Holding Therapy and Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy Are Not Supported and Acceptable Social Work Interventions: A Systematic Research Synthesis Revisited

@article{Pignotti2007HoldingTA,
  title={Holding Therapy and Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy Are Not Supported and Acceptable Social Work Interventions: A Systematic Research Synthesis Revisited},
  author={Monica G. Pignotti and Jean Mercer},
  journal={Research on Social Work Practice},
  year={2007},
  volume={17},
  pages={513 - 519}
}
This article re-examines material discussed in a recent systematic research synthesis by Craven and Lee. The authors find that two of the interventions for foster children discussed by Craven and Lee were erroneously classified as supported by evidence of efficacy, and one, holding therapy, is shown to be potentially physically harmful to children. Detailed evidence is offered to show that holding therapy and dyadic developmental psychotherapy are not appropriately categorized as supported and… 
Examining Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy as a Treatment for Adopted and Foster Children
Dyadic developmental psychotherapy (DDP) is a mental health intervention intended primarily for children with problematic attachment histories. It has received increased attention in the United
Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy is not ‘evidence-based’: comments in response to Becker-Weidman and Hughes
A recent paper claimed that Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy (DDP), a mental-health intervention for children, was an evidence-based treatment (EBT). We discuss the meaning of the EBT term and the
Revisiting an Article About Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy: The Life Cycle of a Woozle
This paper examines a 2006 Child and Adolescent Social Work Journal article (Becker-Weidman in Child Adolesc Soc Work J 23:147–171, 2006a) that purported to show the effectiveness of Dyadic
The use and limitations of attachment theory in child psychotherapy.
TLDR
An overview of attachment theory and attachment-based interventions is provided and how to apply those constructs to therapeutic work with children is discussed and how attachment-focused interventions can be combined with other therapeutic needs and methods are discussed.
International Concerns About Holding Therapy
TLDR
The present article summarizes background information and the presentations made at the conference, which without exception argued against the use of HT.
The Use and Abuse of Attachment Theory in Clinical Practice with Maltreated Children, Part II: Treatment
TLDR
The theoretical and empirical bases for the use of attachment theory in the treatment of maltreated school-age children are provided, an examination of the ways questionable approaches to treatment have misinterpreted and misapplied attachment theory, and a conceptualization of attachment-based intervention grounded in current theory and research are provided.
Holding therapy: a harmful mental health intervention
TLDR
The evidence of effectiveness for holding therapy, an alternative form of child psychotherapy, involves physical restraint and manipulation, and has been associated with adverse events.
Clinicians' Perspectives on the Developmental Repair Model
TLDR
Qualitative data on the Developmental Repair Model from clinicians working with it currently adds to the growing discussion on children’s mental health concerns and what evidence-based models are currently being used to address such concerns.
The challenging behaviour of children in the South Australian out-of-home care sector: stakeholders’ experiences with collaborative practice and their frameworks for managing behaviour.
TLDR
A thematic analysis of the interviews of 92 South Australian stakeholders, representing five key stakeholder groups: foster carers, teachers, residential care workers, child mental health workers and child welfare, to identify what accounts of behaviour are dominant amongst key stakeholders.
Institutional Care for Young Children: Review of Literature and Policy Implications.
TLDR
Why institutional care is at odds with children's needs is discussed, and the empirical evidence regarding the effects of institutional care on young children's development is reviewed.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 33 REFERENCES
Therapeutic Interventions for Foster Children: A Systematic Research Synthesis
Approximately 30% of children in foster care have severe emotional, behavioral, or developmental problems. A systematic research synthesis of empirical studies was conducted in an attempt to identify
Treatment for Children with Trauma-Attachment Disorders: Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy
TLDR
Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy appears to be an effective treatment for children with trauma-attachment disorders.
Comparative Effectiveness of Holding Therapy with Aggressive Children
TLDR
This study was undertaken to assess the effects of holding therapy on children who have a history of aggressive and delinquent behaviors and found a significant decrease in the outcome variable for the treatment group within this study.
Correlates of the Randolph Attachment Disorder Questionnaire (RADQ) in a Sample of Children in Foster Placement
ABSTRACTThis study examined mental health and attachment problems in children in foster care. This study also obtained data concerning the validity of the Randolph Attachment Disorder Questionnaire
Nature, nurture, and development: from evangelism through science toward policy and practice.
TLDR
A summary review of the real gains in knowledge, some of the misleading claims, and the potential for research and for science-led improvements in policies and practice are provided.
Parenting Children with Attachment Disorders
The psychological adjustment of United States adopted adolescents and their nonadopted siblings.
TLDR
Comparisons were made between adopted adolescents and birth adolescents on the Youth Self-Report, 8 psychological and behavioral adjustment factor scales from the Attitudes and Behaviors survey, and an identity scale and support a body of adoption research that finds a pattern of small but significant differences between adopted and nonadopted persons.
Child Physical and Sexual Abuse: Guidelines for Treatment
The primary purpose of this project was to encourage the use of mental health treatment protocols and procedures that have a sound theoretical basis, a good clinical-anecdotal literature, high
Is the reexperience of painful emotion therapeutic?
Evidence-Based Practice and Policy: Choices Ahead
Choices about how to view evidence-based practice (EBP) are being made by educators, practitioners, agency administrators, and staff in a variety of organizations designed to promote integration of
...
...