Genomic data do not support comb jellies as the sister group to all other animals

@article{Pisani2015GenomicDD,
  title={Genomic data do not support comb jellies as the sister group to all other animals},
  author={Davide Pisani and Walker Pett and Martin Dohrmann and Roberto Feuda and Omar Rota-Stabelli and Herv{\'e} Philippe and Nicolas Lartillot and Gert W{\"o}rheide},
  journal={Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year={2015},
  volume={112},
  pages={15402 - 15407}
}
Significance Clarifying the phylogeny of animals is fundamental to understanding their evolution. Traditionally, sponges have been considered the sister group of all other extant animals, but recent genomic studies have suggested comb jellies occupy that position instead. Here, we analyzed the current genomic evidence from comb jellies and found no convincing support for this hypothesis. Instead, when analyzed with appropriate methods, recent genomic data support the traditional hypothesis. We… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Evidence for sponges as sister to all other animals from partitioned phylogenomics with mixture models and recoding
TLDR
It is shown that incorporating site-heterogeneous mixture models and recoding into partitioned phylogenomics alleviates systematic errors that hamper commonly-applied phylogenetic models and improves model-fit that attenuates branching artefacts induced by systematic error.
Improved resolution of recalcitrant nodes in the animal phylogeny through the analysis of genome gene content and morphology
TLDR
The last common animal ancestor may has been a simple, filter-feeding organism without a nervous system and muscles, while the last common ancestor of Bilateria might have been a small, acoelomate-like worm without a through gut.
Embracing Uncertainty in Reconstructing Early Animal Evolution
Improved Modeling of Compositional Heterogeneity Supports Sponges as Sister to All Other Animals
Revisiting metazoan phylogeny with genomic sampling of all phyla
TLDR
The first attempt to investigate animal relationships using genome-scale data from all phyla is presented, and matrix construction with an eye towards testing specific relationships is explored, showing that Lophotrochozoa can be constructed in strongly conflicting ways using different taxon- and/or orthologue sets.
Support for a clade of Placozoa and Cnidaria in genes with minimal compositional bias
TLDR
This work examines the influence of adding new genomes from placozoans to a large dataset designed to study the deepest splits in the animal phylogeny, and demonstrates that a majority of genes show evidence of compositional heterogeneity, and that support for the Cnidaria + Bilateria clade can be assigned to this source of systematic error.
Placozoa and Cnidaria are sister taxa
TLDR
This work examines the influence of adding new genomes from placozoans to a large dataset designed to study the deepest splits in the animal phylogeny, and demonstrates that a majority of genes show evidence of compositional heterogeneity, and that the support for Planulozoa can be assigned to this source of systematic error.
A Screen for Gene Paralogies Delineating Evolutionary Branching Order of Early Metazoa
TLDR
A comparative phylogenetic approach based on gene duplications is described, which computationally identify and analyze gene families with early metazoan duplications using an approach that mitigates apparent gene loss resulting from the miscalling of paralogs.
Very few sites can reshape a phylogenetic tree
TLDR
It is demonstrated that by removing a small fraction of sites that strongly favor one topology, it is possible to produce a highly-supported tree of an alternate topology.
The role of homology and orthology in the phylogenomic analysis of metazoan gene content
TLDR
It is concluded that the placement of deeply-diverging lineages, like ctenophores, may exceed the limit of resolution afforded by methods based on comparisons of orthologous protein supermatrices, and novel approaches are required to fully capture the evolutionary signal from genes within genomes.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 66 REFERENCES
Error, signal, and the placement of Ctenophora sister to all other animals
TLDR
Investigating possible causes of systematic error by expanding taxon sampling with eight novel transcriptomes, strictly enforcing orthology inference criteria, and progressively examining potential causes of systemic error while using both maximum-likelihood with robust data partitioning and Bayesian inference with a site-heterogeneous model finds a single, statistically robust placement of ctenophores as the authors' most distant animal relatives.
Additional molecular support for the new chordate phylogeny
TLDR
Maximum‐likelihood using standard models and Bayesian phylogenetic analyses using the CAT site‐heterogeneous mixture model of amino‐acid replacement both provided unequivocal support for the sister‐group relationship between tunicates and vertebrates (Olfactores).
Animal Phylogeny and Its Evolutionary Implications
TLDR
There is far more homoplasy for all these characters than had previously been anticipated, even among many complex characters such as segmentation and nervous systems, which has important implications for the understanding of the evolution of development, morphology, genomes, and other characters.
Broad phylogenomic sampling improves resolution of the animal tree of life
TLDR
This data reinforce several previously identified clades that split deeply in the animal tree, unambiguously resolve multiple long-standing issues for which there was strong conflicting support in earlier studies with less data, and provide molecular support for the monophyly of molluscs, a group long recognized by morphologists.
Improved Phylogenomic Taxon Sampling Noticeably Affects Nonbilaterian Relationships
TLDR
This work recovers monophyletic Porifera as the sister group to all other Metazoa and suggests that the basal position of the fast-evolving Ctenophora proposed by Dunn et al. was due to LBA and that broad taxon sampling is of fundamental importance to metazoan phylogenomic analyses.
Novel scenarios of early animal evolution--is it time to rewrite textbooks?
TLDR
It is concluded that the time is not yet ripe to rewrite zoological textbooks and advocate a conservative approach when it comes to developing scenarios of the early evolution of animals.
Deep Genomic-Scale Analyses of the Metazoa Reject Coelomata: Evidence from Single- and Multigene Families Analyzed Under a Supertree and Supermatrix Paradigm
TLDR
It is shown that optimal outgroup selection is key in avoiding LBA and the use of inadequate outgroups as the reason previous deep genomic-scale analyses found strong support for Coelomata.
The phylogenetic position of ctenophores and the origin(s) of nervous systems
TLDR
It is argued that characters like neuropeptide signaling, ciliary photoreceptors, gap junctions and presynaptic molecules are consistent with a shared ancestry of nervous systems, however, that phylogenetic-tree construction artifacts may have placed ctenophores too deep in the metazoan tree.
Phylogenomic Insights into Animal Evolution
...
...