Group critical incident stress debriefing with emergency services personnel: a randomized controlled trial

@article{Tuckey2014GroupCI,
  title={Group critical incident stress debriefing with emergency services personnel: a randomized controlled trial},
  author={Michelle R. Tuckey and Jill Scott},
  journal={Anxiety, Stress \& Coping},
  year={2014},
  volume={27},
  pages={38 - 54}
}
Although single-session individual debriefing is contraindicated, the efficacy of group psychological debriefing remains unresolved. We conducted the first randomized controlled trial of critical incident stress debriefing (CISD) with emergency workers (67 volunteer fire-fighters) following shared exposure to an occupational potentially traumatic event (PTE). The goals of group CISD are to prevent post-traumatic stress and promote return to normal functioning following a PTE. To assess both… 

Was Psychological Debriefing Dismissed Too Quickly? An Assessment of the 2002 Cochrane Review

Emergency personnel and first responders are often exposed to potentially traumatic incidents which can increase the risk of acute stress reactions and ultimately post-traumatic stress symptoms.

De-stressing From Distress

TLDR
Results show that members of an interdisciplinary team will engage in a brief (∼10 minute) nurse-led debriefing program when offered the opportunity to do so, and that this intervention was successful beyond the acute care unit where it originated.

Evaluating the effectiveness of a group-based resilience intervention versus psychoeducation for emergency responders in England: A randomised controlled trial

TLDR
The limited success of this intervention is consistent with the wider literature and future refinements to the intervention may benefit from targeting predictors of resilience and mental ill health.

The Primary Prevention of PTSD in Firefighters: Preliminary Results of an RCT with 12-Month Follow-Up

TLDR
This study is the first randomised control trial investigating the primary prevention of PTSD and found no evidence that the intervention was effective in the primary Prevention of mental health issues, nor did it find any significant impact of MAPS training on social support or coping strategies.

Early Psychological Preventive Intervention For Workplace Violence: A Randomized Controlled Explorative and Comparative Study Between EMDR-Recent Event and Critical Incident Stress Debriefing

TLDR
Investigation of the efficacy of an early psychological intervention called EMDR-RE compared to Critical Incident Stress Debriefing on 60 victims of workplace violence showed that after 3 months PCLS and SUDS scores were significantly lower with EM DR-RE and delayed EMDRs compared to CISD.

The effect of post-incident discussion on psychological wellbeing and memory integrity

As a consequence of their work, emergency service personnel, such as fire-fighters, police officers and paramedics are frequently exposed to traumatic events. This can result in an elevated risk of

Peer Support and Crisis-Focused Psychological Interventions Designed to Mitigate Post-Traumatic Stress Injuries among Public Safety and Frontline Healthcare Personnel: A Systematic Review

TLDR
A systematic review synthesized and appraised recent empirical research from 22 electronic databases following a population–intervention–comparison–outcome framework to find effectiveness evidence for organizational post-exposure PTSI mitigation services remains lacking.

Coping among public safety personnel: A systematic review and meta–analysis

TLDR
The current findings can inform the development and evaluation of organizational training programs that effectively promote sustained adaptive coping for PSP and mitigate PTSIs.
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 50 REFERENCES

Firefighter preferences regarding post-incident intervention

Abstract The effectiveness of Critical Incident Stress Debriefing (CISD) as a tool remains, at best, inconclusive. Yet in many locales CISD is mandatory for emergency services workers, including

Commentary: Evaluating Psychological Debriefing: Are we Measuring the Right Outcomes?

TLDR
The findings of this study suggest that that it is premature to conclude thatdebriefing is ineffective and that a broader range of outcome measures should be employed in future trials of debriefing.

Brief psychological interventions ("debriefing") for trauma-related symptoms and the prevention of post traumatic stress disorder.

TLDR
There is no current evidence that psychological debriefing is a useful treatment for the prevention of post traumatic stress disorder after traumatic incidents and compulsorydebriefing of victims of trauma should cease.

A group randomized trial of critical incident stress debriefing provided to U.S. peacekeepers.

TLDR
For those soldiers reporting the highest degree of exposure to mission stressors, CISD was minimally associated with lower reports of posttraumatic stress and aggression, higher perceived organizational support, and more alcohol problems than SMC and SO.

Emergency response service personnel and the critical incident stress debriefing debate.

  • S. Wagner
  • Psychology
    International journal of emergency mental health
  • 2005
TLDR
It is concluded that at this time, for this population, the call for the removal of current programs using CISD is unwarranted and the available literature regarding the effectiveness of CISD for use with emergency service workers is reviewed.

Early intervention for trauma: Current status and future directions.

Although psychological debriefing (PD) represents the most common form of early intervention for recently traumatized people, there is little evidence supporting its continued use with individuals

To debrief or not to debrief our heroes: that is the question.

TLDR
This paper argues that there are at least three reasons for the apparent failure of 'debriefing' in the two studies that reported adverse effects, and calls for reviewers to recognize the limitations of debriefing research and not to overgeneralize their conclusions.

Psychological debriefing and the workplace: defining a concept, controversies and guidelines for intervention

Critical incident stress debriefing (CISD), a specific form of psychological debriefing, has gained widespread acceptance and implementation in the few short years since it was first proposed

Battlemind debriefing and battlemind training as early interventions with soldiers returning from iraq: Randomization by platoon.

TLDR
Compared to stress education participants, large group Battlemind training participants with high combat exposure reported fewer posttraumatic stress symptoms and lower levels of stigma and, regardless of combat exposure, reported fewer depression symptoms.