Good, Actually: Aristotelian Metaphysics and the ‘Guise of the Good’

@article{Willows2022GoodAA,
  title={Good, Actually: Aristotelian Metaphysics and the ‘Guise of the Good’},
  author={Adam M. Willows},
  journal={Philosophy},
  year={2022},
  volume={97},
  pages={187 - 205}
}
Abstract In this paper I argue that both defence and criticism of the claim that humans act ‘under the guise of the good’ neglects the metaphysical roots of the theory. I begin with an overview of the theory and its modern commentators, with critics noting the apparent possibility of acting against the good, and supporters claiming that such actions are instances of error. These debates reduce the ‘guise of the good’ to a claim about intention and moral action, and in so doing have become… 

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 36 REFERENCES

The metaphysics of goodness in the ethics of Aristotle

Kraut (Against absolute goodness. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2011) and other neo-Aristotelians have argued that there is no such thing as absolute goodness. They admit only good in a kind, e.g.

Aristotle's Agathon

THERE ARE ANY NUMBER OF REASONS for wanting to know what Aristotle means by "good" ([TEXT NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ASCII.]). For students of Aristotle, understanding his conception of goodness would

The Eudemian Ethics

  • C. Rowe
  • Philosophy
    The Classical Review
  • 1983
of what he knows is specifiable in some set of such sentences. To the possible objection that the set of such sentences must be infinite it is sufficient to reply that the fact that there are

The Guise of the Good

The agent portrayed in much philosophy of action is, let's face it, a square. He does nothing intentionally unless he regards it or its consequences as desirable. The reason is that he acts

Aristotle's Definition of Motion

It 4T otion," says Aristotle, "is the actualization of what potentially is, as such 'ro5 8uvu4a Ovroq E'vreXiXec, a 'rTOLi:irov."' If we are to believe Aristotle, this definition speaks to a problem

Aiming at the good

  • A. Saemi
  • Philosophy
    Canadian Journal of Philosophy
  • 2015
This paper shows how we can plausibly extend the guise of the good thesis in a way that avoids intellectualist challenge, allows animals to be included, and is consistent with the possibility of

Shared Intention

In Choice: The Essential Element in Human Action Alan Donagan argued for the importance of "will" to our shared understanding of intelligent action.1 By "will" Donagan meant a complex of capacities

THE NICOMACHEAN ETHICS

This revised translation of Aristotle's classic treatise contains ten books based on the famous doctrine of the golden mean which advocates taking the middle course between excess and deficiency.

A Treatise of Human Nature

PART 1: INTRODUCTORY MATERIAL. How to Use this Book. List of Abbreviations. Editor's Introduction. Hume's Early years and Education. A Treatise of Human Nature. Book 1: Of the Understanding. Book 1

Commentary on Aristotle's de Anima

"This translation is an important research tool for all philosophers interested in Aquinas's philosophy of mind and epistemology...Every library of both undergraduate and graduate philosophy programs