Human-computer interaction as science

  title={Human-computer interaction as science},
  author={Stuart Reeves},
  booktitle={Aarhus Conference on Critical Alternatives},
  • S. Reeves
  • Published in
    Aarhus Conference on Critical…
    17 August 2015
  • Art
The human-computer interaction (HCI) has had a long and troublesome relationship to the role of 'science'. HCI's status as an academic object in terms of coherence and adequacy is often in question---leading to desires for establishing a true scientific discipline. In this paper I explore formative cognitive science influences on HCI, through the impact of early work on the design of input devices. The paper discusses a core idea that I argue has animated much HCI research since: the notion of… 

Figures from this paper

HCI Research as Problem-Solving
This essay contributes a meta-scientific account of human-computer interaction (HCI) research as problem-solving that offers a rich, generative, and 'discipline-free' view of HCI and resolves some existing debates about what HCI is or should be.
Talking about interaction
Critical Realist HCI
This paper seeks to develop a non-reductionist view on interaction with technology that accommodates and potentially reconciles the variety of approaches, practices and stances that the authors see in current HCI.
What Do We Mean by “Interaction”? An Analysis of 35 Years of CHI
It is shown that the use of “interaction” is both increasing and diversifying, suggesting the importance of the notion, but also the difficulty in developing theory about interaction.
Reflections on Teaching a Mandatory HCI Course to Computer Science Undergraduates
We report on challenges that we encountered in teaching Human-Computer Interaction (HCI) to undergraduate computer science students. One of the main challenges we experienced is that students seem to
Locating the 'big hole' in HCI research
The emergence of increased debate about the very idea of HCI—what its work does, could, or should look like academically—feels like a valuable activity and is probably long overdue.
HCI Within Cross-Cultural Discourses of Globally Situated Rhetorical and Etymological Interactions
The disentanglement of established meanings through the dissemination of objects, concepts and HCI definitions and terminologies is proposed by applying a theoretical and a pragmatic analysis with the aim of shedding clarity via reflection and comprehension into mindfulness of ethical and integral possibilities.
Commentary: Usability in Vivo
  • S. Reeves
  • Philosophy
    Hum. Comput. Interact.
  • 2018
This commentary discusses Noam Tractinsky’s article “The Usability Construct: A Dead End?” (2017), which provides a thoughtful meditation on the notion of “usability,” and suggests the analytic solution for usability is the adoption of umbrella constructs.
Situated Dissemination through an HCI Workplace
This paper examines academic dissemination practices within HCI research communities from an institutional to individual level and introduces 'Research Fictions' in the form of video essays and live performances produced by the first author with her colleagues, based on their HCI submissions.
Implications for Adoption
The motivations for, and practicalities of, incorporating "implications for adoption" into HCI research practice are explored and methods for addressing this need are discussed, specifically design fiction.


Human-computer interaction: psychology as a science of design
Human-computer interaction study has progressively integrated its scientific concerns with the engineering goal of improving the usability of computer systems and applications, which has resulted in a body of technical knowledge and methodology.
Design-oriented human-computer interaction
It is proposed that it needs to acknowledge, first, the role of design in HCI conduct, and second, the difference between the knowledge-generating Design-oriented Research and the artifact-generate conduct of Research-oriented Design.
Conceptualizing a possible discipline of human-computer interaction
The Weak Science of Human-Computer Interaction
This article is about science and the discipline of humancomputer interaction (HCI). Science in HCI is merely one component of a wider agenda; alone science is not sufficient for ‘good’ HCI (whatever
The Three Paradigms of HCI
The underlying unity of a third wave in HCI is demonstrated, and how these waves suggest the centrality of currently marginal criteria for design, evaluation, appreciation, and developmental methodology in CHI work is documented.
Interaction Design: Beyond Human-Computer Interaction
Interaction Design offers a cross-disciplinary, practical and process-oriented approach to Human Computer Interaction, showing not just what principles ought to apply to Interaction Design, but crucially how they can be applied.
Interaction Design: Beyond Human-Computer Interaction. Second Edition
Interaction Design offers a cross-disciplinary, practical and process-oriented approach to Human Computer Interaction, showing not just what principles ought to apply to Interaction Design, but crucially how they can be applied.
HCI Models, Theories, and Frameworks: Toward a Multidisciplinary Science
Finally-a thorough pedagogical survey of the multidisciplinary science of HCI. Human-Computer Interaction spans many disciplines, from the social and behavioral sciences to information and
Conceptions of the discipline of HCI: craft, applied science, and engineering
The theme within a characterisation of alternative conceptions of the discipline of Human-Computer Interaction (HCI) is developed, and a framework is proposed within which different conceptions ofThe HCI discipline may be established, ordered, and related.