'Information is information': a public perspective on incidental findings in clinical and research genome-based testing.


The potential for genomic incidental findings is increasing with the use of genome-based testing. At the same time approaches to clinical decision making are shifting to shared decision-making models involving both the healthcare community and the public. The public's voice has been nearly absent in discussions on managing incidental findings. We conducted nine focus groups and nine interviews (n = 63) with a broad cross-section of lay public groups to elucidate public viewpoints on incidental findings that could occur as a result of genome-based testing in clinical and research situations. Data were analyzed using qualitative content analysis. Participants wanted incidental findings disclosed to them whether or not these were clinical or research findings. Participants used different terms to define and describe incidental findings; they wanted to know that incidental findings are possible and be given a choice to learn about them. Personal utility was an important reason for disclosure, and participants believed that managing information is a shared responsibility between professionals and themselves. Broad public input is needed in order to understand and incorporate the public's perspective on management of incidental findings as disclosure guidelines, and policies are developed in clinical and research settings.

DOI: 10.1111/cge.12167

4 Figures and Tables

Citations per Year

358 Citations

Semantic Scholar estimates that this publication has 358 citations based on the available data.

See our FAQ for additional information.

Cite this paper

@article{DaackHirsch2013InformationII, title={'Information is information': a public perspective on incidental findings in clinical and research genome-based testing.}, author={Sandra E. Daack-Hirsch and Martha Driessnack and Alyson E Hanish and Victoria Anne Johnson and Lisa L. Shah and Christian M. Simon and Janet K. D. Williams}, journal={Clinical genetics}, year={2013}, volume={84 1}, pages={11-8} }