How analogies are generated: The roles of structural and superficial similarity

  title={How analogies are generated: The roles of structural and superficial similarity},
  author={Isabelle Blanchette and Kevin Dunbar},
  journal={Memory \& Cognition},
Laboratory studies of analogical reasoning have shown that subjects are mostly influenced by superficial similarity in the retrieval of source analogs. However, real-world investigations have demonstrated that people generate analogies using deep structural features. We conducted three experiments to determine why laboratory and real-world studies have yielded different results. In the first two experiments, we used a “production paradigm” in which subjects were asked to generate sources for a… Expand

Tables from this paper

The Role of Surface Similarity in Analogical Retrieval: Bridging the Gap Between the Naturalistic and the Experimental Traditions
Both studies revealed a strong effect of surface similarity on the retrieval of participants' own sources, thus suggesting that the superficial bias typically observed in experimental studies--and simulated by most computational models--does not originate in a lack of ecological validity. Expand
An Exploration of Real-World Analogical Problem Solving in Novices
Despite the postulated importance of analogising to human cognition, the study of analogical problem solving in the laboratory has found disappointing results. Providing an analogue to a participantExpand
Expert analogy use in a naturalistic setting
The results supported previous conclusions about the infrequency of superficial similarity in subject-generated analogs, but also showed that distance and depth characteristics were more evenly balanced than in previous observational studies. Expand
Challenging the superficial similarities superiority account for analogical retrieval
It is shown that in some contexts, abstract encoding induces a superiority of structural similarities over superficial ones in retrieval, and implications for analogical retrieval approaches are discussed. Expand
A Computational Analysis Model for Complex Open-ended Analogical Retrieval
MAC/FAC (“many are called, but few are chosen”), which models two stages of analogical reasoning, was applied to experimental data and the results support the MAC/Fac’s theoretical assumption – different similarities are involved in the two stage of analogicals reasoning. Expand
Chapter One – Cracking the Problem of Inert Knowledge: Portable Strategies to Access Distant Analogs From Memory
The present chapter reviews the successful and failed attempts to help learners overcome competence limitations and provides several plausibility arguments for the hypothesis that an abstraction of the target analog can enable access to distant analogs whose initial encoding had not highlighted their structural features. Expand
Seek, and ye shall find: Differences between spontaneous and voluntary analogical retrieval
While voluntary search yields analogical retrievals reliably, the argumentation activity seldom elicits spontaneous remindings, and whether strategic search can relax the superficial bias typically obtained in experimental studies of analogical retrieval is tackled. Expand
Retrieval of analogs from long-term memory: Explaining the divergence between experimental and naturalistic studies
Abstract In contrast to the experimental tradition in the study of analogical retrieval, naturalistic studies in which participants have to retrieve their own source analogs suggest that retrievalExpand
Explaining the abundance of distant analogies in naturalistic observations of experts
The time is ripe to assert that the naturalistic observation of experts shows a more flexible use of analogical sources than is predicted by experimental studies on analogical transfer, and simulated by dominant computer models of analogICAL retrieval. Expand
Representational change and analogy: how analogical inferences alter target representations.
  • I. Blanchette, K. Dunbar
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Journal of experimental psychology. Learning, memory, and cognition
  • 2002
Overall, these experiments show that analogical inferences are incorporated in the representation of the target and cannot be differentiated from information actually presented. Expand


Constraints on Analogical Mapping: A Comparison of Three Models
This article shows how these theories of analogy can be unified within a common metatheoretical framework that distinguishes among levels of informational, behavioral, and hardware constraints. Expand
Below the Surface: Analogical Similarity and Retrieval Competition in Reminding
Abstract While the importance of surface semantic similarities between reminding cues and memory targets has been well documented, it has been unclear whether or when human memory retrieval isExpand
The Roles of Similarity in Transfer: Separating Retrievability From Inferential Soundness
There is a dissociation between the similarity that governs access to long-term memory and that which is used in evaluating and reasoning from a present match, and a model is described, called MAC/FAC, that uses a two-stage similarity retrieval process to model these findings. Expand
Systematicity as a Selection Constraint in Analogical Mapping
Results support Gentner's (1983, 1989) structure-mapping theory in that analogical mapping concerns systems and not individual predicates, and that attention to shared systematic structure constrains the selection of information to include in on analogy. Expand
MAC/FAC: A Model of Similarity-Based Retrieval
A model of similarity-based retrieval that attempts to capture three seemingly contradictory psychological phenomena, showing that structural commonalities are weighed more heavily than surface commonalities in similarity judgments for items in working memory and that MAC/FAC can model patterns of access found in psychological data. Expand
Pragmatics in Analogical Mapping
The qualitative pattern of results was successfully simulated using the ACME model, implementing the impact of processing goals as an inhibitory process of selective attention. Expand
Structured Imagination: the Role of Category Structure in Exemplar Generation
Abstract College students imagined animals that might live on a planet somewhere else in the galaxy. In the first experiment, they provided drawings and descriptions of their initial imagined animal,Expand
Analogical problem solving
Abstract The use of an analogy from a semantically distant domain to guide the problemsolving process was investigated. The representation of analogy in memory and processes involved in the use ofExpand
On Retrieving Analogues When Solving Problems
An ad hoc model of analogue retrieval is proposed based on Schank's dynamic memory theory, and its consistency with the evidence and more general implications are considered. Expand
Analogical Mapping by Constraint Satisfaction
A theory of analogical mapping between source and target analogs based upon interacting structural, semantic, and pragmatic constraints is proposed here and is able to account for empirical findings regarding the impact of consistency and similarity on human processing of analogies. Expand