Handling conflict between domain descriptions with computer-supported negotiation

  title={Handling conflict between domain descriptions with computer-supported negotiation},
  author={Steve M. Easterbrook},
  journal={Knowledge Acquisition},
  • S. Easterbrook
  • Published 1 September 1991
  • Computer Science
  • Knowledge Acquisition

Figures and Tables from this paper

Conflict Analysis and Information Systems: A Rough Set Approach
A rough set based requirements determination model using a conflict relation for representing requirements agreements (or disagreements) in high-level requirements negotiation for an automated lighting system is presented.
An empirical approach toward the resolution of conflicts in goal-oriented models
This paper proposes a novel approach to validate models in the Goal-oriented Requirement Language and resolve conflicts between the perspectives of intervening stakeholders (and especially between stakeholders of a given group).
Approaches to Conflict Dynamics Based on Rough Sets
Several approaches to the analysis of conflicts situations are presented in this paper, namely, conflict graphs, approximation spaces and risk patterns, a rough set-based requirements scope determination model and assessment mechanisms using a complex conflict model.
Negotiation in the Requirements Elicitation and Analysis Process
  • Sabrina Ahmad
  • Engineering
    19th Australian Conference on Software Engineering (aswec 2008)
  • 2008
This paper considers introducing negotiation spiral model with supporting elements in the requirements elicitation and analysis process, which has advantages of well aligned requirements by all the stakeholders, improved system quality, a sound basis for resource estimation and less resource wastage.
Conflict identification and resolution for software attribute requirements
  • H. In
  • Computer Science
  • 1998
Two prototype support tools are developed, QARCC and S-COST, which expand the capabilities of the WinWin system and evaluate the theories, models, and tools with the results of WinWin negotiations, such as the CS577 15-project samples.
Domain modelling with hierarchies of alternative viewpoints
  • S. Easterbrook
  • Computer Science
    [1993] Proceedings of the IEEE International Symposium on Requirements Engineering
  • 1993
It is shown how domain modelling can be used within requirements engineering to reveal the conceptual models used by the participants, and relate these to one another. Existing elicitation techniques
Requirements Negotiation Using Multi-Criteria Preference Analysis
The MPARN model assisted stakeholders to have unbiased aspects within a requirements negotiation in a light-weighted way and increase stakeholders' levels of cooperation and trust by measuring each stakeholder's preference and value function explicitly through a step-by-step process.
Negotiation support for compiling knowledge
This work proposes a collaborative development environment for supporting domain experts in constructing design-oriented critiquing systems and expects to improve and to ensure the knowledge base's quality by supporting information exchange and negotiation processes between domain experts.
Generalized Conflict and Resolution Model with Approximation Spaces
A rough set based requirements scope determination model using a generalized conflict model with approximation spaces is presented, helpful in analyzing and resolving conflict in disputes in both government and industry.
Negotiation and the Role of the Requirements Specification 1
This chapter argues that the problems of requirements engineering deserve greater study, and considers the role of the specification in the software engineering process, and describes issues which must be addressed during specification construction.


Resolving Goal Conflicts via Negotiation
This work provides a model of goal conflict resolution through negotiation implemented in the PERSUADER, a program that resolves labor disputes by integrating case-Based Reasoning with the use of multi-attribute utilities to portray tradeoffs and propose novel goal relaxations and compromises.
Synview: the design of a system for cooperative structuring of information
  • D. Lowe
  • Computer Science
    CSCW '86
  • 1986
The original design of the SYNVIEW system is reviewed, ways to interface to existing information in the form of traditional documents are examined, and simplifications to the debate representation that reduce the amount of effort required to enter information are described.
The Resolution of Conflict
SUMMARY The paper deals with the resolution of conflict by bargaining, a term which is defined broadly. It is more concerned with the actual results of bargains than "fair" results, and discusses
Rational interaction: cooperation among intelligent agents
This dissertation describes a framework for interacting intelligent agents, and explores strategies of interaction among intelligent agents using a formalism that removes some serious restrictions that underlie previous research in distributed artificial intelligence.
Viewpoint Oriented Software Development: Mehtods and Viewpoints in Requirements Engineering
A central thread in this work the -concept of "ViewPoint"- is examined, motivated and systematically characterised, and the implications for methods to support the construction of formal specifications are considered.
Design rationale and maintainability
  • J. Conklin
  • Computer Science
    [1989] Proceedings of the Twenty-Second Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences. Volume II: Software Track
  • 1989
An approach is proposed for capturing this process-oriented material during development, indexed so that it provides this critical information to maintainers during development.
A field study of the software design process for large systems
A layered behavioral model is used to analyze how three of these problems—the thin spread of application domain knowledge, fluctuating and conflicting requirements, and communication bottlenecks and breakdowns—affected software productivity and quality through their impact on cognitive, social, and organizational processes.
A proposed perspective shift: viewing specification design as a planning problem
This paper argues that with the right perspective and set of assumptions, work in AI planning may be brought to bear on three aspects of designing a software specification: proposing a specification (generation); analyzing a proposed specification for problems (critiquing); and modifying a specification to mitigate problems (elaboration).
Beyond the chalkboard: computer support for collaboration and problem solving in meetings
An experimental meeting room called the Colab has been created at Xerox PARC to study computer support of collaborative problem solving in face-to-face meetings, with the long-term goal to understand how to build computer tools to make meetings more effective.
Discussions and Reviews : Models of cooperation and conflict: a critical review
tures of the situation (e.g., relative power, conflict of interest, communication channels); various characteristics of the parties (e.g., ideology, motives, group decision-making processes);