General covariance and the foundations of general relativity: eight decades of dispute

@article{Norton1993GeneralCA,
  title={General covariance and the foundations of general relativity: eight decades of dispute},
  author={J D Norton},
  journal={Reports on Progress in Physics},
  year={1993},
  volume={56},
  pages={791 - 858},
  url={https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:250902085}
}
  • J D Norton
  • Published 1993
  • Physics, Philosophy
  • Reports on Progress in Physics
Einstein offered the principle of general covariance as the fundamental physical principle of his general theory of relativity and as responsible for extending the principle of relativity to accelerated motion. This view was disputed almost immediately with the counter-claim that the principle was no relativity principle and was physically vacuous. The disagreement persists today. This article reviews the development of Einstein's thought on general covariance, its relation to the foundations… 

Einstein's gravitation is Einstein-Grossmann's equations

While the philosophers of science discuss the General Relativity, the mathematical physicists do not question it. Therefore, there is a conflict. From the theoretical point view “the question of

Relationalism vs. Bayesianism

We compare and contrast the basic principles of two philosophies: Bayesianism and relationalism. These two philosophies are both based upon criteria of rationality. The analogy invoked in such a

Physics Tomorrow: New Cosmology and Gravitation in Modern Physics

In this work, we present a new Cosmology of the Grand Universe, which is a relativistic model of the steady-state, matter-antimatter symmetric Universe in infinite space-time. The Grand Universe

General Covariance and the Objectivity of Space-time Point-events

"The last remnant of physical objectivity of space-time" is disclosed, beyond the Leibniz equivalence, in the case of a continuous family of spatially non-compact models of general relativity. The

Quantum Gravity: Has Spacetime Quantum Properties?

The incompatibility between GR and QM is generally seen as a sufficient motivation for the development of a theory of Quantum Gravity. If - so a typical argumentation - QM gives a universally valid

An information theory interpretation of relativistic phenomena

Analysis of the evolution of optical and electromagnetic theorizing is suggested to demonstrate that the choice of a mechanically compatible model of electromagnetic radiation, as has conventionally underwritten development of the light-speed postulate of special relativity, is inappropriate.

Teaching cosmology with special relativity: piecewise inertial frames as a model for cosmic expansion

This article presents a simple model that reproduces key concepts of modern cosmology within the framework of special relativity, at a level that is suitable for an undergraduate or high school

Operational General Relativity: Possibilistic, Probabilistic, and Quantum

In this paper we develop an operational formulation of General Relativity similar in spirit to existing operational formulations of Quantum Theory. To do this we introduce an operational space (or

Chasing individuation : mathematical description of physical systems

This work is a conceptual analysis of certain recent developments in the mathematical foundations of Classical and Quantum Mechanics which have allowed to formulate both theories in a common