IN DEFENSE OF SINICIZATION : A REBUTTAL OF EVELYN RAWSKI'S REENVISIONING THE QING

@article{Ho1998INDO,
  title={IN DEFENSE OF SINICIZATION : A REBUTTAL OF EVELYN RAWSKI'S REENVISIONING THE QING},
  author={Ping-ti Ho},
  journal={The Journal of Asian Studies},
  year={1998},
  volume={57},
  pages={123-155}
}
  • P. Ho
  • Published 1 February 1998
  • History
  • The Journal of Asian Studies
In her recent presidential address, “Reenvisioning the Qing,” Professor Evelyn Sakakida Rawski attacks the “sinicization” theme originally presented as one of the five major aspects of my 1967 article, “The Significance of the Ch'ing Period in Chinese History” (Ho 1967). In her essay—frankly admitted to have been based exclusively on “recent secondary literature”—she states that “a notable outcome of the new scholarship is the rejection of the sinicization thesis and its Han-centered… Expand
The Shun-chih Reign
The Shun-chih reign is poorly documented and understood period. This chapter describes the process of political and military consolidation and the integration of the Han Chinese scholar-officialExpand
Cultural Identity and Local Self-Government
Until recently, the study of Chinese historical writings of the 1920s and 1930s has centered on “the May Fourth approach to history,” especially the Doubting Antiquity Movement (yigu yundong) led byExpand
The Board of Rites and the Making of Qing China
State ritual in late imperial China has been a familiar topic to Qing historians, but Macabe Keliher’s new book brings a fresh and important perspective to our understanding of the subject. In manyExpand
Defending Christianity in China: the Jesuit defense of Christianity in the lettres edifiantes et Curieuses & Ruijianlu in relation to the Yongzheng proscription of 1724
Jesuits presented evidence in both French and Chinese to defend Christianity by citation of legal and historical precedents in favor of the “Teaching of the Lord of Heaven” (Catholicism) even afterExpand
New Qing History: Dispute, Dialog, and Influence
This article studies the New Qing History approach that arose in the US in the 1980s and the ensuing responses to it, and how these responses can be understood in the context of American ChinaExpand
Myth of ethnic conflict and ethnic revolutions, 1644–1911
There has been a long-entrenched view that China’s Qing Dynasty was a ‘Manchu Dynasty’, which imposed alien conquest on China’s majority of the ethnic Han. Such a view has made the Manchus allegedlyExpand
History, Space, and Ethnicity: The Chinese Worldview
In writing this article, I attempt to answer two interrelated questions: ( i ) What was the Chinese perception of the world, or world history, before China came into close contact with the rest ofExpand
Can the Chinese Nation Be One? Gu Jiegang, Chinese Muslims, and the Reworking of Culturalism
This article examines how the classicist and folklorist Gu Jiegang, in conversation with his Hui (Chinese Muslim) colleagues at the Yugong study society and journal (published 1934–1937), theorizedExpand
Agony over national–imperial identity: Interpreting the coloniality of the Chinese New Left
European thought, rather than an overarching ideology imposed on the colonized, offers a concatenation of keywords and narratives for people to imagine their national community, yet, sometimesExpand
Agony over national–imperial identity: Interpreting the coloniality of the Chinese New Left
European thought, rather than an overarching ideology imposed on the colonized, offers a concatenation of keywords and narratives for people to imagine their national community, yet, sometimesExpand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 25 REFERENCES
The Buddhist conquest of China
"The reprinting in 2007 of a book originally produced nearly fifty years earlier (and based on a doctoral dissertation begun in the early 1950s) is not merely a publishing event. It constitutes aExpand
The Presidential Address: The Chinese Civilization: A Search for the Roots of Its Longevity
t he longevity of Chinese civilization is generally conceded to be a unique phenomenon in world history; as such it has evoked explanations ranging from the plausible to the esoteric. A search forExpand
Thinking About Ethnicity in Early Modern China
��� "Ethnicity," whatever one may mean by it, has emerged as a seminal issue in historical, sociological and cultural exchange. It has become a catchphrase whose elasticity is in some ways welcome,Expand
Books of Revelations: The Importance of the Manchu Language Archival Record Books for Research on Ch'ing History
The received wisdom on the Manchu language archives of the Ch'ing dynasty has been that historians of the Ch'ing have little need either to learn Manchu or to use Manchu materials for research onExpand
A History of Chinese Civilization
Written with an elegant and flowing narrative, the essential virtue of Jacques Gernet's classic book is to see the history of Chinese civilization as a whole. Yet within the synthesis of the trends -Expand
Muslim Chinese : ethnic nationalism in the People's Republic
Part 1 Muslim nationalism in China - a fourth tide: Qing Zhen - expressions of Hui identity state power and the evolution of an ethnonym the problem - who are the Hui? sociocultural diversity amongExpand
The Significance of the Ch'ing Period in Chinese History
Although the Ch'ing period is generally regarded as one of the better studied and understood periods of Chinese history, the existing fund of our knowledge is actually far from adequate. A systematicExpand
Khubilai Khan : His Life and Times
Living from 1215 to 1294, Khubilai Khan is one of history's most renowned figures. Morris Rossabi draws on sources from a variety of East Asian, Middle Eastern, and European languages as he focusesExpand
Presidential Address: Reenvisioning the Qing: The Significance of the Qing Period in Chinese History
L'auteur evalue dans cet article les progres realises dans de recentes etudes sur l'empire des Qing, grâce a un acces a de nouvelles sources chinoises et mandchoues, en particulier sur le debut deExpand
...
1
2
3
...