In science communication, why does the idea of a public deficit always return? How do the shifting information flows in healthcare affect the deficit model of science communication?

@article{Ko2016InSC,
  title={In science communication, why does the idea of a public deficit always return? How do the shifting information flows in healthcare affect the deficit model of science communication?},
  author={Henry Ko},
  journal={Public Understanding of Science},
  year={2016},
  volume={25},
  pages={427 - 432}
}
  • Henry Ko
  • Published 26 April 2016
  • Medicine, Political Science
  • Public Understanding of Science
The healthcare field contains a multitude of opportunities for science communication. Given the many stakeholders dancing together in a multidirectional tango of communication, we need to ask how much does the deficit model apply to the health field? History dictates that healthcare professionals are the holders of all knowledge, and the patients and other stakeholders are the ones that need the scientific information communicated to them. This essay argues otherwise, in part due to the rise of… 

How the information deficit model helps create unidirectional and paternalistic mode of healthcare communication

  • Medicine
    Journal of Communication in Healthcare
  • 2018
TLDR
Two communication challenges pediatricians routinely face are discussions about vaccines with reluctant parents and weight loss counseling and the information deficit model, which originated by social scientists in the 1970s in the context of discussion about science and technology with the public.

Critical topics and good practices for trust in science communication before and during the COVID-19 pandemic

TLDR
A ‘strong’ consensus is revealed about good practices promoting trust in scicomm (mainly based on direct interactions with targeted audiences), and about critical topics where trust plays a key role, before and during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Translating antimicrobial resistance: a case study of context and consequences of antibiotic-related communication in three northern Thai villages

TLDR
This study challenges the current dominance of awareness-raising campaigns to change population behaviours and calls for comprehensive mixed-method evaluations of future campaigns, mandatory two-directional knowledge exchange components, and alternative behaviour change approaches that respond to contextual constraints like precarity rather than alleged knowledge deficits.

Lessons Learned from a Writing to Learn Program for Public Health Students at the University of Tokyo

TLDR
There was a curse of knowledge (ie, difficulties to imagine the state of mind of not knowing when knowing something) among students, and debiasing this curse ofknowledge among students will be the main target of the writing education.

Strengthening public engagement on environmental hazards: insights from cross-disciplinary air pollution research

ABSTRACT Studying air pollution provides an opportunity to explore public opinion about the environment from a health perspective, and examine how the often-siloed fields of health, environmental,

Expertise and communicating about infectious disease: a case study of uncertainty and rejection of local knowledge in discourse of experts and decision makers

TLDR
It is asserted that more inclusive, reflective and ultimately more effective risk communication practices will result if the legitimacy of diverse knowledge sources and the inevitability of uncertainty are acknowledged.

Creative (Climate) Communications

Conversations about climate change at the science-policy interface and in our lives have been stuck for some time. This handbook integrates lessons from the social sciences and humanities to more

Editorial: Are We All Better-than-Average Drivers, and Better-than-Average Kissers? Outwitting the Kruger-Dunning Effect in Clinical Practice and Research.

  • S. Leopold
  • Medicine
    Clinical orthopaedics and related research
  • 2019
TLDR
The Kruger–Dunning effect carries at least three important implications for orthopaedic surgeons: (1) How to disseminate (and learn) new surgical techniques; (2) how to convince patients that unproven treatments they think they need are not as good as they believe; and (3) why discredited treatments persist in common orthopedic practice.

What do people know about climate change ― and how confident are they? On measurements and analyses of science related knowledge

The measurement and analysis of people's knowledge on scientific topics, such as climate change, is challenging for researchers. One reason is that objectives are multi-dimensional and that

Epistemic engagement: examining personal epistemology and engagement preferences with climate change in Oregon

Engaging politically polarized publics surrounding climate science is a vital element in the effort to enact climate mitigation policy. Science communication experts have identified several models of

References

SHOWING 1-4 OF 4 REFERENCES

The public production and sharing of medical information. An Australian perspective

TLDR
There is a wealth of medical information now available to the public through various sources that are not necessarily controlled by medical or healthcare professionals, but there needs to be caution about the use of publicly available scientific information to further the agenda of special-interest groups and lobbying groups to advance often biased and unproven opinions or for scaremongering.

Public understanding of drug therapy.

  • A. Herxheimer
  • Medicine
    British journal of clinical pharmacology
  • 2012
TLDR
Knowing some basic principles about medicines would help patients to understand drug therapy and to help and encourage them to use it well, and Conversations between patients and professionals would become more effective and help shared decision making.

Brief Summary and Adequate Directions for Use: Disclosing Risk Information in Consumer-Directed Print Advertisements and Promotional Labeling for Prescription Drugs. Guidance for industry

  • 2015