How Not to Compare African Traditional Thought with Western Thought

  title={How Not to Compare African Traditional Thought with Western Thought},
  author={J. E. Wiredu},
  journal={Transition: An International Review},
  • J. E. Wiredu
  • Published 1997
  • Economics
  • Transition: An International Review
ManyWesterners have been puzzled by the virtual ubiquity of gods and spirits in traditional African explanations of things. Robin Horton, the Western anthropologist, has suggested that this failure of understanding is partly attributable to the fact that many Western anthropologists "have been unfamiliar with the theoretical thinking of their own culture."l I would like to suggest that a much more significant reason is that they have also been unfamiliar with the folk thought of their own… Expand
Ethno-philosophy is Rational: A Reply to Two Famous Critics
In this article, I contend that philosophical reactions against ethno-philosophy, especially the arguments by professional African philosophers such as Paulin Hountondji and Kwame Anthony Appiah,Expand
Philosophers of different ages, epochs and ideological orientations have engaged themselves in a heated debate on the issue of the mindbody interaction. Indeed, there are two different butExpand
'Down But Not Out': Critical Insights in Traditional Shona Metaphysics
Abstract The paper provides a corrective to the Western gaze that modern medicine; science and Christianity are familiar parts of Western imagination. It shows the beauty of African indigenousExpand
Echoes from the Great Divide: On the Faltering Philosophical Dialogue between Africa and the West
Even in the field of comparative or cross-cultural philosophy, distinctive contributions by African philosophers are often side-lined – that is, relegated to niche publications. Why is it so hard forExpand
Hountondji’s Critique of Ethnophilosophy and His Notion of African Philosophy
Paulin Hountondji became famous for his rigorous critique of ethnophilosophy. This chapter presents the historical context of the emergence of ethnophilosophy, portrays the most important writings ofExpand
The problem of gerontocracy in Africa: The Yorùbá perspective as illustrated in the Ifá corpus
In the field of African philosophy, there exists the belief among the modernists or professional philosophers that gerontocracy is coterminous with authoritarian traditions in traditional AfricaExpand
Reflection on euthanasia: Western and African Ntomba perspectives on the death of a chief.
The Ntomba Chief is chosen because of his above average vital force, which puts him in the position of intermediary between the Supreme Being, the ancestors, and his subordinates, and he has to be killed ritually to avoid the loss of the entire community's vital force. Expand
In this paper I unpack some nuanced aspects of cultural imperialism against the backdrop of Du Bois’s analysis in The souls of black folk, dealing with the confrontation of African Americans orExpand
Tradition and Modernization: Siting Philosophy for Children Within the African Outlook
In this philosophical paper, we investigate the project of doing philosophy with children in Africa. While the philosophy for children program has its roots in the Anglo-Saxon world, we contend thatExpand
A Comparative Perspective for Functional Application of Scientific Temper in Southern Africa
In celebration of the launch of a journal in India that will be dedicated to the advancement of the notion of scientific temper, it is apt to reflect on the possibilities of the impact that such aExpand