Corpus ID: 169142411

Inexpressible Truths and the Allure of the Knowledge Argument

  title={Inexpressible Truths and the Allure of the Knowledge Argument},
  author={Benj Hellie},
Dualism is a perpetually seductive doctrine; the Knowledge Argument for dualism (Jackson, 1982) a particularly alluring source of support for the doctrine. Jackson advocated the soundness of the argument for nearly two decades before changing his mind; I and many of my comrades, before we became sophisticated, found the allure of the argument as Jackson presents it hard to avoid; many other philosophers doubtless have had this experience as well. And, as Stoljar and Nagasawa (2003, §§1–2… Expand
Semantic gaps and protosemantics B enj H ellie December
A ‘semantic gap’ divides two regions of language when the meanings on the one side are very different from those the other. The gap considered here divides language about the physical (quotidian orExpand
Factive Phenomenal Characters
The central focus of this article is on a doctrine in the philosophy of perceptual consciousness I call Phenomenal Naivete, and a paradox associated with that doctrine. Phenomenal Naivete is a sortExpand
Anti-individualism and Phenomenal Content
The paper addresses a prima facie tension between two popular views about concepts. The first is the doctrine that some concepts are constitutively perceptual/experiential, so that they can beExpand
There's something about Mary : essays on phenomenal consciousness and Frank Jackson's knowledge argument
In Frank Jackson's famous thought experiment, Mary is confined to a black-and-white room and educated through black-and-white books and lectures on a black-and-white television. In this way, sheExpand
The Knowledge Argument Against Physicalism
  • 2020
The knowledge argument is one of the main challenges to physicalism, the doctrine that the world is entirely physical. The argument begins with the claim that there are truths about consciousnessExpand
There are no phenomenal concepts
It has long been widely agreed that some concepts can be possessed only by those who have undergone a certain type of phenomenal experience. Orthodoxy among contemporary philosophers of mind has itExpand
Higher-order theories of consciousness and what-it-is-like-ness
How HO theorists must understand the two crucial notions if they are to reject the misrepresentation argument but assert the awareness argument is examined, and it shows that HO theorists can and do adopt an understanding—the HO reading—which seems to give them what they want. Expand
An Externalist’s Guide to Inner Experience
The aim of John M. Hinton’s Experiences: An Inquiry into Some Ambiguities is set out in its introduction as follows: Someone who has more sympathy with traditional empiricism than with much ofExpand
`There's Something It's Like' and the Structure of Consciousness
For an experience to be phenomenally conscious is for there to be something it’s like; our talk about phenomenal consciousness accordingly is permeated by the expression ‘there’s something it’sExpand
Imagining subjective absence: Marcus on zombies
Abstract The claim that zombies are conceivable is a premise of one of the most important anti-physicalist arguments. Eric Marcus (2004) challenges that premise in two novel ways. He observes thatExpand


Papers in metaphysics and epistemology
Introduction 1. New Work for a theory of universals 2. Putnam's paradox 3. Against structural universals 4. A comment on Armstrong and Forrest 5. Extrinsic properties 6. Defining 'intrinsic' (withExpand
Knowing who
Propositional knowledge is the knowledge attributed by sentences of the form 'x knows that p'. Knowing where to F, knowing why to F, and knowing when to F are all definable in terms of propositionalExpand
A Treatise of Human Nature
PART 1: INTRODUCTORY MATERIAL. How to Use this Book. List of Abbreviations. Editor's Introduction. Hume's Early years and Education. A Treatise of Human Nature. Book 1: Of the Understanding. Book 1Expand
What Is It Like to Be a Bat?
Introduction: Thomas Nagel was born in Belgrade, Yugoslavia, in 1937. He came to the United States in 1939 and became a naturalized citizen five years later. After completing his undergraduate degreeExpand
Color and the Inverted Spectrum
We argue that the extant versions of the inverted spectrum argument are unsound and that any possible version must also be. We outline a conceptual role semantics for color perception and give anExpand
Experience Teaches
  • Nature
  • 1914
IT may be doubted if many young people read books of advice as to conduct, and probably this chatty volume will prove of most assistance to parents and teachers whose duty it often is to offer wordsExpand
Explaining Objective Color in Terms of Subjective Reactions
I am concerned with attempts to explain objective color in terms of subjective reactions so I had better begin by saying what I mean by "objective color" and what I mean by "subjective reactions". ByExpand
Readings on Color: The Philosophy of Color Vol. I
An end insulator for a power distribution system of the type providing an essentially continuous convenience outlet enabling electrical plugs to be connected thereto at substantially any selectedExpand
Should a Materialist Believe in Qualia
What Mary Didn't Know