Irish public histories as an historiographical problem

  title={Irish public histories as an historiographical problem},
  author={John M. Regan},
  journal={Irish Historical Studies},
  pages={265 - 292}
  • J. Regan
  • Published 1 November 2010
  • History
  • Irish Historical Studies
It is now almost impossible to reflect upon the historical reputations of Eamon de Valera and Michael Collins without considering the recent war in Northern Ireland (c. 1969–97) and the challenges to Irish identities it has induced. In the Republic this is evident in the movement away from irredentist nationalism toward official recognition of partition, following a constitutional referendum in 1998. Against a similarly barometric historiography, de Valera and Collins's historical… 

Objective historians, irrational fenians and the bewildered herd: revisionist myth and the Irish revolution

ABSTRACT While many commentators have highlighted the limitations of Irish revisionist historiography, this article offers the first comprehensive and explicitly anti-imperialist critique, locating

Ethnic Cleansing, Ethical Smearing and Irish Historians: Ethnic Cleansing, Ethical Smearing and Irish Historians

Do most academic historians of twentieth-century Ireland conform to a ‘constitutional narrative’, driven by a moral imperative to subvert republican interpretations? Has their shared political agenda

Killing in Cork and the Historians

Across most of the 1970s, eighties and nineties, much of the writing of Irish history seemed consumed by a single great debate. Extending over most periods and topics in the country’s past, dispute

Ireland in British parliamentary debates 1803–2005:Plotting changes in discourse in a large volume of time-series corpus data

This study investigates the changing contexts in which the word ireland appears in the The Hansard Corpus of British Parliamentary debates. It combines the use of two statistical techniques for

New Field, Old Practices: Promises and Challenges of Public History

Although public history is becoming increasingly international, the field remains difficult to define and subject to some criticism. Based on sometimes long-established public practices, public

Negotiating public history in the Republic of Ireland: collaborative, applied and usable practices for the profession

Since the nineteen-seventies public history has emerged as an increasingly coherent discipline in North America, Australia, New Zealand, the U.K. and, latterly, in a wider European context. In all of




  • J. Regan
  • History, Sociology
    The Historical Journal
  • 2007
To what extent has the recent war in Northern Ireland influenced Irish historiography? Examining the nomenclature, periodization, and the use of democracy and state legitimization as interpretative

Michael Collins, General Commanding‐in‐Chief, as a Historiographical Problem

This revisionist article argues the case for recognizing a short-lived military dictatorship in 1922 in southern Ireland under the revolutionary leader Michael Collins. Central to understanding this

A History of Ireland: From the Earliest Times to 1922

Edmund Curtis's remarkable survey of Ireland, from its earliest origins to the twentieth century, is a classic introduction to Ireland's fascinating history. Reaching from St Patrick's Mission in 432

Britain and Ireland 1914-23

This analysis, based on many previously unused primary sources, offers the most authoritative account to date of the formative years of modern Ireland and the final years of the old United Kingdom.

Twentieth-Century Ireland: Nation and State

With the emphasis on the South, this book looks at the island since partition and examines the performances of the two entities created by the collapse of the old Union. The author traces the

Biography of the revolutionary period: Michael Collins and Kevin Barry

The enormous commercial success of Tim Pat Coogan's biography of Michael Collins has demonstrated the continuing fascination with the leading figures of the Irish revolutionary era and the popularity

The Evolution of Irish Nationalist Politics

This classic work studies the growth of nationalism in Ireland from the middle of the eighteenth century to modern times. It traces the continuity of tradition from earlier organisations, such as the

Harry Boland's Irish revolution

Apart from Michael Collins and Eamon de Valera, Harry Boland was probably the most influential organiser of the Irish Republican movement between 1916 and 1922. Already famous as a hurler before

1922, the birth of Irish democracy

This book examines the birth of the Irish state, and sets it in its European historical context. The process of democratic nation-making reached full fruition, while a vicious civil war was raging,

Trials of Irish history : genesis and evolution of a reappraisal, 1938-2000

Part 1: History and Theory in the Irish Debate : Foes or Allies ? 1. The Intellectual Mood in the 1990s 2. The Revisionist : A New Type of Intellectual Part 2: The Genesis of Modern Historical