Hellenophilia versus the History of Science

@article{Pingree1992HellenophiliaVT,
  title={Hellenophilia versus the History of Science},
  author={David Edwin Pingree},
  journal={Isis},
  year={1992},
  volume={83},
  pages={554 - 563}
}
THE GENESIS OF THIS PAPER lies in a conversation that I had with A. I. Sabra of Harvard on the perennial problem of the definition of science appropriate to a historian of science; its corruption (including the deliberately extreme mode of its expression) is entirely a result of my own labors. For the piece represents the attitudes toward the subject that I have developed over some three and a half decades of studying the history of the "exact" sciences (as 1 will persist in calling them… 

The History of Science and Ancient Mesopotamia

Abstract This paper views the relevance of cuneiform texts to the history of science from inside, i.e., from the perspective of the available sources, as well as from outside, i.e., from the

Ancient Greek Historiography of Science

There is some uncertainty among historians of science as to when the history of science first appeared. Unlike the old historical debate over the origin of mathematics or astronomy, the origin of the

Otto Neugebauer, Historian

Reviewing a recent book in the journal Isis, a historian of modem science felt it necessary, when introducing Otto Neugebauer, to qualify him as "the storied professor of ancient mathematics".1 The

Ancient Greece and the Origins of Science.

This paper was given as a public lecture to open the 2005 Conference of Greek Studies. It presents a case for locating the origins of science with the ancient Greeks. Although this was once a common

Western science, religion and Vietnamese traditional culture: Harmony or antagonism?

The relationship between religion and science has been very diverse and dynamic in the thousands-year-long history of human thoughts, many times seen as the incompatible terms signifying very

The cultures of archaeoastronomy and the history of science†

  • S. McCluskey
  • Physics
    Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union
  • 2011
Abstract This essay draws on the skeptical opinions that some historians of science have of archaeoastronomy, on historians' changing interpretations of proper historical method, and on their varied

Neither Sherlock Holmes nor Babylon: A Reassessment of Plimpton 322

Ancient mathematical texts and artefacts, if we are to understand them fully, must be viewed in the light of their mathematico-historical context, and not treated as artificial, self-contained

Creationism in Antiquity

Natural teleology, associated above all with Aristotle, and dealt with in a separate chapter of this volume, seeks to establish and elucidate the explanatory role of purposive structures and

From Craft to Nature: The Emergence of Natural Teleology

A teleological explanation is an explanation in terms of an end or a purpose. So saying that ‘X came about for the sake of Y’ is a teleological account of X. It is a striking feature of ancient Greek

The Crisis of Kingship in Late Medieval Islam

In the sixteenth century, Muslim rulers of the largest empires of West and South Asia all embraced a new vocabulary of sovereignty that supplemented traditional Perso-Islamic titles and concepts of
...