Is there a right not to know one's sex? The ethics of ‘gender verification’ in women's sports competition

@article{Wiesemann2011IsTA,
  title={Is there a right not to know one's sex? The ethics of ‘gender verification’ in women's sports competition},
  author={Claudia Wiesemann},
  journal={Journal of Medical Ethics},
  year={2011},
  volume={37},
  pages={216 - 220}
}
  • C. Wiesemann
  • Published 1 March 2011
  • Education
  • Journal of Medical Ethics
The paper discusses the current medical practice of ‘gender verification’ in sports from an ethical point of view. It takes the recent public discussion about 800 m runner Caster Semenya as a starting point. At the World Championships in Athletics 2009 in Berlin, Germany, Semenya was challenged by competitors as being a so called ‘sex impostor’. A medical examination to verify her sex ensued. The author analyses whether athletes like Semenya could claim a right not to know that is generally… 

PROBLEMATISING TRANS ‘GENDER’ CATEGORY IN FIGHT-BOXING BY ANALYSING BEAUTIFUL BOXER

The research intends to look at the non-existence of the queer identity amongst all the gender identities recognized in the world. The study follows a cultural methodology with hints of an

Sex and gender issues in competitive sports: investigation of a historical case leads to a new viewpoint

TLDR
It might be justifiable to use the circulating testosterone level as an endocrinological parameter to try to arrive at an objective criterion in evaluating what separates women and men in sports competitions, which could prevent the initiation of complicated, lengthy and damaging sex and gender verification procedures.

The Onus of Inclusivity: Sport Policies and the Enforcement of the Women’s Category in Sport

With recent controversies surrounding the eligibility of athletes with disorders of sex development (DSD) and hyperandrogenism, as well as continued discussion of the conditions transgender athletes

The taxonomy and ontology of sexual difference: implications for sport

When it comes to sexing the body, the effect of increasing knowledge has not been to consolidate the two-sex model of sexual difference, but to challenge the certainties of binary thinking. While

Striking a balance between inclusion and exclusion in competitive sport

This thesis aims to investigate the regulatory balance between inclusion and exclusion in competitive sport. Society is obsessed with categorising and treating individuals and groups according to

Research on the Relationships Among the Gender Consciousness, Social Support, and Wellbeing in Taiwan College Female Athletes

The purpose of this research was to understand the cognition of female college athletes on gender consciousness and social support, which will contribute to the wellbeing of college female athletes.

Conceptualizing the Human Being: Insights from the Genethics Discourse and Implications for Islamic Bioethics

  • A. Padela
  • Medicine
    Islamic Ethics and the Genome Question
  • 2019
TLDR
A large number of articles without abstracts were automatically carried through to full-text review and exclusion criteria were same for both stages as outlined in the methods section Aasim I.

I. INTRODUCTION Due to the interaction of the International Olympic Committee with the International Sports Federation and the Organizing Committee of the Olympic Games, an agreement

2219 Published By: Blue Eyes Intelligence Engineering & Sciences Publication Retrieval Number F8613088619/2019©BEIESP DOI: 10.35940/ijeat.F8613.088619 Abstract: Sporting achievements are

Regional Variations in the Management of Testicular or Ovotesticular Disorders of Sex Development

TLDR
The regional variations exist not only between different continents, as already demonstrated by others, but also between Northern, Latin and Eastern European countries, suggesting that ‘one-fits-all’ guidelines for management are not appropriate.

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 40 REFERENCES

The Use and Misuse of Sex Chromatin Screening for `Gender Identification' of Female Athletes

TLDR
It is shown herein that the sex chromatin screening method reveals only a small proportion of individuals with certain congenital chromosome abnormalities and other abnormal conditions without increased muscle strength, and proposed that the aims of gender identification should be defined and methods chosen that achieve the desired result.

The right not to know: an autonomy based approach

TLDR
This paper argues that individuals may have a legitimate interest in not knowing their genetic make up to avoid serious psychological consequences and that this interest, far from being contrary to autonomy, may constitute an enhancement of autonomy.

Ethical principles and recommendations for the medical management of differences of sex development (DSD)/intersex in children and adolescents

TLDR
Three leading ethical principles that apply to DSD management are identified: to foster the well-being of the child and the future adult, to uphold the rights of children and adolescents to participate in and/or self-determine decisions that affect them now or later, and to respect the family and parent–child relationships.

"Sex passport" obligation for female athletes. Consideration and criticisms on 364 subjects.

TLDR
The present work indicates several scientific shortcomings of the current I.O.C.C.'s examination criteria, illustrates three chromatin-negative cases, their consequences and proposed a return to original criteria for examination except in doubtful cases.

Caster Semenya: sport, categories and the creative role of ethics

TLDR
Caster Semenya's case has implications for the ethics of sports and debates about gender and enhancement, and for the philosophical debate about the nature of categories and the classification of people.

Sexual identity and sexual orientation in children with traumatized or ambiguous genitalia

It has long been proposed that the development of sexual orientation and sexual identity is due to an interaction of both constitutional and social forces (Diamond, 1965). A great deal of evidence

‘We Shall Never Know the Exact Number of Men who Have Competed in the Olympics Posing as Women’: Sport, Gender Verification and the Cold War

From 1968 to 1998, participants in Olympic women's events had to undergo a test in order to establish if they really were women. This practice, referred to as ‘gender verification’, has not escaped

Sex Typing for Sport

  • A. Dreger
  • Education
    The Hastings Center report
  • 2010
TLDR
In January, the International Olympic Committee sponsored a meeting of medical professionals in Miami aimed at revising the "gender verification" policies of the IOC and the International Association of Athletics Federations, which failed to produce any clear consensus and only seemed to create confusion about what is now considered fair or allowable so far as sports gender divisions go.

Gender verification of female athletes

TLDR
The history and rationales for fairness in female-only sports that have led to the rise and fall of on-site, chromosome-based gender verification at international sporting events are reviewed.