LETTERS AND COMMENTS: On Bohr's response to the clock-in-the-box thought experiment of Einstein *On Bohr's response to the clock-in-the-box thought experiment of Einstein

  title={LETTERS AND COMMENTS: On Bohr's response to the clock-in-the-box thought experiment of Einstein *On Bohr's response to the clock-in-the-box thought experiment of Einstein},
  author={Vladimir Hnizdo},
  journal={European Journal of Physics},
  • V. Hnizdo
  • Published 5 July 2001
  • Physics, Education
  • European Journal of Physics
The recent analysis by de la Torre, Daleo and Garcia-Mata of the reply of Bohr to the famous clock-in-the-box challenge of Einstein is criticized. 
Once again on the 'demythologizing' of the clock-in-the-box debate of Bohr and Einstein ∗
The reply of de la Torre, Daleo and Garcia-Mata [Eur. J. Phys. 23 (2002) L15-L16] to a criticism of their `demythologizing' analysis of the clock-in-the-box debate between Einstein and Bohr is
LETTERS AND COMMENTS: The photon-box Bohr-Einstein debate demythologized. Reply to Comment *The photon-box Bohr-Einstein debate demythologized. Reply to Comment
The arguments presented in the criticism of our work suffer from the same mistakes that we have denounced. That is, the confusion of quantum indeterminacies with experimental uncertainties. We
Einstein’s photon box revisited
  • H. Schmidt
  • Physics
    International Journal of Theoretical Physics
  • 2022
We present a reformulation of Bohr’s analysis of Einstein’s thought experiment with the photon box, which hopefully settles some unclear issues. The box is weighed by two position measurements, the
EPR before EPR: a 1930 Einstein–Bohr thought experiment revisited
In 1930, Einstein argued against the consistency of the time–energy uncertainty relation by discussing a thought experiment involving a measurement of the mass of the box which emitted a photon. Bohr
Thought Experiments in Science
Thought experiments are a means of imaginative reasoning with an employment record longer than two and a half thousand years. Used by Aristotle, Galileo, Newton, Darwin, Maxwell, and Einstein, they
Breaking the Unbreakable : Exploiting Loopholes in Bell’s Theorem to Hack Quantum Cryptography
In this thesis we study device-independent quantum key distribution based on energy-time entanglement. This is a method for cryptography that promises not only perfect secrecy, but also to be a pra
A Classical-Light Attack on Energy-Time Entangled Quantum Key Distribution, and Countermeasures
Quantum key distribution (QKD) is an application of quantum mechanics that allowstwo parties to communicate with perfect secrecy. Traditional QKD uses polarization of individual photons, but the de
The equivalent invariant mass of closed systems of massive particles
The use of relativistic frame invariants is very well established, especially when it comes to the energy-momentum. What is less understood is the notion of ‘invariant mass’ as it applies to systems
Taming theory with thought experiments: Understanding and scientific progress.
  • M. Stuart
  • Education
    Studies in history and philosophy of science
  • 2016


The photon-box Bohr-Einstein debate demythologized
The legendary discussion between Einstein and Bohr concerning the photon-box experiment is critically analysed. It is shown that Einstein's argument is flawed while Bohr's reply is wrong.
Discussion with Einstein on Epistemological Problems in Atomic Physics
Niels Bohr's Times: In Physics, Philosophy, and Polity
Niel Bohr's life spans times of revolutionary change, in science and in its impact on society. Along with Einstein, Bohr can be considered as this century's major driving force behind the new
Quantum theory and measurement
The forty-nine papers collected here illuminate the meaning of quantum theory as it is disclosed in the measurement process. Together with an introduction and a supplemental annotated bibliography,
"Weighing" a closed system and the time-energy uncertainty principle
It is proved that for an internal observer the time tau, required to measure the total energy with accuracy DeltaE, is bounded according to tauDeltaE>Planck's over 2pi.
Can Quantum-Mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete?
Consideration of the problem of making predictions concerning a system on the basis of measurements made on another system that had previously interacted with it leads to the result that one is led to conclude that the description of reality as given by a wave function is not complete.
Surprises in Theoretical Physics
Problems in theoretical physics often lead to paradoxical answers; yet closer reasoning and a more complete analysis invariably lead to the resolution of the paradox and to a deeper understanding of
: This work presents a novel zero in-plane Poisson’s ratio honeycomb design for large out-of-plane deformations and morphing. The novel honeycomb topology is composed by two parts that provide
Surprises in Theoretical Physics (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University
  • 1979