Interpretation and the Hypothetico-Deductive Method: A Dilemma

  title={Interpretation and the Hypothetico-Deductive Method: A Dilemma},
  author={Christian Folde},
  journal={Journal of Literary Theory},
  pages={58 - 82}
Abstract The Norwegian philosopher Dagfinn Føllesdal and his German colleague Heide Göttner argued independently from one another that the interpretation of literary texts proceeds by the hypothetico-deductive method. In this paper I critically examine their view. My interest, however, is systematic rather than exegetical. After elucidating the claim and working through some case studies, I discuss several objections raised in the debate. My central point is that the view runs into a dilemma… Expand


Validity in Interpretation
By demonstrating the uniformity and universality of the principles of valid interpretation of verbal texts of any sort, this closely reasoned examination provides a theoretical foundation for aExpand
Hypothetico-Deductivism: Incomplete But Not Hopeless
Alleged counter-examples deployed in Park (2004) [Erkenntnis  60: 229–240] against the account of selective hypothetico-deductive confirmation offered in Gemes (1998) [Erkenntnis  49: 1–20] are shownExpand
Hypothetico-deductive confirmation
Hypothetico-deductive (H-D) confirmation builds on the idea that confirming evidence consists of successful predictions that deductively follow from the hypothesis under test. This article reviewsExpand
Revamping Hypothetico-Deductivism: A Dialectic Account of Confirmation
We use recently developed approaches in argumentation theory in order to revamp the hypothetico-deductive model of confirmation, thus alleviating the well-known paradoxes the H-D account faces. MoreExpand
The Logic of Interpretation
One of the more important and controversial problems in contemporary analytic aesthetics concerns the logic of critical interpretation. There appear to be at least three distinguishable, thoughExpand
Hermeneutics and the hypothetico‐deductive method
La these defendue ici, c'est que la methode hermeneutique n'est autre que la methode hypothetico-deductive appliquee a un materiel signifiant (c'est-a-dire a tout ce qui exprime les croyances et/ouExpand
Fiction as a Genre
Standard theories define fiction in terms of an invited response of imagining or make-believe. I argue that these theories are not only subject to numerous counterexamples, they also fail to explainExpand
Literaturwissenschaft und Methodologie
Besprechung zu: Heide Gottner, Logik der Interpretation. Analyse einer literaturewissenschaftlichen Methode unter kritischer Betrachtung der Hermeneutik. (Muncherner Universitats-Schriften. Reihe derExpand
Geburtstag, Meisenheim am Glan
  • Revamping Hypothetico-Deductivism, Erkenntnis
  • 2013
The nature of fiction