Is the male marriage premium due to selection? The effect of shotgun weddings on the return to marriage

  title={Is the male marriage premium due to selection? The effect of shotgun weddings on the return to marriage},
  author={Donna K Ginther and Madeline Zavodny},
  journal={Journal of Population Economics},
Abstract. In standard cross-sectional wage regressions, married men appear to earn 10 to 20% more than comparable never married men. One proposed explanation for this male marriage premium is that men may be selected into marriage on the basis of characteristics valued by employers as well as by spouses or because they earn high wages. This paper examines the selection hypothesis by focusing on shotgun weddings, which may make marital status uncorrelated with earnings ability. We compare the… Expand

Tables from this paper

The Marriage Earnings Premium as a Distributed Fixed Effect
Wage equations using cross-sectional data typically find an earnings premium in excess of 10 percent for married men. One leading hypothesis for the premium is that marriage facilitatesExpand
On the Marriage Wage Premium∗
In this paper, we use a novel instrument based on local social norms towards marriage to present a new finding: marriage has a positive causal effect on the wages of both men and women. Despite theExpand
The marital earnings premium: an IV approach
Numerous studies find that married men earn more than single men. However, identifying whether and why marriage affects earnings is complicated by the fact that marriage market outcomes are jointlyExpand
The male marriage premium: selection, productivity, or employer preferences? Evidence from panel data and a survey experiment
Survey evidence finds a wage premium for married men over single in most of the western world. Three key theories are put forward as an explanation: 1) marriage makes men more productive andExpand
Does Marriage Lead to Specialization in Sweden? An Evaluation of Trends in Adult Earnings Before and After Marriage
Although a positive male marriage premium has been found in many studies, the source of the premium is unclear and debated – does it result from selection or specialization? Our paper analyzes trendsExpand
The Distribution of Returns to Marriage
The phenomenon that married men earn a higher wage on average than unmarried men, the so-called marriage premium, is rather well established. However, the robustness of the marriage premium acrossExpand
Valuable Vows: An Examination of the Marriage Premium Using Same-Sex Marriage Legalization
We utilize U.S. same-sex marriage legalization to reexamine the unresolved question of why married men earn higher wages than comparable unmarried men. If this marriage premium operates similarly forExpand
Is There a Male Marital Wage Premium? New Evidence from the United States
This study reconsiders the phenomenon that married men earn more money than unmarried men, a key result of the research on marriage benefits. Many earlier studies have found such a “male marital wageExpand
The Male Marital Wage Premium in Germany: Selection versus Specialization
Empirical research consistently confirms a marital wage premium (MWP) for men, which is explained by selection (high earnings potentials being more attractive on the marriage market) orExpand
Does Marriage Lead to Specialization? An Evaluation of Swedish Trends in Adult Earnings Before and After Marriage
We examine whether marriage leads to specialization in Sweden by implementing a model that differentiates specialization in the household by cohabitation and marriage. Our paper evaluates this modelExpand


The Fall in Men's Return to Marriage: Declining Productivity Effects or Changing Selection?
Historically, one of the most robust findings from human capital wage equations has been that married men earn more than men who never marry. However, the earnings premium paid to married comparedExpand
Men money and marriage: are high earners more prone than low earners to marry?
Most empirical research on earnings reveals that married men earn more than never married or divorced men. This research addresses the question of whether married men are seen to earn more becauseExpand
Does Marriage Really Make Men More Productive
This paper presents new descriptive evidence regarding marital pay premiums earned by white males. Longitudinal data indicate that wages rise after marriage, and that cross-sectional marriageExpand
Unobservable Individual Effects, Marriage and the Earnings of Young Men
While there is compelling evidence that married men earn more than unmarried men, the source of this premium remains unsettled. Using panel data from the National Longitudinal Survey of Young Men, weExpand
Productivity Differences and the Marriage Wage Premium for White Males
Attempts to account for the positive, and often large, wage premium paid to married men based on their greater productivity have been inconclusive. Using data from the National Longitudinal Survey ofExpand
Local Marriage Markets and the Marital Behavior of Black and White Women
Previous research has typically ignored the spatial dimension of marriage markets, focusing instead on highly aggregated data or on individual models of entry into marriage. A basic premise of thisExpand
The declining marital-status earnings differential
There is some evidence that differences in human-capital investment between married and unmarried men have fallen over time, but this effect has apparently been largely offset by increases in the return to that human capital. Expand
Marriage rates and marriageable men: A test of the Wilson hypothesis
This article examines the hypothesis that recent declines in black marriage rates have been driven by a declining pool of high-earning, young black men. Using 1970 and 1980 SMSA-level Census data toExpand
Employment and Marriage among Inner-city Fathers
This article uses data from the Urban Poverty and Family Structure Survey of inner-city residents in Chicago to examine the effect of employment on the likelihood that single fathers marry. OurExpand
Evidence on omitted variable bias in earnings equations
Abstract In this paper we propose that family background variables are significant in earnings equations because they measure investments in children made by families in the home, over and aboveExpand