Human rights derogation during coup situations

  title={Human rights derogation during coup situations},
  author={Ignatius Yordan Nugraha},
  journal={The International Journal of Human Rights},
  pages={194 - 206}
ABSTRACT After the failure of the abortive coup in 2016, Turkey announced that it would derogate from the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) during the pronounced state of emergency. While the derogation was claimed to be necessary to eliminate the remaining hostile factions, a sweeping purge followed and human rights organisations have raised concerns over the deteriorating situation. This evokes the question of… 
The threat of derogations from international human rights treaties to democracies worldwide
According to the International Human Rights Law, States can limit the application of human rights rules to preserve individual and collective interests, such as public health, for example. The
The Role of Derogations from the ECHR in the Current “War on Terror”
This chapter explores the reasons behind the lack of reliance on derogations, and the implications of turning to such other methods as alternatives, given that derogations have played little part in counter-terrorism efforts in most of the ECHR contracting states.
Preserving Article 8 in Times of Crisis
The European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) has been enormously influential among international instruments in defining and defending individual rights around the world. Article 8, in particular,
Non-Discrimination, Minority Rights and Self-Determination: Turkey’s Post-Coup State of Emergency and the Position of Turkey’s Kurds
States of emergency are often declared due to underlying problems of minority group accommodation, and the extraordinary limitation of rights arising from them tends to have a particularly striking
International human rights law – lessons in the era of COVID-19
ABSTRACT The COVID-19 pandemic has brought the connections between law and public health into stark relief. The pandemic has demonstrated both the essential nature of global cooperation and
Derogation in the Field of Human Rights: International Legal Instruments and Practice of Ukraine
Summary The study highlights the international legal framework for the regulation of derogation of human rights and the practice of applying the latter by Ukraine, which is exercised for the first


When Does an Emergency Threaten the Life of the Nation? Derogations from Human Rights Obligations and the War on International Terrorism
The threat from international terrorism undoubtedly requires sophisticated responses from states. Too often, it is believed that in order to respond to this threat it is necessary to bypass on a
The Human Rights Treaty Obligations of Peacekeepers
1. Introduction and overview 2. The emerging relevance of human rights law in UN-mandated peace operations 3. The other side of the coin: the alleged inappropriateness of applying human rights
European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
[EDITORIAL NOTE: At this time when continued attention is being directed to a review of the Charter of the United Nations, it is suggested that a proper review should include an examination of the
The International Law of Human Rights and States of Exception: with special reference to the travaux préparatoires and case-law of the international monitoring organs
Abbreviations. Terminology. General Introduction. Part I: Emergency Powers in a Historic Perspective. 1. Public Emergencies Yesterday and Today. Part II: A Basic Legal Framework for Considering
The International Law of Human Rights
Part 1: Introducing Human Rights 1. The International Bill of Human Rights 2. Earlier Conceptions of 'Human Rights' Part 2: The Substantive Rights 3. Civil and Political Rights 4. Economic, Social
Are coups good for democracy?
A number of recent studies argue that coups can help usher in democracy. We examine this relationship empirically by looking at the political regimes that follow coups in autocracies, as well as the
The rise of the Taliban in Afghanistan : mass mobilization, civil war, and the future of the region
Introduction Historical Background The Political Elements of Afghan Society The Theory of Mass Mobilization Mass Mobilization in Afghanistan Violence: A source for Authority Traditional Political
American Convention on Human Rights Articles 46(1)(A) and 46(2)(C): Achilles Heel or Trojan Horse?
American Convention on Human Rights (Convention) Articles 46(1) and 46(2) seek compromise yet appear to create ambiguity. In fact, Article 46(1) requires a complainant to exhaust domestic remedies
2. The Committee welcomes the submission of the third periodic report of Bulgaria and the information presented therein, but regrets that it was submitted late. It expresses appreciation for the
The Political Instability of Reciprocal Trade and the Overthrow of the Hawaiian Kingdom
The overthrow of the Hawaiian monarchy in 1893 offers an illuminating case study of the political economy of preferential trading relationships between large and small countries. The limited-term