How Not to Detect Design

  title={How Not to Detect Design},
  author={Branden Fitelson and Christopher Stephens and Elliott Sober},
  journal={Philosophy of Science},
  pages={472 - 488}
Critique de l'ouvrage de W. A. Dembsky intitule «L'inference du dessein» (198) qui examine les contextes non-theologiques de l'argument philosophique du dessein. L'A. rejette la methode epistemologique de Dembsky, fondee sur la hasard et la probabilite, qui ne rend pas compte de la these creationniste ni de la theorie evolutionniste de l'univers. 

The Advantages of Theft over Toil: The Design Inference and Arguing from Ignorance

Intelligent design theorist William Dembski hasproposed an ``explanatory filter'' fordistinguishing between events due to chance,lawful regularity or design. We show that ifDembski's filter were

Detecting Design: Fast and Frugal or All Things Considered?

Within the Cognitive Science of Religion, Justin Barrett has proposed that humans possess a hyperactive agency detection device that was selected for in our evolutionary past because ‘over detecting’

The scientific viability of W. A. Dembski's design inference: Response to B. Forrest and R. Pennock of the Kitzmiller trial


Truthlikeness and the Problem of Measure Sensitivity

It is shown that some basic arguments concerning truth approximation through belief change are not invariant across the different truthlikeness measures proposed in the literature.

Testability, Likelihoods, and Design

It is often assumed by friends and foes alike of intelligent design that a likelihood approach to design inferences will require evidence regarding the specific motives and abilities of any

Critical Notice I the Testability of Intelligent Design Ii Testing Claims about Natural Selection Iii Testing Claims about Common Ancestry

  • Biology
Elliott Sober's latest book Evidence and Evolution is an epistemological study of scientific inference and the confirmation of hypotheses in the context of evolutionary biology, and philosophers and biologists will benefit, since Sober steps back from the variety of existing quantitative models and identifies common themes of hypothesis testing.

On the assumption of design

The assumption of design of the universe is examined from a scientific perspective. The claims of William Dembski and of Michael Behe are unscientific because they are a-theoretic. The argument from

Are Probabilities Indispensable to the Design Inference

After sketching the various probabilistic accounts of the design inference, including the Bayesian and Dembskian models, I make a stab at developing, in an admittedly crude form, a non-probabilistic

Intelligent design and mathematical statistics: a troubled alliance

Although the explanatory filter has been extensively criticized from many angles, this work presents the first rigorous criticism based on the theory of mathematical statistics.

A case of confusing probability and confirmation

It is argued that Stoneham neglects the distinction between degrees of confirmation and degrees of probability, and once the distinction is in place, it becomes clear that no conjunction fallacy has been committed.



Statistical Evidence: A Likelihood Paradigm

Although the likelihood paradigm has been around for some time, Royall's distinctive voice, combined with his contribution of several novel lines of argument, has given new impetus to a school of

Plantinga's Probability Arguments Against Evolutionary Naturalism

In Chapter 12 of Warrant and Proper Function, Alvin Plantinga constructs two arguments against evolutionary naturalism, which he construes as a conjunction E&N. The hypothesis E says that “human

Tower of Babel: The Evidence against the New Creationism

Creationism is no longer the simple notion it once was taken to be. Its new advocates have become more sophisticated in how they present their views, speaking of "intelligent design" rather than

The Design Inference: Eliminating Chance Through Small Probabilities

This paper presents a meta-analysis of the design inference ofcomplexity theory and its applications in the context of discrete-time reinforcement learning.

Physicalism from a Probabilistic Point of View

Physicalism -like other isms -has meant different things to different people. The main physicalistic thesis I will discuss here is the claim that all occurrences supervene on physical occurrences

Warrant and proper function

Professor Plantinga is known for distinguished work in the fields of epistemology and philosophy of religion. In this companion volume to Warrant: The Current Debate, Plantinga develops an original

Abusing Science: The Case Against Creationism

Abusing Science is a manual for intellectual self-defense, the most complete available for presenting the case against Creationist pseudo-science, and refutes the popular complaint that the scientific establishment is dogmatic and intolerant.

Philosophy of Biology

What Is Evolutionary Theory? Creationism Fitness The Units of Selection Problem Adaptationism Systematics Sociobiology and the Extension of Evolutionary Theory.

Morgan's canon.

Knowledge and the Flow of Information.