Is Empathic Accuracy Enough to Facilitate Responsive Behavior in Dyadic Interaction? Distinguishing Ability From Motivation

@article{Winczewski2016IsEA,
  title={Is Empathic Accuracy Enough to Facilitate Responsive Behavior in Dyadic Interaction? Distinguishing Ability From Motivation},
  author={Lauren Winczewski and Jeffrey D. Bowen and Nancy L. Collins},
  journal={Psychological Science},
  year={2016},
  volume={27},
  pages={394 - 404}
}
Growing evidence suggests that interpersonal responsiveness—feeling understood, validated, and cared for by other people—plays a key role in shaping the quality of one’s social interactions and relationships. But what enables people to be interpersonally responsive to others? In the current study, we argued that responsiveness requires not only accurate understanding but also compassionate motivation. Specifically, we hypothesized that understanding another person’s thoughts and feelings… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Empathic Accuracy and Relationship Satisfaction: A Meta-Analytic Review
TLDR
A meta-analytic review of 21 studies that examined the association between EA and satisfaction found that EA for negative emotions was more closely related to satisfaction than EA for positive ones, suggesting that EA may be more meaningful when relationships are consolidating but before they become stable.
Seeing bad does good: Relational benefits of accuracy regarding partners’ negative moods
When would greater empathic accuracy (EA) be an asset and when would it not? In two studies of romantic couples (both employing daily diaries, the second also involving a lab-based video-recall
What really helps? Divergent implications of talking to someone with an empathic mindset versus similar experience for shame and self-evaluation in the wake of an embarrassing event.
TLDR
Perceivers' dispositional empathy, involving a different type of experience accumulated over time, also predicted benefits to targets, and perceiver experience over empathic concern in facilitating targets' recovery from embarrassing events was suggested.
Who Cares? Effects of Social Approach and Avoidance Motivation on Responsiveness to Others
TLDR
Evidence that responsiveness has motivational origins is found and it is suggested that both approach and avoidance motivation might be ways of behaving responsively in potentially difficult social situations.
You don't know how it feels: Accuracy in emotion perception predicts responsiveness of support.
TLDR
The results suggest that accuracy in perceiving a partner's emotions is crucial for providing responsive support and individual differences in one's own emotional experiences are associated both accuracy and responsiveness.
Teaching empathic concern and altruism in the smartphone age
Abstract Numerous studies show empathic concern promotes altruistic motivation and prosocial behavior. Here, we discuss empathic concern, its relation to altruistic motivation, and how empathic
The interpersonal costs of dishonesty: How dishonest behavior reduces individuals' ability to read others' emotions.
TLDR
How dishonest conduct can reduce one's generalized empathic accuracy-the ability to accurately read other people's emotional states is unpacked and a causal relationship is demonstrated.
Seeing Their Side Versus Feeling Their Pain: Differential Consequences of Perspective-Taking and Empathy at Work
TLDR
Meta-analytically examined 304 independent samples to uncover unique effects of perspective taking and empathic concern on important work-related outcomes and develops and test a contingency model of those effects, based on three facets of psychological interdependence: outcome, hierarchical (or power asymmetry), and social category.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 51 REFERENCES
It Takes Two
TLDR
It is found that perceivers' self-reported affective empathy can indeed predict their empathic accuracy, but only when targets' expressivity allows their thoughts and feelings to be read.
Naturalistic Social Cognition: Empathic Accuracy in Mixed-Sex Dyads
The research paradigm that Ickes and his colleagues developed for the study of naturalistic social cognition was used to explore the phenomenon of empathic accuracy in the initial, unstructured
Gender differences in empathic accuracy: Differential ability or differential motivation?
Following their qualitative review of the findings from 10 relevant studies, Graham and Ickes (1997) speculated that reliable gender-of-perceiver differences in empathic accuracy (a) were limited to
Attachment and the Management of Empathic Accuracy in Relationship-Threatening Situations
TLDR
Relative to less anxious persons, highly anxious individuals were more empathically accurate when discussing intimacy issues that posed a potential threat to their relationship and when they were rated as more distressed when discussing a relationship conflict.
When accuracy hurts, and when it helps: a test of the empathic accuracy model in marital interactions.
TLDR
This study tested predictions from W. Ickes and J. A. Simpson's empathic accuracy model on married couples as they tried to resolve a problem in their marriage and found that when the partner's thoughts and feelings were relationship-threatening, greater empathy accuracy on the part of the perceiver was associated with pre-to-posttest declines in the perceIVER's feelings of subjective closeness.
Creating good relationships: responsiveness, relationship quality, and interpersonal goals.
TLDR
Examination of how interpersonal goals initiate responsiveness processes in close relationships, the self-perpetuating nature of these processes, and how responsiveness evolves dynamically over time through both intrapersonal projection and reciprocal interpersonal relationship processes suggest that both projection and reciprocation of responsiveness associated with compassionate goals create upward spiral of responsiveness that ultimately enhance relationship quality for both people.
Empathic Accuracy
People are motivated to understand each other's psychological states as well as each other's personality traits. As a consequence, the more traditional study of accuracy in trait inference can be
Creating and undermining social support in communal relationships: the role of compassionate and self-image goals.
TLDR
Actors' average compassionate and self-image goals interacted to predict changes over 3 weeks in partners' reports of social support received from and given to actors; support that partners gave to actors, in turn, predicted changes in actors' perceived available support, indicating that people with compassionate goals create a supportive environment for themselves and others, but only if they do not have self-images.
When to Use Your Head and When to Use Your Heart
Four studies explored whether perspective-taking and empathy would be differentially effective in mixed-motive competitions depending on whether the critical skills for success were more cognitively
On the difficulty of distinguishing “good” and “poor” perceivers: A social relations analysis of empathic accuracy data
Two studies were conducted to explore the reasons why replicable individual-difference correlates of empathic accuracy have proved so difficult to find. In Study 1, we examined sources of variance in
...
...