• DOI:10.1177/0191453708093085
• Corpus ID: 143684323

Harry Frankfurt's metaphysics of care

@article{Jouan2008HarryFM,
  title={Harry Frankfurt's metaphysics of care},
  author={Marl{\`e}ne Jouan},
  journal={Philosophy \& Social Criticism},
  year={2008},
  volume={34},
  pages={759 - 797}
}

• M. Jouan
• Published 1 September 2008
• Philosophy
• Philosophy & Social Criticism

Harry Frankfurt's conception of care and love has largely been considered a seductive theory of personality, but an untenable and irresponsible theory of moral normativity. Contrary to that interpretation, this article aims at showing that it is possible to remain faithful to Frankfurt's metaphysical premises while not falling into some moral relativism. First, by comparing Frankfurt's and Heidegger's conceptions of care, I show that Frankfurt's subordination of ethics to carology apparently commits him to a neutral foundationalism. In the next step, I argue that his calling into question of the relation between rationality and morality does indeed subject moral normativity to some subjective and contingent limits. And finally, I show that the objections raised against such a conclusion can be answered by shifting Frankfurt's frontier between contingency and necessity and by exploiting his concept of wholeheartedness.