Is Universal Grammar ready for retirement? A short review of a longstanding misinterpretation

@article{MendvilGir2018IsUG,
  title={Is Universal Grammar ready for retirement? A short review of a longstanding misinterpretation},
  author={Jos{\'e}-Luis Mend{\'i}vil-Gir{\'o}},
  journal={Journal of Linguistics},
  year={2018},
  volume={54},
  pages={859 - 888}
}
In this paper I consider recent studies that deny the existence of Universal Grammar (UG), and I show how the concept of UG that is attacked in these works is quite different from Chomsky’s, and thus that such criticisms are not valid. My principal focus is on the notions of ‘linguistic specificity’ and of ‘innateness’, and I conclude that, since the controversy about UG is based on misinterpretations, it is rendered sterile and thus does unnecessary harm to linguistic science. I also address… 

Misused Terms in Linguistics

Tanja Kupisch and Jason Rothman, psycholinguists working primarily on bilingual development, recently noted that “[o]nce offered to the public domain, terminology can have far-reaching and

AGAINST MECHANISMS: TOWARDS A MINIMAL THEORY OF CHANGE

  • Philosophy
  • 2021
A widespread view in the literature on language change is that there exist a finite number of mechanisms of change to which attested instances of change can be assigned. In this paper I argue against

On language innate building blocks : An open letter to Martin Haspelmath

These days I have been reading some of your recent contributions: comments on Facebook and Twitter, several blogposts and interviews from your blog (dlc.hypotheses.org), including one that you kindly

The Grammar of the Utterance

This book examines how speakers of Ibero-Romance ‘do things’ with conversational units of language, paying particular attention to what they do with utterance-oriented elements such as vocatives,

Foundations of generative linguistics

: This paper gives a broad overview of the ideas underlying the Chomskyan approach to linguistics. It identifies the main innovation of generative grammar in linguistics and clarifies some recurring

Constructing a Consensus on Language Evolution? Convergences and Differences Between Biolinguistic and Usage-Based Approaches

TLDR
Across both paradigms, researchers have come to increasingly embrace more complex views of these issues and havecome to appreciate the view that biological and cultural evolution are closely intertwined, which lead to an increased amount of common ground between minimalist biolinguistic and usage-based approaches.

Did language evolve through language change? On language change, language evolution and grammaticalization theory

The relation between language change and the process of language evolution is controversial in current linguistic theory. Some authors believe that the two processes are completely unrelated, while

Grammar in Low-Stakes, Informal Testing Context — Do Different Task Types Influence Performance?

TLDR
The present study explores the potential of informal, low-stakes, grammar-based test forms, by adopting a combination of qualitative and quantitative approach, and provides a contextualised, diagnostic view of testing grammar.

Language in our brain : The origins of a uniquely human capacity

vatore Gilij (1721–1789) in Ch. 17, Matthias Pache, Arjan Mossel, and Willem F. H. Adelaar remark on the very modern notions he proposed while documenting Indigenous languages of the Orinoco region.

The Influence of First Language Aptitude and Print Exposure (Arabic) on Foreign Language Learning Performance (English) And the Effectiveness of the General Aptitude Test in Saudi Arabia

This study seeks to examine areas of influence of the first language on the second language that have not yet been explored, supported or evaluated in the domain of language skills transfer. The

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 57 REFERENCES

An Evaluation of Universal Grammar and the Phonological Mind1

TLDR
There is no evidence that phonology is innate and that, in fact, the simplest hypothesis seems to be that phonologist is learned like other human abilities, i.e., the opposite of what UG is normally thought to predict.

What exactly is Universal Grammar, and has anyone seen it?

TLDR
This paper critically examines a variety of arguments that have been put forward as evidence for UG, focussing on the three most powerful ones: universality (all human languages share a number of properties), convergence (all language learners converge on the same grammar in spite of the fact that they are exposed to different input), and poverty of the stimulus (children know things about language which they could not have learned from the input available to them).

ON CARTESIAN LINGUISTICS

The central doctrine of Cartesian linguistics is that the general features of grammatical structure are common to all languages and reflect certain fundamental properties of the mind. It is this

Approaching UG from Below

The problem that has virtually defined the serious study of language since its ancient origins, if only implicitly, is to identify the specific nature of this distinctive human possession. Within the

The Generative Enterprise Revisited: Discussions with Riny Huybregts, Henk van Riemsdijk, Naoki Fukui and Mihoko Zushi

Spanning more than two decades of thinking about generative approaches to Universal Grammar, the two interviews with Noam Chomsky in this book permit a rare and illuminating insight into his views on

Pre-established categories don't exist: Consequences for language description and typology

Abstract 1. Introduction Structural categories of grammar (such as clitic, affix, compound, adjective, pronoun, dative, subject, passive, diphthong, coronal) have to be posited by linguists and by

The language faculty that wasn't: a usage-based account of natural language recursion

TLDR
It is argued that a language faculty is difficult to reconcile with evolutionary considerations, and that the authors' ability to process recursive structure does not rely on recursion as a property of the grammar, but instead emerges gradually by piggybacking on domain-general sequence learning abilities.

The myth of language universals: language diversity and its importance for cognitive science.

TLDR
This target article summarizes decades of cross-linguistic work by typologists and descriptive linguists, showing just how few and unprofound the universal characteristics of language are, once the authors honestly confront the diversity offered to us by the world's 6,000 to 8,000 languages.
...