Inversions in Us Presidential Elections: 1836-2016

  title={Inversions in Us Presidential Elections: 1836-2016},
  author={M. Geruso and Dean Spears and Ishaana Talesara},
  journal={Political Institutions: Elections eJournal},
Inversions—in which the popular vote winner loses the election—have occurred in four US presidential races. We show that rather than being statistical flukes, inversions have been ex ante likely since the early 1800s. In elections yielding a popular vote margin within one point (one-eighth of presidential elections), about 40% will be inversions in expectation. We show this conditional probability is remarkably stable across historical periods—despite differences in which groups voted, which… Expand
The Pathologies of Voting Schemes
In 2016, Trump pulled a shocking upset, winning 306 electoral votes and the presidency, despite losing the popular vote by almost 3 million votes [7]. This phenomenon, where the popular vote winnerExpand
The Effect of Electoral Inversions on Democratic Legitimacy: Evidence from the United States
When a party or candidate loses the popular vote but still wins the election, do voters view the winner as legitimate? This scenario, known as an electoral inversion, can give power to candidates orExpand
Real Effects of Markets on Politics: Evidence from U.S. Presidential Elections
Despite the economic importance of the U.S. stock market, there is strikingly little evidence of its impact on elections. Using county-level variation in stock market participation, we document aExpand
How Likely is it that Courts Will Select the Us President? The Probability of Narrow, Reversible Election Results in the Electoral College Versus a National Popular Vote
Extremely narrow election outcomes—such as could be reversed by rejecting a few thousand ballots—are likely to trigger dispute over the results. Narrow vote tallies may generate recounts andExpand
Measuring gerrymandering by recovering individuals’ preferences and turnout costs
Legislative maps are often evaluated along dimensions of proportionality (the alignment between parties’ seat shares and their stateor nation-wide vote shares) and competitiveness (the fraction ofExpand


Are Presidential Inversions Inevitable? Comparing Eight Counterfactual Rules for Electing the U.S. President*
My research focuses on electoral representation, the convergence of legal and empirical social science, and special emphasis on the geographic constraints and spatial aspects of politics. In additionExpand
Estimating the likelihood of an unpopular verdict in the electoral college
We use historical data to estimate the probability that a presidential candidate could win the popular vote and subsequently lose in the electoral college (a divided verdict). We replicate the modelExpand
Representation, Swing, and Bias in U.S. Presidential Elections, 1872-1988
In this paper we extend the research program on the seats-votes relationship to the U.S. electoral college. Borrowing liberally from the work of King and Browning (1987), we develop measures ofExpand
The architecture of the Electoral College, the House size effect, and the referendum paradox
Abstract Using data from U.S. presidential elections, we show how seemingly insignificant changes to what we call the “architecture” of the Electoral College can cause different candidates to beExpand
Evaluation of a Presidential Election Game
There has been considerable discussion, over the past decade, of the merits of the presidential election system in the United States. In particular, discussion has frequently centered on theExpand
Popular Myths About Popular Vote-Electoral College Splits
An official recount was required to determine the winner of a knifeedged election. A Senate candidate's untimely death resulted, surprisingly and circuitously, in the Democrats picking up an extraExpand
Estimating Partisan Bias of the Electoral College Under Proposed Changes in Elector Apportionment
Abstract In the election for President of the United States, the Electoral College is the body whose members vote to elect the President directly. Each state sends a number of delegates equal to itsExpand
How the Electoral College Influences Campaigns and Policy: The Probability of Being Florida
This paper analyzes how US presidential candidates should allocate resources across states to maximize the probability of winning the election, by developing and estimating a probabilistic-votingExpand
Do Newspapers Serve the State? Incumbent Party Influence on the Us Press, 1869-1928
Using data from 1869 to 1928, we estimate the effect of party control of state governments on the entry, exit, circulation, prices, number of pages, and content of Republican and Democratic dailyExpand
Presidential Selection: Electoral Fallacies*
Serious discussion of the so-called "electoral college"2 was one mi nor casualty of the thirty-six days of legal and political maneuvering accompa nying the Florida recount that ultimately decidedExpand