Homer Nodded: Von Neumann’s Surprising Oversight

@article{Mermin2018HomerNV,
  title={Homer Nodded: Von Neumann’s Surprising Oversight},
  author={N. David Mermin and R{\"u}diger Schack},
  journal={Foundations of Physics},
  year={2018},
  volume={48},
  pages={1007-1020}
}
We review the famous no-hidden-variables theorem in von Neumann’s 1932 book on the mathematical foundations of quantum mechanics (Mathematische Grundlagen der Quantenmechanik, Springer, Berlin, 1932). We describe the notorious gap in von Neumann’s argument, pointed out by Hermann (Abhandlungen der Fries’schen Schule 6:75–152, 1935) and, more famously, by Bell (Rev Modern Phys 38:447–452, 1966). We disagree with recent papers claiming that Hermann and Bell failed to understand what von Neumann… 

von Neumann’s Theorem Revisited

According to a popular narrative, in 1932 von Neumann introduced a theorem that intended to be a proof of the impossibility of hidden variables in quantum mechanics. However, the narrative goes, Bell

Hilbert-Style Axiomatic Completion: The (Not So) Hidden Contextuality of von Neumann’s “No Hidden Variables” Theorem

Von Neumann’s (in)famous proof of the non-existence of hidden variables in quantum mechanics is commonly discussed in the context of work that came much later, namely that of Bohm and Bell. In this

Must hidden variables theories be contextual? Kochen & Specker meet von Neumann and Gleason

It is a widespread belief that the Kochen-Specker theorem imposes a contextuality constraint on the ontology of beables in quantum hidden variables theories. On the other hand, after Bell’s

Von Neumann's No Hidden Variable Theorem

Von Neumann use 4 assumptions to derive the Hilbert space (HS) formulation of quantum mechanics (QM). Within this theory dispersion free ensembles do not exist. To accommodate a theory of quantum

Oversights in the Respective Theorems of von Neumann and Bell are Homologous

We show that the respective oversights in the von Neumann's general theorem against all hidden variable theories and Bell's theorem against their local-realistic counterparts are homologous. Both

Bell’s Theorem: A Critical Analysis of an Orthodox View

When used to prove the Bell inequality, the widely accepted counterfactual definiteness assumption constitutes an inconsistent hypothesis. It is not equivalent either to realism or determinism, and

The GHSZ Argument: A Gedankenexperiment Requiring More Denken

I reassess the gedankenexperiment of Greenberger, Horne, Shimony, and Zeilinger after twenty-five years, finding their influential claim to the discovery of an inconsistency inherent in high

Ideas Abandoned en Route to QBism

The interpretation of quantum mechanics known as QBism developed out of efforts to understand the probabilities arising in quantum physics as Bayesian in character. But this development was neither

Resurrecting the Prospect of Supplementary Variableswith the Principle of Local Realism

  • F. Lad
  • Philosophy
    AppliedMath
  • 2022
I produce a coherent mathematical formulation of the supplementary variables structure for Aspect’s experimental test of Bell’s inequality as devised by Clauser, Horne, Shimony, and Holt, a

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 17 REFERENCES

Deep Beauty: Is Von Neumann's “No Hidden Variables” Proof Silly?

Introduction In his Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics , John von Neumann presented a proof that the quantum statistics cannot be recovered from probability distributions over “hidden”

Von Neumann's Impossibility Proof: Mathematics in the Service of Rhetorics

Von Neumann’s ‘No Hidden Variables’ Proof: A Re-Appraisal

Since the analysis by John Bell in 1965, the consensus in the literature is that von Neumann’s ‘no hidden variables’ proof fails to exclude any significant class of hidden variables. Bell raised the

On the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox

THE paradox of Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen [1] was advanced as an argument that quantum mechanics could not be a complete theory but should be supplemented by additional variables. These additional

On the Problem of Hidden Variables in Quantum Mechanics

The demonstrations of von Neumann and others, that quantum mechanics does not permit a hidden variable interpretation, are reconsidered. It is shown that their essential axioms are unreasonable. It

Deep beauty : understanding the quantum world through mathematical innovation

Part I. Beyond the Hilbert Space Formalism: Category Theory: 1. A prehistory of n-categorical physics John C. Baez and Aaron Lauda 2. A universe of processes and some of its guises Bob Coecke 3.

Simultaneous measurability in quantum theory

This paper presents a study of what is sometimes regarded as the conceptual heart of quantum theory, namely, the orthodox ‘physical’ interpretation of non-commuting operators as representatives of

Hidden variables and the two theorems of John Bell

Although skeptical of the prohibitive power of no-hidden-variables theorems, John Bell was himself responsible for the two most important ones. I describe some recent versions of the lesser known of

The Einstein-Podolski-Rosen Paradox

In a recent article in this journal, Henry Krips [2] claims that he has resolved the Einstein-Podolski-Rosen (EPR) paradox [1]. As is well-known, EPR demonstrated a situation in which performing

Grete Hermann - Between Physics and Philosophy