How do triers of fact infer the accuracy of eyewitness identifications? Using memory for peripheral detail can be misleading.

@article{Wells1981HowDT,
  title={How do triers of fact infer the accuracy of eyewitness identifications? Using memory for peripheral detail can be misleading.},
  author={Gary L Wells and Michael R. Leippe},
  journal={Journal of Applied Psychology},
  year={1981},
  volume={66},
  pages={682-687}
}
Eyewitnesses (n = 107) to a staged theft made identifications from a photo spread and then responded to 11 questions that measured their memory for peripheral details (e.g., how many pictures were in the room where the theft occurred?). Results indicated that witnesses who accurately identified the thief (n = 57) averaged fewer correct answers on the peripheral details test than did eyewitnesses who identified an innocent person (n = 32). The remaining witnesses (n = 18) made no identification… 

Tables from this paper

The Tractability of Eyewitness Confidence and Its Implications for Triers of Fact
A theft staged for 80 unsuspecting eyewitnesses was followed by a picture lineup that did or did not contain the thief. In an attempt to see if eyewitness confidence is tractable after the
The malleability of eyewitness confidence: co-witness and perseverance effects
A theft was staged 70 times for pairs of eyewitnesses (N = 140) who then made a photo-lineup identification. Witnesses then received 1 of 9 types of information regarding the alleged identification
Upper Limits of Eyewitness Identification Accuracy in Court
Eyewitnesses in real life make erroneous identifications, as shown by compilations of a century’s worth of newspaper accounts of erroneous indictments and/ or convictions based on mistaken
What Can Psychology Say About the Neil v . Biggers Criteria for Judging Eyewitness Accuracy ?
In an influential case (Neil v Biggers, 1972), the U S Supreme Court identified five catena to be considered m judging eyewitness identification evidence The Court's intuitions may need reassessment
What can psychology say about the Neil v. Biggers criteria for judging eyewitness accuracy
In an influential case (Neil v Biggers, 1972), the U S Supreme Court identified five catena to be considered m judging eyewitness identification evidence The Court's intuitions may need reassessment
In support of a diversity of methods : eyewitness memory in actual cases of robbery and fraud
Much of our knowledge of eyewitness memory is built on laboratorybased studies. In recent years this has caused a controversy, the resolution of which seems to be an acceptance of the need to learn
The effect of post-identification feedback on the recall of crime and perpetrator details
The present study examines the effect of identification feedback on the quantity and accuracy of crime event details recalled, willingness to attempt misleading questions and confidence in the
Mock-Juror Belief of Accurate Inaccurate Eyewitnesses and A Replication and Extension *
In response to lawyers' critiques of earlier staged-crime, mock-jury studies, 16 eyewitnesses to a staged crime were videotaped while being questioned by lawyers in a real courthouse. Accurate and
Opinions of attorneys and law enforcement personnel on the accuracy of eyewitnes identifications
A survey was conducted to obtain the opinions of attorneys and law enforcement personnel regarding several important aspects of eyewitness evidence: (1) legal procedures concerning eyewitness
Mock-juror belief of accurate and inaccurate eyewitnesses
In response to lawyers' critiques of earlier staged-crime, mock-jury studies, 16 eyewitnesses to a staged crime were videotaped while being questioned by lawyers in a real courthouse. Accurate and
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 16 REFERENCES
Can People Detect Eyewitness-Identification Accuracy Within and Across Situations?
Thefts were staged 108 times for as many witnesses who were subsequently given a photo lineup for identifying the thief. The thefts were staged under conditions designed to yield low (33%), moderate
Accuracy, confidence, and juror perceptions in eyewitness identification.
TLDR
Jurors were unable to distinguish accurate from inaccurate witnesses across the 42 cross-examina tion sessions, and jurors in the leading-questions conditions were significantly more likely to believe accurate than inaccurate witnesses, whereas the reverse effect held for nonleading questions.
Realism and eyewitness identification research
The importance of realism in eyewitness identification research is examined as the basis for both the credibility and utility of the information it provides. Without knowledge of how laboratory
Effects of expert psychological advice on human performance in judging the validity of eyewitness testimony
A review is made of recent experimental research regarding how well human observers can judge the accuracy of eyewitness testimony. It is concluded that people: (a) may be overwilling to believe in
Crime Seriousness as a Determinant of Accuracy in Eyewitness Identification
Male and female subjects (n — 65) witnessed a staged theft in which either an expensive object (high seriousness) or an inexpensive object (low seriousness) was stolen, and subjects either had prior
Eyewitness accuracy and confidence
In deciding the trustworthiness of eyewitness testimony, the U.S. judiciary employs as one of five criteria the witness' level of confidence demonstrated at the confrontation. A very recent
Effects of integrative memorial and cognitive processes on the correspondence of eyewitness accuracy and confidence
Reported correlations between accuracy and certainty of eyewitness identifications are sometimes positive, but equally often nil. Examination of theory and research in eyewitness, cognitive, and
Influence of expert testimony regarding eyewitness accuracy on jury decisions
To determine the influence of expert testimony regarding the general unreliability of eyewitnesses, a two-phase study was conducted. In the first phase, 24 community residents served as jurors on
On the Economy of the Human Processing System: A Model of Multiple Capacity.
Abstract : An approach to human performance which is based on economic concepts is proposed. This approach hinges on the idea that the human processing system has a number of mechanisms each having
...
...