Implementing partisan symmetry: Problems and paradoxes

  title={Implementing partisan symmetry: Problems and paradoxes},
  author={Daryl R. DeFord and Natasha Dhamankar and Moon Duchin and Varun Gupta and Mackenzie McPike and Gabe Schoenbach and Ki Wan Sim},
  journal={Political Analysis},
We consider the measures of partisan symmetry proposed for practical use in the political science literature, as clarified and developed in Katz-King-Rosenblatt. Elementary mathematical manipulation shows the symmetry metrics derived from uniform partisan swing to have surprising properties. To accompany the general analysis, we study measures of partisan symmetry with respect to recent voting patterns in Utah, Texas, and North Carolina, flagging problems in each case. Taken together, these… 

Figures from this paper

A Computational Approach to Measuring Vote Elasticity and Competitiveness
Examining several classes of competitiveness metrics motivated by recent reform proposals and then evaluating their potential outcomes across large ensembles of districting plans at the Congressional and state Senate levels demonstrates the importance of avoiding writing detailed metric constraints into long-lasting constitutional reform and carrying out careful mathematical modeling on real geo-electoral data in each redistricting cycle.
Assessing congressional districting in Maine and New Hampshire
We use voting precinct and election data to analyze the political geography of New Hampshire and Maine. We find that the location of dividing line between Congressional districts in both states are
Mathematical Analysis of Redistricting in Utah
This work investigates the claim that the Utah congressional districts enacted in 2011 represent an unfair Republican gerrymander, and proposes a new metric of partisan fairness in Utah, namely, the Republican vote share in the least-Republican district.
Colorado in Context: Congressional Redistricting and Competing Fairness Criteria in Colorado
A large random sample of reasonable redistricting plans are generated and the partisan balance of each district is determined using returns from state-wide elections in 2018, and the 2011/2012 enacted districts are analyzed in this context.
The Essential Role of Statistical Inference in Evaluating Electoral Systems: A Response to DeFord et al.
Katz, King, and Rosenblatt (2020) introduces a theoretical framework for understanding redistricting and electoral systems, built on basic statistical and social science principles of inference.
The Geography and Election Outcome (GEO) Metric: An Introduction
We introduce the Geography and Election Outcome (GEO) metric, a new method for identifying potential partisan gerrymanders. In contrast with currently popular methods, the GEO metric uses both


Theoretical Foundations and Empirical Evaluations of Partisan Fairness in District-Based Democracies
We clarify the theoretical foundations of partisan fairness standards for district-based democratic electoral systems, including essential assumptions and definitions not previously recognized,
Democratic Representation and Partisan Bias in Congressional Elections
The translation of citizen votes into legislative seats is of central importance in democratic electoral systems. It has been a longstanding concern among scholars in political science and in
Representation, Swing, and Bias in U.S. Presidential Elections, 1872-1988
In this paper we extend the research program on the seats-votes relationship to the U.S. electoral college. Borrowing liberally from the work of King and Browning (1987), we develop measures of
Unfair Partisan Gerrymanders in Politics and Law: A Diagnostic Applied to Six Cases
Abstract We propose standards for detecting partisan gerrymandering as a finding of fact and for determining whether the factual finding is legally significant. The standard is grounded in the U.S.
The Future of Partisan Symmetry as a Judicial Test for Partisan Gerrymandering after LULAC v. Perry
While the Supreme Court in Bandemer v. Davis found partisan gerrymandering to be justiciable, no challenged redistricting plan in the subsequent 20 years has been held unconstitutional on partisan ...
Measures of Partisan Bias for Legislating Fair Elections
Abstract Several measures of partisan bias are reviewed for single member districts with two dominant parties. These include variants of the simple bias that considers only deviation of seats from
Measures of Partisan Bias for Legislating Fair Elections
Several measures of partisan bias are reviewed for single member districts with two dominant parties. These include variants of the simple bias that considers only deviation of seats from 50% at
Locating the Representational Baseline: Republicans in Massachusetts
Republican candidates often receive between 30 and 40 percent of the two-way vote share in statewide elections in Massachusetts. For the last three Census cycles, MA has held 9-10 seats in the House
Recombination: A family of Markov chains for redistricting
This paper sets up redistricting as a graph partition problem and introduces a new family of Markov chains called Recombination (or ReCom) on the space of graph partitions and presents evidence that ReCom mixes efficiently, especially in contrast to the slow-mixing Flip, and provides experiments that demonstrate its qualitative behavior.
GitHub repository
  • 2020