Language of Physics, Language of Math: Disciplinary Culture and Dynamic Epistemology

  title={Language of Physics, Language of Math: Disciplinary Culture and Dynamic Epistemology},
  author={Edward F. Redish and Eric Weilin Kuo},
  journal={Science \& Education},
  • E. Redish, E. Kuo
  • Published 22 September 2014
  • Education, Physics
  • Science & Education
Mathematics is a critical part of much scientific research. Physics in particular weaves math extensively into its instruction beginning in high school. Despite much research on the learning of both physics and math, the problem of how to effectively include math in physics in a way that reaches most students remains unsolved. In this paper, we suggest that a fundamental issue has received insufficient exploration: the fact that in science, we don’t just use math, we make meaning with it in a… 
Analysing the Competency of Mathematical Modelling in Physics
A primary goal of physics is to create mathematical models that allow both predictions and explanations of physical phenomena. We weave maths extensively into our physics instruction beginning in
Towards a Full Integration of Physics and Math Concepts: Words vs Meanings
Mathematics and physics concepts have been closely interrelated since their formal beginnings in ancient times. Moreover, from a wide variety of perspectives, it is possible to identify that the
Students’ Understanding of Algebraic Concepts
Redish and Kuo gave in 2015 in a paper on the language of physics and mathematics for higher physics education the following take-away message: “How mathematical formalism is used in the discipline
Physics and Mathematics as Interwoven Disciplines in Science Education
The relationship between physics and mathematics is reviewed upgrading the common in physics classes’ perspective of mathematics as a toolkit for physics. The nature of the physics-mathematics
Mathematics learning in physics classrooms of Russian schools: a changing landscape from the Soviet period to the present
For a long time, Soviet students learned ‘pure’ mathematics in their mathematics classrooms, while applications of mathematics were introduced in their science (mainly physics) classrooms. This
The Mathematics of High School Physics
In the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, mathematicians and physical philosophers managed to study, via mathematics, various physical systems of the sublunar world through idealized and
Toward a Functional Grammar of Physics Equations
An area of student difficulty in introductory physics courses is how they use and reason with equations. We propose that part of this difficulty is due to meaning that is embedded in the structure of
Theorems-in-Action for Problem-Solving and Epistemic Views on the Relationship Between Physics and Mathematics Among Preservice Physics Teachers
The difficulties students have with mathematics while trying to understand physics is one of the more remarkable, at least for physics teachers. In this chapter, we present our attempt to understand
Physics Teaching: Mathematics as an Epistemological Tool
Abstract We study the interconnection between Physics and Mathematics in concrete instances, departing from the usual expression for the Coulomb electric field, produced by a point-like charge. It is
The “Math as Prerequisite” Illusion: Historical Considerations and Implications for Physics Teaching
Mathematics is widely considered to be a prerequisite for learning physics. However, it is quite naive to believe that learning basic math is sufficient to use mathematics as a reasoning tool to


Making Meaning with Math in Physics: A Semantic Analysis
Physics makes powerful use of mathematics, yet the way this use is made is often poorly understood. Professionals closely integrate their mathematical symbology with physical meaning, resulting in a
How Students Understand Physics Equations
What does it mean to understand a physics equation? The use of formal expressions in physics is not just a matter of the rigorous and routinized application of principles, followed by the formal
Problem Solving and the Use of Math in Physics Courses.
Mathematics is an essential element of physics problem solving, but experts often fail to appreciate exactly how they use it. Math may be the language of science, but math-in-physics is a distinct
The dynamics of variability in introductory physics students' thinking: Examples from kinematics
This dissertation contributes to ongoing inquiry into the nature of students’ intuitive thought and its role in learning physics through the pursuit of dynamic systems characterizations of student reasoning, with a particular focus on how students settle into and shift among multiple patterns of reasoning about motion.
Elements of a Cognitive Model of Physics Problem Solving: Epistemic Games.
Although much is known about the differences between expert and novice problem solvers, knowledge of those differences typically does not provide enough detail to help instructors understand why some
Common sense clarified: The role of intuitive knowledge in physics problem solving
Over the last two decades, a significant body of research has documented the nature of intuitive physics knowledge—the knowledge of the world that students bring to the learning of formal physics.
Epistemic Complexity and the Journeyman-Expert Transition.
Physics students can encounter difficulties in physics problem solving as a result of failing to use knowledge that they have but do not perceive as relevant or appropriate. In previous work the
Resources , framing , and transfer
As researchers studying student reasoning in introductory physics, and as instructors teaching courses, we often focus on whether and how students apply what they know in one context to their
Tapping Epistemological Resources for Learning Physics
Research on personal epistemologies has begun to consider ontology: Do naive epistemologies take the form of stable, unitary beliefs or of fine-grained, context-sensitive resources? Debates such as
Disciplinary Authenticity: Enriching the Reforms of Introductory Physics Courses for Life-Science Students.
Educators and policy makers have advocated for reform of undergraduate biology education, calling for greater integration of mathematics and physics in the biology curriculum. While these calls