in Argentina (1976–1983) has been carried out in federal courts by


Taking Behavioralism Seriously: The Problem of Market Manipulation
For the past few decades, cognitive psychologists and behavioral researchers have been steadily uncovering evidence that human decisionmaking processes are prone to nonrational, yet systematic,
Individual differences in the experience of emotions.
Evaluating Empirical Research Methods: Using Empirical Research in Law and Policy
Using the study of capital punishment in Nebraska as a starting point, this paper explores more broadly the tensions and tradeoffs at the intersection of social science methodology and the law from
Attitude Importance and the False Consensus Effect
Numerous studies have demonstrated that the attitudes people consider personally important have an enhanced impact on cognition and behavior. This article explores the possibility that importance may
The Uncertain Psychological Case for Paternalism
INTRODUCTION Human beings are fallible creatures. They often make poor choices, seizing upon irrelevant considerations to support their decisions even as they ignore important ones.1 Even choices
Four latent traits of emotional experience and their involvement in well-being, coping, and attributional style
In two samples of college students (Ns = 116 and 141), this research investigated the ways in which individuals differ in their experience of emotion. Four latent traits emerged from scales assessing
Temporal Adjustments in the Evaluation of Events: The "Rosy View"
The results of all three studies supported the hypothesis that people's expectations of personal events are more positive than their actual experience during the event itself, and their subsequent recollection of that event is morepositive than the actual experience.
The Culture of Compliance: The Final Triumph of Form over Substance in Sexual Harassment Law
Why does sexual harassment persist despite nearly three decades of attempts to eliminate it? While courts have developed a comprehensive set of legal rules governing workplace harassment, the
Decisions and revisions: the affective forecasting of changeable outcomes.
The results demonstrate that errors in affective forecasting can lead people to behave in ways that do not optimize their happiness and well-being.
The Social Organization of Surrogacy: Relinquishing a Baby and the Role of Payment in the Psychological Detachment Process
The ‘maternal-foetal detachment’ theory provides a framework for understanding how some women relinquish a baby in the context of paid surrogacy, and considers what can be learned about the concepts of maternal- foetal attachment and maternal instinct.