Generalising the Hit Rates Test for Racial Bias in Law Enforcement, with an Application to Vehicle Searches in Wichita

  title={Generalising the Hit Rates Test for Racial Bias in Law Enforcement, with an Application to Vehicle Searches in Wichita},
  author={Nicola Persico and Petra E. Todd},
  journal={Wiley-Blackwell: Economic Journal},
  • N. Persico, P. Todd
  • Published 1 November 2006
  • Psychology
  • Wiley-Blackwell: Economic Journal
This article considers the use of outcomes-based tests for detecting racial bias in the context of police searches of motor vehicles. We characterise the police and motorist decision problems in a game theoretic framework, where police encounter motorists and decide whether to search them and motorists decide whether to carry contraband. Our modelling framework generalises that of Knowles et al. (2001). We apply the tests to data on police searches of motor vehicles gathered by the Wichita… 
The Hit Rates Test for Racial Bias in Motor‐Vehicle Searches
This paper exposits a rational choice model of police–motorist interactions originally developed in Knowles, Persico, and Todd (Knowles, J., Persico, N., & Todd, P. [2001]. Racial bias in motor
The Decision to Search
This manuscript examines police officer decision making during automobile stops to determine whether Black and Hispanic drivers are searched at parity with nonminorities, with particular focus on
Learning by Doing in Law Enforcement
This study examines task-specific learning by police officers. Using data on twenty million traffic stops, I show that rookie officers become significantly more likely to find contraband as they
Deterrence Externalities and Racial Bias in Law Enforcement
Knowles, Persico, and Todd (2001) develop a test for racial bias in traffic stops that is predicated on the notion that it is the hit rate—the rate at which motor-vehicle searches result in the
Reconsidering Racial Bias in Motor Vehicle Searches: Theory and Evidence
Knowles, Persico, and Todd (2001) present a model of police and motorist behavior in the context of vehicle searches and test it using data from Maryland. Their work marked a resurgence in interest
Methods for Assessing Racially Biased Policing
As part of the response to allegations of racially biased police practices many police agencies began collecting information on the stops made by their officers. Social scientists have attempted to
A New Look at Racial Profiling: Evidence from the Boston Police Department
This paper provides new evidence on racial profiling using information on the race of both motorists and officers. Extending the model of Knowles, Persico, and Todd (2001), we develop a new test for
Police Bias in the Enforcement of Drug Crimes: Evidence from Low Priority Laws
We consider the impact of adoption of a low priority initiative in some jurisdictions within Los Angeles County on police behavior. Low priority initiatives instruct police to make the enforcement of
Do Police Maximize Arrests or Minimize Crime? Evidence from Racial Profiling in U.S. Cities
It is difficult to know if racial discrepancies in police stop and search data are caused by racial bias or statistical discrimination. In part, this is due to uncertainty over the benchmark of
Are Police Racially Biased in the Decision to Shoot?∗
Racial disparities in police use of force are common in the United States and may be widest for Black Americans relative to other racial groups. Determining racial bias as the cause of such


Racial Bias in Motor Vehicle Searches: Theory and Evidence
Police checking for illegal drugs are much more likely to search the vehicles of African‐American motorists than those of white motorists. This paper develops a model of police and motorist behavior
Racial Bias in Motor Vehicle Searches: Additional Theory and Evidence
Knowles, Persico, and Todd (2001) develop a model of police search and offender behavior. Their model implies that if police are unprejudiced the rate of guilt should not vary across groups. Using
Crime Minimisation and Racial Bias: What Can We Learn from Police Search Data?
It is shown that the basic idea of extracting information from hit rates may still be valid, provided one can verify some simple restrictions on the joint distribution of criminality by race.
Can Racially Unbiased Police Perpetuate Long-Run Discrimination?
We develop a stylized dynamic model of highway policing in which a non-racist police officer exhibits a cognitive bias: relative overconfidence. The officer is given incentives to arrest criminals
Crime Minimization and Racial Bias: What Can We Learn from Police Search Data?
Are variations in the success rate of searches by race informative about racial bias if police are motivated by crime minimization rather than success-rate maximization? We show that the basic idea
Driving While Different: A Potential Theoretical Explanation for Race-Based Policing
During the first 6 months of 2001, the Wichita (Kansas) Police Department collected information on 37,454 stops conducted by its employees. The initial analysis of these data indicates a substantial
Racial Profiling, Fairness, and Effectiveness of Policing
Citizens of two groups may engage in crime, depending on their legal earning opportunities and on the probability of being audited. Police audit citizens. Police behavior is fair if both groups are
! This Interim Report is limited to the examination of the practice commonly referred to as “racial profiling.” The Report specifically focuses on activities of state troopers assigned to patrol the
Rethinking Racial Profiling: A Critique of the Economics, Civil Liberties, and Constitutional Literature, and of Criminal Profiling More Generally
New data on highway stops and searches from across the country have spawned renewed debate over racial profiling on the roads. The new data reveal consistently disproportionate searches of minority
Assessing Racial Profiling
In this article I consider the evaluation of racial profiling in traffic stops from a combination of welfarist and non-welfarist considerations. I argue that benefits from profiling in terms of crime