Hume's Experimental Method

  title={Hume's Experimental Method},
  author={Tam{\'a}s Demeter},
  journal={British Journal for the History of Philosophy},
  pages={577 - 599}
  • T. Demeter
  • Published 1 May 2012
  • Philosophy
  • British Journal for the History of Philosophy
In this article I attempt to reconstruct David Hume's use of the label ‘experimental’ to characterise his method in the Treatise. Although its meaning may strike the present-day reader as unusual, such a reconstruction is possible from the background of eighteenth-century practices and concepts of natural inquiry. As I argue, Hume's inquiries into human nature are experimental not primarily because of the way the empirical data he uses are produced, but because of the way those data are… 

Prescription, Description, and Hume's Experimental Method

There seems a potential tension between Hume's naturalistic project and his normative ambitions. Hume adopts what I call a methodological naturalism: that is, the methodology of providing

Four Methods of Empirical Inquiry in the Aftermath of Newton’s Challenge

In this paper I distinguish four methods of empirical inquiry in eighteenth century natural philosophy. In particular, I distinguish among what I call, (i) the mathematical-experimental method; (ii)

Liberty, necessity and the foundations of Hume’s ‘science of man’

  • T. Demeter
  • Philosophy, Education
    History of the human sciences
  • 2012
In this article I suggest that section VIII of Hume’s Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding could be read as a contribution to the foundational issues of a characteristic 18th-century enterprise,

Newtonian and Non-Newtonian Elements in Hume

For the last forty years, Hume's Newtonianism has been a debated topic in Hume scholarship. The crux of the matter can be formulated by the following question: Is Hume a Newtonian philosopher?

Hume's experimental psychology and the idea of erroneous preferences

  • R. Sugden
  • Psychology, Philosophy
    Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization
  • 2020

Hume’s (Ad Hoc?) Appeal to the Calm Passions

  • Hsueh Qu
  • Philosophy
    Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie
  • 2018
Abstract Hume argues that whenever we seem to be motivated by reason, there are unnoticed calm passions that play this role instead, a move that is often criticised as ad hoc (e. g. Stroud 1977 and

Before the Two Cultures: Merging the Canons of the History of Science and Philosophy

This article argues that early modern philosophy should be seen as an integrated enterprise of moral and natural philosophy. Consequently, early modern moral and natural philosophy should be taught

Economic and Sociological Accounts of Social Norms

Abstract Classifying accounts of institutionalized social norms that rely on individual rule-following as ‘sociological’ and accounts based on individual opportunity-seeking behavior as ‘economic’,

Algunas precisiones acerca de la filosofía moral experimental de David Hume

pesar de que existe un consenso entre los estudiosos respecto de establecer una filiacion entre Hume y la filosofia experimental, prevalecen importantes divergencias al momento de determinar el


RESUMEN Existe cierta interpretación restringida de la metodología humeana que entiende su experimentalismo únicamente en términos de la reducción de los enunciados epistémicos a impresiones



Hume's vitalism and its implications

The subject of this paper is David Hume’s ‘vitalism’. By this I mean the thesis expressed as follows in the essay ‘Of Interest’: ‘There is no craving or demand of the human mind more constant and

Mechanism and Materialism: British Natural Philosophy in an Age of Reason

Robert Schofield demonstrates that mechanistic concepts dominated interpretations from about 1687 to 1740, when they were replaced by materialistic concepts.

The Natural History of Man in the Scottish Enlightenment

Although the Enlightenment is commonly considered to be the age of Newton, historians of the period would probably now agree that it should also be regarded as the age of natural history. For as

An Essay concerning Human Understanding

IT is possible to appreciate the reason for this abridged edition of Locke's great Essay and at the same time to regret its appearance. If it had to be done, no living philosopher is so qualified to

A Note on Newton, Boyle, and Hume's "Experimental Method"

Etude du debat scientifique sur la relation de Hume a Newton, a travers la question de la methode experimentale heritee du newtonianisme. Defendant l'interpretation standard du probleme contre la

Mathematical vs. Experimental Traditions in the Development of Physical Science

Mathematical vs. Experimental Traditions in the Development of Physical Science Anyone who studies the history of scientific development repeatedly encounters a question, one version of which would

Vitalizing nature in the Enlightenment

Acknowledgments Introduction Prologue: The Humboldt Brothers Confront Nature's Sublimity 1. Storming "the Temple of Error": Buffon, the Historie naturelle, and the Midcentury Origins of Enlightenment

Speculative Truth: Henry Cavendish, Natural Philosophy, and the Rise of Modern Theoretical Science

List of Illustrations Preface and Acknowledgments Introduction PART ONE. NATURAL PHILOSOPHY 1. Natural Philosophers 2. Philosophies 3. Theories PART TWO. A GREAT QUESTION 4. Historical Setting of

A Study of History

OINCE it is commonly agreed that western civilisation has now reached a supreme crisis in its history, since disillusionment, rife among laymen and men of science alike, is poisoning the well-springs

Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding

Copyright ©2010–2015 All rights reserved. Jonathan Bennett [Brackets] enclose editorial explanations. Small ·dots· enclose material that has been added, but can be read as though it were part of the