Jumping the Line, Charitably: Analysis and Remedy of Donor-Priority Rule

  title={Jumping the Line, Charitably: Analysis and Remedy of Donor-Priority Rule},
  author={Tinglong Dai and Ronghuo Zheng and Katia P. Sycara},
  journal={Manag. Sci.},
The ongoing shortage of organs for transplantation has generated an expanding literature on efficient and equitable allocation of the donated cadaveric organs. By contrast, organ donation has been ... 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Organ donation with vouchers
This paper proposes and analyzes a general class of deceased organ allocation policies that assign priority on organ waiting lists to voucher holders to promote deceased donor registration. Expand
Improving Societal Outcomes in the Organ Donation Value Chain
An analytical model is developed to study the effects of contextual parameters and decisions of the supply-side entities (OPO and hospital) on their respective payoffs and on societal outcomes and recommends an administratively feasible and Pareto-improving contract that the social planner can use to help the ODVC achieve socially-optimal performance. Expand
An Achievable-Region-Based Approach for Kidney Allocation Policy Design with Endogenous Patient Choice
The ranking policy that chooses kidney transplant candidates according to characteristics of both the donor and the recipient should be reconsidered. Expand
Optimal Organ Allocation Policy Under Blood-Type Barriers with the Donor-Priority Rule
Shortages in organs for transplantation have resulted in a renewed interest in designing incentive policies to promote organ supply. The donor-priority rule, which grants priority for transplantationExpand
Is it Time to Include Post‐Transplant Survival in Heart Transplantation Allocation Rules?
Identifying an efficient and fair allocation of limited donated hearts to patients on the waiting list is one of the top priorities in heart transplantation management. The recent heart allocationExpand
Incentivizing organ donation by swearing an oath: The role of signature and ritual
In China, United States and in many other countries, there is a serious gap between the demand and the supply of human organs for transplantation. To fill this gap, policy makers have made greatExpand
Does a Rising Tide Lift All Boats? Kidney Transplantation through Surgery Suspension and Resumption
Problem Definition. Between March and May 2020, in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, multiple states in the U.S. issued guidances for suspending elective surgery and subsequently lifted them. InExpand
Does Transportation Mean Transplantation? Impact of New Airline Routes on Sharing of Cadaveric Kidneys
Nearly 5,000 patients die every year while waiting for kidney transplants, and an estimated 18% of procured kidneys are discarded. Such a polarized co-existence of dire scarcity and massiveExpand
OM Forum - Healthcare Operations Management: A Snapshot of Emerging Research
A new generation of healthcare operations management (HOM) scholars is studying timely healthcare topics (e.g., organization design, design of delivery, and organ transplantation) using contemporar...
An Achievable-Region-Based Approach for Kidney Allocation Policy Design with Endogenous Patient Choice
The deceased-donor kidney transplant candidates in the US are ranked according to characteristics of both the donor and the recipient. We seek the ranking policy that optimizes the efficiency-equityExpand


The potential impact of an opt-out system for organ donation in the UK
  • R. Rieu
  • Medicine
  • Journal of Medical Ethics
  • 2010
The recent report of the UK government's Organ Donation Taskforce is in favour of continuing with the current organ donation system rather than changing to an opt-out system where people are assumedExpand
Ethical incentives--not payment--for organ donation.
Advances in immunosuppression have eliminated the requirement of a genetic match for organ transplants, and many patients with end-stage organ failure are no longer relying solely on the waiting list and are turning to spouses, friends, or strangers as possible donors. Expand
Organ Allocation Policy and the Decision to Donate
It is found that an organ allocation policy giving priority on waiting lists to those who previously registered as donors has a significant positive impact on registration. Expand
Encouraging altruism: public attitudes and the marketing of organ donation.
  • J. Prottas
  • Medicine
  • The Milbank Memorial Fund quarterly. Health and society
  • 1983
The public's attitudes toward organ donation are treated and what can and is being done to foster the willingness to donate are considered, about altruism and its exploitation for the common good. Expand
Loopholes undermine donation: An experiment motivated by an organ donation priority loophole in Israel☆
Giving registered organ donors priority on organ waiting lists, as has been implemented in Israel and Singapore, provides an incentive for registration and has the potential to increase the pool ofExpand
Prioritizing registered donors in organ allocation: an ethical appraisal of the Israeli organ transplant law
An ethical analysis of the new organ transplant law in Israel, which gives priority in organ allocation to candidates who in various ways support organ donation, which has resulted in a significant increase in organ donation in 2011, is provided. Expand
OrganJet: Overcoming Geographical Disparities in Access to Deceased Donor Kidneys in the United States
This work proposes an operational solution that offers affordable jet services (OrganJet) to patients on the transplant waiting list, allowing them to list in multiple different, and possibly very distant, donation service areas of their choosing. Expand
The Gift That Keeps on Giving: Increasing Donation Rates by Offering Incentives
  • D. Goldberg, J. Trotter
  • Medicine
  • American journal of transplantation : official journal of the American Society of Transplantation and the American Society of Transplant Surgeons
  • 2016
Changes in organ donation before and after implementation of a novel national policy in Israel, where citizens were rewarded for either registering as a donor or authorizing donation by their next of kin, were reviewed. Expand
A new law for allocation of donor organs in Israel
A national plan for prioritisation of organ allocation was devised to increase the number of individuals with donor cards in the hope that such an increase would lead to an increase in organ donation. Expand
The Optimal Timing of Living-Donor Liver Transplantation
This work considers the problem of optimally timing a living-donor liver transplant to maximize the patient's total reward, such as quality-adjusted life expectancy, and formulate a Markov decision process (MDP) model in which the state of the process is described by patient health. Expand