Juror attitudes and biases in sexual assault cases

  title={Juror attitudes and biases in sexual assault cases},
  author={Natalie Taylor},
  journal={Trends and issues in crime and criminal justice},
  • N. Taylor
  • Published 2007
  • Psychology
  • Trends and issues in crime and criminal justice
Sexual assault has among the highest rates of acquittal and lowest rates of proven guilt compared with other offences. Given that more than 70 percent of sexual assault incidents are not reported to police and only about one in 10 reported incidents results in a guilty finding, increasing conviction rates for sexual assault is a key issue for the criminal justice system. This paper presents findings from two recent studies conducted by the Australian Institute of Criminology. These show that… Expand

Figures and Tables from this paper

Similar facts and consent in sexual assault cases: Filling in the gap left by the high court in Phillips
A number of jurisdictions in Australia have amended their rules governing joint trials in order to encourage trial judges to join sexual assault counts in the one trial where there are multipleExpand
Defining Consent as a Factor in Sexual Assault Prevention
One in five women and one in sixteen men are sexually assaulted while attending college (Krebs et al., 2007; White House Task Force to Protect Students from Sexual Assault, 2014). The inconsistenciesExpand
Enhancing the credibility of complainants in child sexual assault trials: the effect of expert evidence and judicial directions.
Results revealed that endorsement of CSA misconceptions negatively impacted ratings of complainant credibility and verdicts, and comparisons of the effectiveness of two procedural legal mechanisms to manage juror misconceptions and improve knowledge about CSA provide guidance for future researchers investigating ways to increase fairness in cases of C SA. Expand
The Role Of Schema Congruence In Mock Jurors’ Judgments Of Sexual Assault Cases
People use schemas to categorize their informational world. Schemas allow us to appraise a current social situation, or to predict future social behaviors; schemas are cognitive shortcuts that canExpand
Uncertainty and Misconceptions About Child Sexual Abuse: Implications for the Criminal Justice System
Recent amendments to the uniform evidence legislation in Australia mean that it will be possible for prosecutors to call expert opinion evidence to bolster the credibility of child complainants inExpand
The jury is an inappropriate decision-making body in rape trials in Scotland:Not Guilty, Not Proven, Guilty?
This thesis reviews the influence of prejudicial social attitudes on jury decision-making in rape trials, and considers whether the verdict in rape cases should continue to be determined by a jury inExpand
The Effect of Gender on Perceptions of Credibility in Child Sexual Assault Cases: A Systematic Review
Results suggest that overall females tend to rate victim credibility higher than do males; however, this gender effect is minimized when the alleged perpetrator is not the biological parent of the victim. Expand
Of ‘Normal Sex’ and ‘Real Rape’: Exploring The Use of Socio-Sexual Scripts in (Mock) Jury Deliberation
This article explores a series of 27 jury deliberations, undertaken by volunteer members of the public, following their observation of a mini-rape trial reconstruction. While research with ‘real’Expand
The many facets of shame in intimate partner sexual violence
Despite indications of a high prevalence rate of spousal sexual violence, there seems to be more reluctance on the part of victim/survivors to report or discuss spousal sexual violence compared toExpand
Victim representation for sexual history evidence in Ireland: A step towards or away from meeting victims’ procedural justice needs?
Sexual assault cases have historically resulted in persistent victim dissatisfaction with, and alienation from, the prosecution process. As a result, some adversarial jurisdictions have movedExpand


Attrition of Sexual Offences from the New South Wales Criminal Justice System, The
Each year NSW Police receive reports of more than 7,000 sexual and indecent assault incidents. Only about one in ten of these incidents result in someone being found guilty in court. This paperExpand
Juror Stereotypes and Blame Attribution in Rape Cases Involving Intoxicants: The Findings of a Pilot Study
Prior to recent legislative changes, sexual offences were contained in a combination of statutory provisions and common law that was criticized as being ill-equipped to tackle the intricacies ofExpand
The impact of pre-recorded video and closed circuit television testimony by adult sexual assault complainants on jury decision-making: an experimental study
A mock sexual assault jury trial research project investigated whether the impact of adult sexual assault complainant testimony on juror perceptions and decisions differed if presented via CCTV,Expand
Criminal courts Australia 2005–06
  • ABS cat. no. 4513.0. Canberra: ABS
  • 2007
Recorded crime, victims, Australia, 2006
  • ABS cat. no. 4510.0. Canberra: ABS. http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/ cat/4510.0
  • 2007
Criminal courts Australia 2004–05
  • ABS cat. no. 4513.0. Canberra: ABS
  • 2006
Criminal courts Australia 2003–04
  • ABS cat. no. 4513.0. Canberra: ABS
  • 2005
Community attitudes to violence against women survey 2006: full technical report
  • Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology
  • 2006
Responding to sexual assault: the way forward
  • Sydney: NSW Attorney General’s Department
  • 2005