It is magic! How impossible solutions prevent the discovery of obvious ones?

@article{Thomas2018ItIM,
  title={It is magic! How impossible solutions prevent the discovery of obvious ones?},
  author={Cyril Thomas and Andr{\'e} Didierjean and Gustav Kuhn},
  journal={Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology},
  year={2018},
  volume={71},
  pages={2481 - 2487}
}
When confronted with an insight problem, some factors limit our capacity to discover the optimal solution. Previous research on problem solving has shown that the first idea that comes to participants’ minds can inhibit them from finding better alternative solutions. We used a magic trick to demonstrate that this mind fixing effect is more general than previously thought: a solution that participants knew to be incorrect and impossible inhibited the discovery of an easy alternative. We show… 

Figures from this paper

Too perfect to be good? An investigation of magicians’ Too Perfect Theory
The “Too Perfect Theory” states that if a trick is too perfect, it might paradoxically become less impressive, or give away its secret method. This theory suggests that an increased impossibility
Cognitive conflict and restructuring: The neural basis of two core components of insight
TLDR
This work presents magic tricks to participants and asks them to find out the secret method used by the magician for the mechanism behind the magic trick, believing this type of approach towards understanding insight will give a better understanding of this complex process and the specific role that different brain regions play in creative thought.
On the cognitive bases of illusionism
TLDR
Some of the mysteries of how the brain works may be trapped in the split realities present in every magic effect, as well as in tasks that are more ecological and context-dependent than those usually exploited in artificial laboratory settings.
On the Cognitive Bases of Illusionism: An Untapped Tool for Brain and Behavioral Research
Cognitive scientists have paid very little attention to magic as a distinctly human activity capable of creating situations or events that are considered impossible because they violate expectations
Misdirection – Magic, Psychology and its Application
The art of magic relies on deception and illusions to create human experiences that appear impossible.  Misdirection lies at the heart of this deceptive art, and yet there is little consensus as to
Why game designers should study magic
TLDR
It is argued that video game designers face the same design challenge - crafting believable and engaging illusions - and that the practice of magic provides an untapped wealth of design principles and techniques for game designers.
Latent value in humiliation: A design thinking tool to enhance empathy in creative ideation
ABSTRACT Design thinking emphasizes that in addition to being creative, design solutions should be empathetic. Yet, research suggests there may be a tension between these goals, where focusing on
Cognitive control of invalid predominant ideas in insight-like problem solving.
Predominant ordinary ideas are insufficient for solving insight-like problems; they interfere with subordinate original ideas and can produce a mental impasse. However, how people monitor and control
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 27 REFERENCES
Does Magic Offer a Cryptozoology Ground for Psychology?
Magicians often trick spectators’ senses by relying on cognitive limitations. To do so, they use intuitive but age-old knowledge of human cognition. Research into the relationship between magic and
A framework for using magic to study the mind
TLDR
A framework outlining how knowledge about magic can be used to help us understand the human mind is proposed, including the possibility of a science centered around the experience of wonder.
Aha! experiences leave a mark: facilitated recall of insight solutions
The present study investigates a possible memory advantage for solutions that were reached through insightful problem solving. We hypothesized that insight solutions (with Aha! experience) would be
Magic in Theory: An Introduction to the Theoretical and Psychological Elements of Conjuring
Magic, properly performed, is a complex and skilful art, and is capable of deceiving anyone. One of the reasons why so little information is available to non-magicians interested in the topic is that
Towards a science of magic
What about False Insights? Deconstructing the Aha! Experience along Its Multiple Dimensions for Correct and Incorrect Solutions Separately
TLDR
Findings cast some doubt on the assumption that the occurrence of an Aha! experience can serve as a definitive signal that a true insight has taken place, and the quantitative and qualitative differences in the experience of correct and incorrect solutions demonstrate that the Aha!. experience is not a mere epiphenomenon.
A psychologically-based taxonomy of misdirection
TLDR
This article argues that a more natural way of making sense of misdirection is to focus on the perceptual and cognitive mechanisms involved, and develops a psychologically-based taxonomy based on the mechanisms that control these effects.
Correcting false information in memory: Manipulating the strength of misinformation encoding and its retraction
TLDR
It is concluded that the continued influence effect seems to defy most attempts to eliminate it, and a simple computational model based on random sampling that captures this effect pattern is presented.
The Mechanism of the Einstellung (Set) Effect
The eye movements of expert players trying to solve a chess problem show that the first idea that comes to mind directs attention toward sources of information consistent with it and away from
...
...