I Want You! The Determinants of Military Conscription

  title={I Want You! The Determinants of Military Conscription},
  author={Victor Asal and Justin Conrad and Nathan W. Toronto},
  journal={Journal of Conflict Resolution},
  pages={1456 - 1481}
What explains the use of military conscription? Using a new data set of more than 100 countries over a period of 200 years, we examine the determinants of a state’s decision to implement a military draft. We argue that the decision to use conscription is largely dependent on historical factors. Specifically, we contend that former British colonies are less likely to use conscription as a means of military recruitment because of an anticonscription precedent set during the English Civil War. We… 

Tables from this paper

The martial origins of democracy: a global study of military conscription and suffrage extensions since the Napoleonic wars
ABSTRACT This article examines the relationship between conscription (the compulsory enlistment of civilians for military service) and democracy. Using the best available cross-country comparable
Public Support for the Armed Forces: The Role of Conscription
ABSTRACT How does conscription influence citizens’ support for the armed forces? We argue that conscription, more so than voluntary-recruitment systems, can reach out to and socialize larger segments
Markets and Manpower
Economic studies of military manpower systems emphasize the advantages of voluntarism under all but the most total threats, but this explains neither the persistence of institutionalized conscription
Patrons and Personnel: The Determinants of Military Recruitment Policies
This dissertation examines why some states develop conscript militaries while others rely solely on volunteers. I argue that two variables determine what recruitment decisions states make when
Military conscription, external security, and income inequality: The missing link
This article seeks to analyze the political economy of military conscription policy and its relationship with a country’s external security environment. National security is modeled as a
How leaders’ experiences and rebellion shape military recruitment during civil war
The use of forced recruitment strategies during war can adversely affect military effectiveness and human rights. Given these costs, under what conditions do state leaders adopt coercive recruitment
Explaining the worldwide decline in the length of mandatory military service, 1970–2010
Compulsory military service has declined considerably since 1970. This explained by changes on both the extensive and intensive margins by governments. While the decision to use conscription for
Why They Fight: How Perceived Motivations for Military Service Shape Support for the Use of Force
What shapes public support for military missions? Existing scholarship points to, on the one hand, individuals’ affiliations and predispositions (such as political partisanship and gender), and, on
Filling the Ranks: The Remplacement Militaire in Post-Revolutionary France
Many economists have analyzed the efficiency of a volunteered army relative to a conscripted army. However, they have rarely studied the working of real-world alternative, market-based, military
Territorial threat and women’s legislative representation
ABSTRACT Why do some countries have fewer women in parliament than do others? Recent studies find that women have less access to positions of political power in countries facing external threats.


Military conscription as a means of stabilizing democratic regimes
Previous studies on the determinants of military conscription have found no association between the level of democracy and conscription. This paper argues that the stability of democratic
More Than Meets the Eye
At first glance, Britain’s decision in 1957 to end conscription appears to be explainable solely by external factors since that change coincided with the decision of Harold Macmillan’s government to
Dangerous Drafts? A Time-Series, Cross-National Analysis of Conscription and the Use of Military Force, 1946—2001
Conscription has been claimed to both increase leaders’ propensity to use military force abroad and constrain them from doing so. The author sheds new light on this longstanding controversy by
Conscription as Regulation
We examine the practice of military conscription around the world from the perspective of two standard theories, and a new one, which emphasizes the fixed cost of introducing and administering the
Conscription and Democracy: The Mythology of Civil— Military Relations
The assumption of a mutually conditional relationship between democracy and conscription is a persistent aspect of the debate on civil—military relations. This article discusses the relationship
Raising an Army: A Positive Theory of Military Recruitment
  • T. W. Ross
  • Economics
    The Journal of Law and Economics
  • 1994
THIs essay presents and tests a positive theory of the choice between conscription and voluntarism as means to supply manpower to the military. These systems have coexisted for centuries, and neither
Civil-Military Relations and the End of Conscription in France
LIKE MILITARY doctrine or weapons acquisition, military structure and systems of recruitment are critical components of national military policy and deeply affect the security of the state that
Drafting Community: Understanding the Fate of Conscription
Discussion about the fate of conscription has focused on whether structural trends are undermining its viability. This article takes another point of departure, arguing that the fate of conscription
Drafting Support for War: Conscription and Mass Support for Warfare
How does a military’s recruitment policy—whether a country has a draft or conscript army—influence mass support for war? We investigate how military recruitment affects the way the American public