Is “chart junk” useful? An extended examination of visual embellishment

@article{Li2014IsJ,
  title={Is “chart junk” useful? An extended examination of visual embellishment},
  author={Huiyang Li and Nadine Marie Moacdieh},
  journal={Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting},
  year={2014},
  volume={58},
  pages={1516 - 1520}
}
  • Huiyang Li, N. Moacdieh
  • Published 1 September 2014
  • Business
  • Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting
Although many well-cited theories or guidelines for visualization design advocate ‘minimalism’, designers tend to include a wide variety of visual embellishments in their charts. Researchers have examined the effects of visual embellishment on comprehension and memorability of charts under specific conditions, such as charts with a small number of data points that were viewed with no time limit (Bateman et al., 2010). This paper extends previous studies and investigates the effects of visual… 

Figures from this paper

Memorability of Enhanced Informational Graphics
TLDR
It was found that enhancements relevant to the data helped in the recall of title and thematic elements, but enhancements did not signifcantly affect recall of specifc data values, which suggests that using relevant enhancements can have a positive effect on memorability of some chart content, but only if the design styles are chosen well to match the information topic.
Infomages: Embedding Data into Thematic Images
TLDR
A design tool is built that links web‐scale image search with a set of interactive image processing tools to empower novice users with the ability to design a wide variety of infomages.
Data Visualization Practitioners’ Perspectives on Chartjunk
TLDR
This investigation uncovers a broad and pluralistic understanding ofChartjunk among practitioners, and foregrounds a variety of personal and situated factors that influence the use of chartjunk beyond context.
Minimalism in Data Visualization: Perceptions of Beauty, Clarity, Effectiveness, and Simplicity
Minimalism in data visualization has been espoused by experts such as Edward Tufte for many years. In this work, minimalism in basic charts, as represented by the data-ink ratio in those charts is
The Influence of Data Storytelling on the Ability to Recall Information
TLDR
This work synthesizes a framework of data storytelling principles with concrete actions for every principle and designs an online, controlled experiment to test compare traditional data visualizations with data storytelling visualizations in terms of their effects on short-term and long-term recall of information displayed in the visualizations.
Figurative frames: A critical vocabulary for images in information visualization
TLDR
A model of the information content of a figurative image, which is used to classify hybrid visualizations along two dimensions, reveals how the figurative images expand the expressiveness of information visualization by integrating descriptive and abstract information and allows the formulation of new measures of visualization quality.
Beyond Memorability: Visualization Recognition and Recall
TLDR
It is shown that visualizations memorable “at-a-glance” are also capable of effectively conveying the message of the visualization, and thus, a memorable visualization is often also an effective one.
Map‐based Visualizations Increase Recall Accuracy of Data
TLDR
Participants in the study recalled the data better when exposed to map‐based visualizations as opposed to node‐link diagrams, and significant differences in the accuracy of the tasks performed persist days after the original exposure to the visualizations.
Towards Understanding Enjoyment and Flow in Information Visualization
TLDR
This paper relates the flow model of Csikszentmihalyi to Munzner's nested model of visualization evaluation and suggests that, even though previous papers tackled individual elements of flow, in order to understand what specifically makes a visualization enjoyable, it might be necessary to measure all specific elements.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 10 REFERENCES
Useful junk?: the effects of visual embellishment on comprehension and memorability of charts
TLDR
It is found that people's accuracy in describing the embellished charts was no worse than for plain charts, and that their recall after a two-to-three-week gap was significantly better, questioning some of the premises of the minimalist approach to chart design.
Benefitting InfoVis with Visual Difficulties
TLDR
This paper characterize effective graph design as a trade-off between efficiency and learning difficulties in order to provide Information Visualization researchers and practitioners with a framework for organizing explorations of graphs for which comprehension and recall are crucial.
What Makes a Visualization Memorable?
TLDR
The largest scale visualization study to date, using 2,070 single-panel visualizations, suggests that quantifying memorability is a general metric of the utility of information, an essential step towards determining how to design effective visualizations.
Designer's Guide to Creating Charts and Diagrams
TLDR
The author teaches how to apply four steps to any task beginning with identifying the reader or user of the chart, selecting a production method, reviewing the numbers, and finding the right symbol around which to design it.
Color, form and luminance capture attention in visual search
Computational modelling of visual attention
TLDR
Five important trends have emerged from recent work on computational models of focal visual attention that emphasize the bottom-up, image-based control of attentional deployment, providing a framework for a computational and neurobiological understanding of visual attention.
Graphic displays in decision making — the visual salience effect
The study investigates the visual salience of information in making differential predictions for alpha-numeric versus graphic displays in consumer decision making. The experiment partially supports
The visual display of quantitative information
TLDR
Med sin høye kompetanse innen informasjonsgrafikk blir Edward Tufte i dag sett på som en av de fremste pioneerene innen faget, og han har blitt tildelt over 40 priser for sine verker.
Nigel Holmes On Information Design
Computational modeling of visual attention
  • Natural Reviews Neuroscience
  • 2001