How to Become a Dominant French Philosopher: The Case of Jacques Derrida

  title={How to Become a Dominant French Philosopher: The Case of Jacques Derrida},
  author={Mich{\`e}le Lamont},
  journal={American Journal of Sociology},
  pages={584 - 622}
  • M. Lamont
  • Published 1 November 1987
  • Art
  • American Journal of Sociology
How can an interpretive theory gain legitimacy in two cultural markets as different as France and the United States? This study examines the intellectual, cultural, institutional, and social conditions of legitimation of Jacques Derrida's work in the two countries and develops hypotheses about the process of legitimation of interpretive theories. The legitimation of Derrida's work resulted from a fit between it and highly structured cultural and institutional systems. In France, Derrida… 

The sudden rise of French existentialism: a case-study in the sociology of intellectual life

This article offers a new explanation for the sudden rise in popularity of French existentialism, in particular of Sartre’s version, in the mid-1940s. It develops a multidimensional account that

Cultural Politics and Modernist Architecture: The Tulip Debate in Postwar Hungary

The article focuses on the interpretive struggles and contests surrounding the adoption and legitimation of fully or partly “imported” ideas. It examines the reception of modernist architecture in

On the Edge of Disciplines: Reception of Karl Polanyi in France (1974–2014)

From the mid 1970s to present times, the importation of Polanyi’s writing in France can be seen as an everlasting work of interpretation, as the author is constantly adapted to struggles and issues

Reactionaries of the lectern: Universalism, anti-empiricism and corporatism in Austrian (and German) social theory

This article discusses one early manifestation of a recurring theme in social theory and sociology: the relationship between general (‘universal’ or ‘grand’) theory and empirical research. For the

Il Mulino-Rivisteweb

The reception of Arendt’s thought in Germany and in Italy presents at first glance a similar trend. From the second postwar until 1968 Arendt is chiefly known for her works on totalitarianism and

A invenção e as reinvenções transatlânticas da “Critical Theory”

Where does the phrase “critical theory” that circulates on American campuses but has no equivalent in continental Europe come from? This article recounts the intellectual and social origins of the

Legacies of Derrida: Anthropology

This article considers the legacies of Jacques Derrida in and for Anglo-American sociocultural anthropology. It begins with a survey of Derrida's own engagement with themes that have historically

The Transatlantic Invention and Reinventions of Critical Theory

Where does the label “critical theory” come from that circulates on American campuses and libraries but has no equivalent in continental Europe? This article recounts the origins of the concept and

Literary theorists in and beyond French academic space (1960–1970s)

This article demonstrates how social strategies deployed at the margins of French academic space to legitimize theoretical approaches to literary texts (semiology, semantics, structural analysis of

Il Mulino-Rivisteweb

Professor of comparative literature at Columbia University from 1963 to 2003, Said is one of the most well-known and talked about contemporary academics and intellectuals. His works, some of which



After The New Criticism

This work is the first history and evaluation of contemporary American critical theory within its European philosophical contexts. In the first part, Frank Lentricchia analyzes the impact on our

The Dialectical Imagination: A History of the Frankfurt School and the Institute of Social Research, 1923–1950 by Martin Jay (review)

Academies and elsewhere through his friends in high position indicates again his political motivation as well as personal need for open approval, a need intensified doubtless by his crippling

The Sociopolitical Context of Philosophical Beliefs: A Transhistorical Causal Analysis

This paper applies a quasi-experimental design to the problem of the causal relation between intellectual and political movements. A sample of 122 consecutive "generations" (or 20-year periods) was

Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature

Richard Rorty's Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature brings to light the deep sense of crisis within the profession of academic philosophy which is similar to the paralyzing pluralism in contemporary

The Structural Allegory: Reconstructive Encounters with the New French Thought

The Structural Allegory is an important contribution to the evaluation of both structuralist and post-structuralist French social theory. What is particularly exciting about this volume is that the

La Pensée 68. Essai sur L'anti-humanisme contemporain

Luc Ferry and Alain Renaut are political philosophers in Lyon and Nantes, respectively. They have jointly directed the Collège de philosophie since 1975 and have recently collaborated in a study

Institutions and Schools of Thought: The Neogrammarians

In this examination of the institutional conditions under which the Neogrammarian school of thought made its appearance in late 19th century linguistics in Germany, the emergence of the

Writing and reading differently : deconstruction and the teaching of composition and literature

This is the first book to explore the opportunities deconstruction opens up for the teaching of both composition and literature. It is a unique and timely response to crucial issues facing teachers

The Rise of American Philosophy

Despina's Pragmatism receives its impetus when Gugliemo devises a way of escaping the Count's Absolute. Although Gugliemo does not forego another version of idealism, his disenchantment with monism

Philosophy in France Today

1. Introduction Alan Montefiore 2. The philosophical institution Pierre Bourdieu 3. Why I am so very unFrench Jacques Bouveresse 4. The time of a thesis: punctuations Jacques Derrida 5. A path in