Institutionalizing delay: foundation funding and the creation of U.S. climate change counter-movement organizations

  title={Institutionalizing delay: foundation funding and the creation of U.S. climate change counter-movement organizations},
  author={Robert J. Brulle},
  journal={Climatic Change},
This paper conducts an analysis of the financial resource mobilization of the organizations that make up the climate change counter-movement (CCCM) in the United States. Utilizing IRS data, total annual income is compiled for a sample of CCCM organizations (including advocacy organizations, think tanks, and trade associations). These data are coupled with IRS data on philanthropic foundation funding of these CCCM organizations contained in the Foundation Center’s data base. This results in a… Expand

Figures from this paper

Obstructing action: foundation funding and US climate change counter-movement organizations
In a 2016 congressional hearing on the climate crisis, Senator SheldonWhitehouse (D-RI) held up a book entitled Why Scientists Disagree About Climate Change and asked: “Who funded this phony climateExpand
Corporate Climate Policy-planning in the Global Polity: A Network Analysis
Alongside the climate change denial movement, a section of the capitalist class has been organizing to promote a project of “climate capitalism” that relies on carbon markets and other policiesExpand
Strategic philanthropy in the post‐Cap‐and‐Trade years: Reviewing U.S. climate and energy foundation funding
Edited by Mike Hulme, Editor-in-Chief For several decades, philanthropists in the United States have played a behind-thescenes role in framing climate change as a social problem. These foundationsExpand
Another avenue of action: an examination of climate change countermovement industries’ use of PAC donations and their relationship to Congressional voting over time
ABSTRACT The political mobilization of American business elites in the 1970s and 1980s has been well studied by political scientists. Environmental sociologists have explored how industries in thisExpand
‘For us climate action never dies’: a legislative process analysis of environmental movement tactics in Oregon
ABSTRACT In this article, I discuss how environmental groups in Oregon have intervened in the legislative process in the last 5 years to advocate for climate policy. Methodologically, I draw on 76Expand
Elite networks for environmental philanthropy: shaping environmental agendas in the twenty-first century
ABSTRACT Examining all donations of one-million dollars or more to environmental and animal-related causes from 2000–10 in the U.S., this paper employs network methodologies to identify structuralExpand
Nation’s Business and the environment: the U.S. Chamber’s changing relationships with DDT, “ecologists,” regulations, and renewable energy
Nation’s Business was a monthly business magazine published by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, with a subscription list larger than Business Week, Forbes, or Fortune. This study explores how theExpand
Class capacities and climate politics: Coal and conflict in the United States energy policy-planning network
  • R. Wishart
  • Business
  • Energy Research & Social Science
  • 2019
Abstract This article employs a power structure research approach and exploratory network analysis to describe the differing stances on climate action that existed within the United States eliteExpand
Corporate funding and ideological polarization about climate change
  • J. Farrell
  • Political Science, Medicine
  • Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
  • 2015
This research demonstrates how polarization efforts are influenced by a patterned network of political and financial actors, and highlights the important influence of private funding in public knowledge and politics, and provides researchers a methodological model for future studies that blend large-scale textual discourse with social networks. Expand
‘Time to Wake Up’: Climate change advocacy in a polarized Congress, 1996-2015
ABSTRACT Scholars who study the failure of climate change policy in the United States tend to focus on the mechanics of denial and the coordinated efforts of political operatives, conservative thinkExpand


Changes in U.S. environmental policy direction under the Bush Administration reflect two interdependent trends that have emerged over the past two decades: an increased capability among corporationsExpand
Defeating Kyoto: The conservative movement's impact on U.S. climate change policy
In this article, we argue that a major reason the United States failed to ratify the Kyoto Protocol to ameliorate global warming is the opposition of the American conservative movement, a key segmentExpand
Climate Change Policy
Having risen from relative obscurity as few as ten years ago, climate change now looms large among environmental policy issues. Its scope is global; the potential environmental and economic impactsExpand
A Neo‐Gramscian Approach to Corporate Political Strategy: Conflict and Accommodation in the Climate Change Negotiations*
A neo-Gramscian theoretical framework for corporate political strategy is developed drawing from Gramsci's analysis of the relations among capital, social forces, and the state, and from moreExpand
American Foundations: Roles and Contributions
Foundations play an essential part in the philanthropic activity that defines so much of American life. No other nation provides its foundations with so much autonomy and freedom of action as doesExpand
Resource Mobilization Theory and the Study of Social Movements
Resource mobilization theory has recently presented an alternative interpretation of social movements. The review traces the emergence and recent controversies generated by this new perspective. AExpand
Countermovements and Conservative Movements in the Contemporary U.S.
Research on social movements continues to be a vigorous and theoretically significant field. Marx & Wood's review article (1975) indicated the growth of research on leftist movements, such as theExpand
Challenging global warming as a social problem: An analysis of the conservative movement's counter-claims
The sociological literature on global environmental change emphasizes the processes by which the problem of global warming is socially constructed. However, the opposing efforts to construct theExpand
Talk of the Enemy: Adversarial Framing and Climate Change Discourse
This article provides a comparative analysis of adversarial framing oriented to reputation discrediting in the context of social movement/counter-movement relations. Website material associated withExpand
World Energy Outlook 2012
  • Aie
  • Business
  • 2012
Industry and government decision-makers and others with a stake in the energy sector all need WEO-2012. It presents authoritative projections of energy trends through to 2035 and insights into whatExpand