Integrative Bioethics: A Conceptually Inconsistent Project

@article{Ivankovi2016IntegrativeBA,
  title={Integrative Bioethics: A Conceptually Inconsistent Project},
  author={Viktor Ivankovi{\'c} and Lovro Savi{\'c}},
  journal={Public Health Law \& Policy eJournal},
  year={2016}
}
This article provides a critical evaluation of the central components of Integrative Bioethics, a project aiming at a bioethical framework reconceptualization. Its proponents claim that this new system of thought has developed a better bioethical methodology than mainstream Western bioethics, a claim that we criticize here. We deal especially with the buzz words of Integrative Bioethics - pluriperspectivism, integrativity, orientational knowledge, as well as with its underlying theory of moral… 
4 Citations
Against the integrative turn in bioethics: burdens of understanding
TLDR
It is claimed that if Integrative Bioethics wants to successfully replace the two existing paradigms, it at least needs to properly address and surmount the lack of common moral vocabulary problem, which points to a semantic incommensurability due to cross-language communication in moral terms.
Do We Need Ethical Theory to Achieve Quality Critical Engagement in Clinical Ethics?
TLDR
It is argued that clinical ethicists should follow MacIntyre in understanding the exploration of alternative traditions and their approaches to problems of clinical ethics as “a work of the imagination” and take up imagined perspectives, which will remain important in allowing committee members from competing traditions to better understand one another's arguments.
A MacIntyrean Critique of Theoretical Pluralism in Applied Ethics
  • Brandon Boesch
  • Sociology, Medicine
    The American journal of bioethics : AJOB
  • 2016

References

SHOWING 1-4 OF 4 REFERENCES
From integrative bioethics to pseudoscience.
TLDR
Although presented as a project that promises to deal with moral dilemmas created by modern science and technology, integrative bioethics does not contain the slightest normativity or action-guiding capacity.
The loss of knowledge in the information age
TLDR
An information society is a form of a society or economy in which the production, storage, processing, exchange, distribution, and the use of information and knowledge in the form of data are playing an increasingly dominant role.
Argument Und Einsicht. Orientierungswissen Als Begr€ undungswissen?
  • 2005