How Important Is Deliberate Practice? Reply to Ericsson (2016)

@article{Macnamara2016HowII,
  title={How Important Is Deliberate Practice? Reply to Ericsson (2016)},
  author={Brooke N. Macnamara and David Z. Hambrick and David Moreau},
  journal={Perspectives on Psychological Science},
  year={2016},
  volume={11},
  pages={355 - 358}
}
Ericsson and colleagues’ view that individual differences in expertise can largely be accounted for by accumulated deliberate practice is not supported by the available empirical evidence. Extending earlier work (Macnamara, Hambrick, & Oswald, 2014), we found that deliberate practice accounted for a sizeable amount of variance in sports performance (18%), but it left a much larger amount unexplained. Ericsson’s (2016, this issue) evaluation of our research is undercut by contradictions… Expand
12 Citations

Figures and Topics from this paper

Is the Deliberate Practice View Defensible? A Review of Evidence and Discussion of Issues
TLDR
Critical inconsistencies in the definition of deliberate practice are document, along with apparent shifts in the standard for evidence concerning deliberate practice, and the impact of these issues on progress in the field of expertise is considered, focusing on the empirical testability and falsifiability of the deliberate practice view. Expand
Toward a more critical dialogue for enhancing self-report surveys in sport expertise and deliberate practice research
Two hallmark criteria are commonly used to determine whether a variable of interest has an impact on sport expertise development: (a) discrimination of performance or skill levels and (b) associationExpand
Personality, Deliberate Practice, and Expertise Development in Sport
Conscientiousness-related personality traits are relevant predictors of many outcomes in achievement domains outside sport. They have also been associated with several outcomes in sport, however,Expand
Toward a multifactorial model of expertise: beyond born versus made
TLDR
It is argued that the nature versus nurture debate in research on expertise is over—or certainly should be, as it has been in other areas of psychological research for decades. Expand
Nonlinear Assessment of Motor Variability During Practice and Competition for Individuals with Different Motivational Orientations
Abstract The aim of the present study was to document how differing motivational orientation profiles, situated within environmental constraints (i.e., a competitive and practice environments)Expand
Developing Musical Imagery : Contributions from Pedagogy and Cognitive Science *
Research into the development of musical imagery ability has remained stagnant in both the fields of aural skills pedagogy and cognitive science. This article integrates scholarship from bothExpand
The Psychology of Human Thought : An Introduction
ion The process of filtering out irrelevant details while preserving the most relevant, common, or significant parts. 56 basic level of categorization Intermediate level that provides the mostExpand
Problem-Solving and Intelligence
The ability to solve complex problems is a defining feature of what most laypeople think of as intelligence. This is also a common theme in how intelligence researchers describe intelligenceExpand
Mapping the outer reaches of the learning curve: Complex intellectual skill performance after decades of extensive practice.
  • R. Howard
  • Medicine, Psychology
  • Acta psychologica
  • 2020
TLDR
Chess skill learning curves were examined for 333 players, mostly grandmasters, who, over a median 20 years, played at least 1500 internationally-rated games and found the more talented tend to plateau later and curves of the greater and lesser talented do not converge. Expand
Self-regulation and performance profiling for athlete's self-determined development
Date of presentation: 30.11.2016
...
1
2
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 25 REFERENCES
The Relationship Between Deliberate Practice and Performance in Sports
TLDR
To understand the underpinnings of expertise, researchers must investigate contributions of a broad range of factors, taking into account findings from diverse subdisciplines of psychology and interdisciplinary areas of research. Expand
Accounting for expert performance: The devil is in the details
The deliberate practice view has generated a great deal of scientific and popular interest in expert performance. At the same time, empirical evidence now indicates that deliberate practice, whileExpand
Summing Up Hours of Any Type of Practice Versus Identifying Optimal Practice Activities
  • K. A. Ericsson
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Perspectives on psychological science : a journal of the Association for Psychological Science
  • 2016
TLDR
It is found that individualized practice with training tasks (selected by a supervising teacher) with a clear performance goal and immediate informative feedback was associated with marked improvement and its accumulated duration related to attained music performance. Expand
Team Sports and the Theory of Deliberate Practice
Two studies tested the theory of deliberate practice (Ericsson, Krampe, & Tesch-Romer, 1993) and contrasted results with the sport commitment model (Scanlan, Carpenter, Schmidt, Simons, & Keeler,Expand
Deliberate Practice and Performance in Music, Games, Sports, Education, and Professions: A Meta-Analysis
TLDR
A meta-analysis covering all major domains in which deliberate practice has been investigated concludes that deliberate practice is important, but not as important as has been argued. Expand
Expert performance: Its structure and acquisition.
Counter to the common belief that expert performance reflects innate abilities and capacities, recent research in different domains of expertise has shown that expert performance is predominantlyExpand
The Scientific Study of Expert Levels of Performance: general implications for optimal learning and creativity 1
Recent research in many different domains of expertise has shown that the large differences in performance between experts and novices are frequently reproducible under standardized conditions andExpand
Giftedness Viewed from the Expert-Performance Perspective
Traditional conceptions of giftedness assume that only talented individuals possess the necessary gifts required to reach the highest levels of performance. This article describes an alternative viewExpand
Practice Does Not Make Perfect
TLDR
It is suggested that music practice may not causally influence music ability and that genetic variation among individuals affects both ability and inclination to practice. Expand
The role of deliberate practice in the acquisition of expert performance.
TLDR
A theoretical framework is proposed that explains expert performance in terms of acquired characteristics resulting from extended deliberate practice and that limits the role of innate (inherited) characteristics to general levels of activity and emotionality. Expand
...
1
2
3
...