Giving Birth to Empathy: The Effects of Similar Experience on Empathic Accuracy, Empathic Concern, and Perceived Empathy

@article{Hodges2010GivingBT,
  title={Giving Birth to Empathy: The Effects of Similar Experience on Empathic Accuracy, Empathic Concern, and Perceived Empathy},
  author={Sara D. Hodges and Kristi J. Kiel and Adam D. I. Kramer and Darya Veach and B. Renee Villanueva},
  journal={Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin},
  year={2010},
  volume={36},
  pages={398 - 409}
}
This study examined how having had a similar experience to a target person’s experience affected three facets of empathy: empathic concern, empathic accuracy, and perceived empathy. Women who had never been mothers, who were pregnant with their first child, or who had just given birth to their first child (20 in each group) served as perceivers, watching videotapes of new-mother targets (N = 20) and providing measures of emotional and cognitive empathy. When perceivers had experienced the same… 

Figures from this paper

Devil in the Details: Effects of Depression on the Prosocial Response Depend on Timing and Similarity
Most accounts of empathy acknowledge the importance of shared experience, but debate continues regarding the precise mechanism and necessity of similarity for an empathic response. The
The relationship between empathic concern and perceived personal costs for helping and how it is affected by similarity perceptions
  • B. Siem
  • Psychology
    The Journal of social psychology
  • 2021
TLDR
Results from an experiment supported assumptions that self-focused feelings of personal distress were a positive predictor of perceived costs and showed the strength of the negative relationship between empathic concern and personal costs depends on two forms of perceived similarity between the helper and the target, person similarity and experience similarity.
Young adults’ empathic responses to others in psychological pain as compared to physical pain: does prior experience of pain matter?
Previous studies have demonstrated a link between prior experience of physical pain and empathic response within similar settings. However, much less is known about emotional hurt derived from
What really helps? Divergent implications of talking to someone with an empathic mindset versus similar experience for shame and self-evaluation in the wake of an embarrassing event.
TLDR
Perceivers' dispositional empathy, involving a different type of experience accumulated over time, also predicted benefits to targets, and perceiver experience over empathic concern in facilitating targets' recovery from embarrassing events was suggested.
Employed Carers’ Empathy Towards People with Intellectual Disabilities: The Development of a New Measure and Some Initial Theory
TLDR
The most salient processes in empathizing with people with intellectual disabilities may be different from empathy in other contexts, and establishing determinants of carer empathy may facilitate the development of psychological interventions to promote and enhance this important quality.
Accurate empathy of romantic partners increases pain ratings but promotes recovery
TLDR
Investigating how perceived empathy and relationship type interact with the subjective perception of pain and objective measures of recovery time suggests that perceived accurate empathy is necessary for romantic relationships when coping with pain.
Knowing What Others Think and Feel: Empathic Accuracy Across Adulthood
Empathic accuracy is the ability to infer another person's inner states. While early findings suggested older adults to be less empathically accurate on average than younger individuals, the context
The Relationship between Evaluation of Empathized Events and Perceived Empathy
In this study, we examined the relationship between perceived empathy and the strength of the empathized event (i.e., the extent to which the event was evaluated to be delightful). We analyzed
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 47 REFERENCES
"I've Been there, Too": Effect on Empathy of Prior Experience with a Need
TLDR
Prior experience with the need increased empathy among women but not among men, while reading a transcript in which a same-sex adolescent described an upsetting life experience decreased empathy among men.
Sex Differences in Empathy and Related Capacities
In this article, the literature on sex differences in empathy (denned as vicarious affective responding to the emotional state of another) and related capacities (affective role taking and decoding
Empathy with a Rape Victim: The Role of Similarity of Experience
TLDR
Women who were identified as having been raped rated themselves as more empathic with, and more similar to, a rape victim patient presented on videotape than did nonrape control subjects who had been matched on level of dispositional empathy.
Exploratory Investigations of Empathy1
Measuring individual differences in empathy: Evidence for a multidimensional approach.
To facilitate a multidimensional approach to empathy the Interpersonal Reactivity Index (IRI) includes 4 subscales: Perspective-Taking (PT) Fantasy (FS) Empathic Concern (EC) and Personal Distress
Distress and empathy: two qualitatively distinct vicarious emotions with different motivational consequences.
TLDR
The recent empirical evidence appears to support the more differentiated view of emotion and motivation proposed long ago by McDougall, not the unitary view proposed by Hull and his followers.
Gender differences in empathic accuracy: Differential ability or differential motivation?
Following their qualitative review of the findings from 10 relevant studies, Graham and Ickes (1997) speculated that reliable gender-of-perceiver differences in empathic accuracy (a) were limited to
Gender Roles and Empathic Accuracy: The Role of Communion in Reading Minds
Although empathic accuracy is considered a stable skill, few individual difference measures consistently predict performance on Ickes’ (e.g., 2001) empathic accuracy measure. Because past work has
The current state of empathy research
The literature on empathy, primarily from counseling and psychotherapy and secondarily from social and developmental psychology, is reviewed. Obstacles that may account for theoretical confusions and
Making It Up and Making Do: Simulation, Imagination, and Empathic Accuracy
How many times have you had a conversation with someone, only to ask yourself as you were leaving, “What was she thinking?!” Researchers have also asked this question, and the last 20 years in
...
...