Is Competition Such a Good Thing? Static Efficiency versus Dynamic Efficiency

  title={Is Competition Such a Good Thing? Static Efficiency versus Dynamic Efficiency},
  author={Mark Blaug},
  journal={Review of Industrial Organization},
  • M. Blaug
  • Published 1 August 2001
  • Economics
  • Review of Industrial Organization
This paper addresses the rationale for antitrust legislation. It is a striking fact that the legitimacy of antitrust law has been taken for granted inthe United States ever since the Sherman Act of 1890 and, until the advent of the so-called Chicago School, it was even taken for granted by conservativeAmerican economists. Europeans, on the other hand, have always been lukewarm about legal action against trusts and cartels and this attitude is found rightacross the political spectrum in most… 
Structure–Conduct–Performance: A Comment on Blaug's ``Is Competition Such a Good Thing? Static Efficiency versus Dynamic Efficiency''
Blaug (2001) airily announces that, “Empirical science frequently proceeds on the untidy basis of what is plausible rather than what can be formally demonstrated beyond any doubt. The
Mathematical Modelling and Ideology in the Economics Academy: competing explanations of the failings of the modern discipline?
The widespread and long-lived failings of academic economics are due to an over-reliance on largely inappropriate mathematical methods of analysis. This is an assessment I have long maintained. Many
The ethics of efficiency
Efficiency is generally regarded as a value-neutral concept, concerned with assessing whether an economy produces at its possibility frontier, that is, generating maximum possible market output with
Competition policy and the impact of market structure on companies' profitability
Competition policy has a role to ensure equal conditions for all market participants. This policy enables the realization of effective competition, which is a prerequisite for economic and broader
An Evolutionary Efficiency Alternative to the Notion of Pareto Efficiency
The paper argues that the notion of Pareto efficiency builds on two normative assumptions: the more general consequentialist norm of any efficiency criterion, and the strong no-harm principle of the
Competition, Productive Capabilities and Structural Transformation in South Africa
Competition law has been promoted across developing countries as part of a market liberalisation package which is premised on a neo-classical model of competition, privileging static allocative
The Relationship Between Competition and Trust: An Essay in an Historical and Theoretical Perspective
Competition is generally claimed to be good for social welfare, even though this claim is rarely coupled with a plain account of the circumstances under which it is actually true. Both the original
Sustainability and Ethics in the Process of Price Determination in Financial Markets: A Conceptual Analysis
This paper explores how financial markets can support the practical applicability of Sustainability Development Goals (SDGs) principles and why ethics has a central role in this process. The
An Economics-Based Approach to ‘Effective Competition’ in Mexico’s Telecommunications Sector
Our paper seeks to define the term effective competition as used in Mexico’s telecommunications sector and implemented through two main regulatory tools: the determination of preponderance and the


The Firm, the Market, and the Law
Few other economists have been read and cited as often as R.H. Coase has been, even though, as he admits, "most economists have a different way of looking at economic problems and do not share my
Assessing Private Enterprise: An Exegesis of Tangled Doctrine
This paper proposes that the twin theorems of welfare economics provide an insubstantial basis for the faith of many economists that private enterprise is a good way of organizing production. Most
The reasoning of a great methodologist: Mark Blaug on the nature of Paretian welfare economics
SummaryIn various publications Blaug has upheld the view that Paretian welfare economics is normative, sharply criticising the opposite ‘Archibald-Hennipman argument.’ He has failed to refute this
The Methodology of Economics
This book is an examination of the nature of economic explanation. The opening chapters introduce current thinking in the philosophy of science and review the literature on methodology. Professor
Chicago Economics: Permanence and Change
M Y PERCEPTION of Chicago economics is that of participant-observer. As a working economist at Chicago, I have observed other members of the tribe at close hand, and have obtained their critical
The General Theory of Second Best
There is an important basic similarity underlying a number of recent works in apparently widely separated fields of economic theory. Upon examination, it would appear that the authors have been
Walras's Market Models
Walras's Market Models describes and evaluates LA©on Walras's models of competitive markets. Through identification of his career phases and the associated general equilibrium models, which are shown
Perfect Competition and the Transformation of Economics
Frank Machovec argues that the assumption of perfect information has done untold economic damage. It has provided the rationale for active state intervention and has obscured the extent to which
Concepts of Competition
This paper surveys the ways in which competition can promote productive efficiency. Some concepts of competition and their historical development are outlined. There is discussion of the effects of
The Coase Theorem
Anyone who has taught the Coase Theorem to fresh minds has experienced first hand the wonder and admiration which it inspires, yet Coase never wrote it down, and, when others try, it probably turns